Banter Carlton is better in 2024. Who will be better in 2025? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3

Banter threads are not to be taken too seriously. Have fun. Let others have fun.

Who will be better in 2025

  • Carlton

  • Collingwood


Results are only viewable after voting.

Remove this Banner Ad

Sorry, I forgot about Cowan.

Why would any club want a Houston when they've already got a Cowan?

Crazy how Houston has become the best HBF since Andy McLeod, instantly launching any club who grabs him into flag contention.

He’s been with port for 10 years & just won 2 AA’s with then and they’ve served up the same shit.
 
Crazy how Houston has become the best HBF since Andy McLeod, instantly launching any club who grabs him into flag contention.

He’s been with port for 10 years & just won 2 AA’s with then and they’ve served up the same shit.
Houston's no good because Port have 'served up the same shit' - 3 times as many Preliminary Finals as Carlton have played in the same time with the likes of Cripps, Weitering, Curnow and McKay.

Where does it leave those guys?
 
Houston's no good because Port have 'served up the same shit' - 3 times as many Preliminary Finals as Carlton have played in the same time with the likes of Cripps, Weitering, Curnow and McKay.

Where does it leave those guys?

He’s a good player. But the absolute circle jerk happening for a half back flanker is stupid.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Is there a bigger circle jerk than blues faithful yelling "woof" when Saad kicks the ball 30m sideways?

Come on, you’re posting this as a supporter of the club that has:

  • Joffa putting on a jacket
  • Chanting ‘USA! USA! USA!’ despite watching an Australian sport in Australia
  • The cringe ‘Collingwood’ long chant that sounds like a Sunday football league chant gone wrong.
 
Crazy how Houston has become the best HBF since Andy McLeod, instantly launching any club who grabs him into flag contention.

He’s been with port for 10 years & just won 2 AA’s with then and they’ve served up the same shit.
Yeah, he’s joining a club that knows what it takes to win a flag. I suppose that’s why he chose Collingwood over Carlton.
 
Saad does a 10m sideways chip kick, the umpire calls play on.
Carlton fans: Woof!!...
C'mon, admit it's embarrassing.
When have the Collingwood fans chanted 'USA, USA, USA'?

His 3 goal quarters in knockout Finals.

His lap of honour as a premiership player.

A little more well deserved than a 10m sideways chip kick.
 
When have the Collingwood fans chanted 'USA, USA, USA'?

His 3 goal quarters in knockout Finals.

His lap of honour as a premiership player.

A little more well deserved than a 10m sideways chip kick.
I reckon we should chant MEOW every time they go woof!

Be good to get some chants for Carlton games. I wish it was part of AFL like it is for Premier league crowds.
Noooooo Show Cuuuuurrrnow Noooooo Show Cuuuuuuuurrrrrrnow.

Hello darkness your old friend....you've gone and shit the bed again.

Bloooooozzzzers Bloooooozers

Walking along, singing a song
Walking in a Daicos wonderland.
You are....Nicky Daicos
You are .... Nicky Daicos
Walking along singing a song
Walking in a Daicos wonderland..
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

I reckon we should chant MEOW every time they go woof!

Be good to get some chants for Carlton games. I wish it was part of AFL like it is for Premier league crowds.
Noooooo Show Cuuuuurrrnow Noooooo Show Cuuuuuuuurrrrrrnow.

Hello darkness your old friend....you've gone and shit the bed again.

Bloooooozzzzers Bloooooozers

Walking along, singing a song
Walking in a Daicos wonderland.
You are....Nicky Daicos
You are .... Nicky Daicos
Walking along singing a song
Walking in a Daicos wonderland..

yeah wow this some serious lame boomer type joke stuff.

you gunna write a funny poem next?

yuck.
 
He’s a good player. But the absolute circle jerk happening for a half back flanker is stupid.
Just because Saad and Williams didn’t get you anywhere, doesn’t mean Houston won’t get us anywhere. The key difference is Houston can hit a target consistently. That’s why he’s so highly rated.

But Carlton supporters only believe big bodied midfielders and tall forwards matter, despite the game changing to value speed, fast ball movement and precision kicking
 
Just because Saad and Williams didn’t get you anywhere, doesn’t mean Houston won’t get us anywhere. The key difference is Houston can hit a target consistently. That’s why he’s so highly rated.

But Carlton supporters only believe big bodied midfielders and tall forwards matter, despite the game changing to value speed, fast ball movement and precision kicking
Wow. Afl website has Houston 82.1% efficiency and Saad 82.7%.

On SM-G980F using BigFooty.com mobile app
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Banter Carlton is better in 2024. Who will be better in 2025? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3

Back
Top