Banter Carlton is better in 2024. Who will be better in 2025? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3

[Worm4]

Are you trying to argue against the fact Carlton's list has gone backwards?

I'm arguing that you are no good at making predictions on Carltons finishing position, particularly last year and the year before that.
Who takes you seriously around here apart from your soggy biscuit brigade ?

 

[Robertio]

It's been happening for 25 years and counting, why would it change?

But it's not even really about that.

Carlton have their salary cap bursting at the seams, and they are still yet to contend for a premiership.

So you are in no position to quickly improve your list (you have actually gone backwards this off season), and to simply don't have the list profile and balance to contend for a premiership.

Oh well, let's hope the next rebuild produces a better result...

You have no idea on the salary cap.

 

[Fadge]

You have no idea on the salary cap.

Carlton's handling of Houston gave us a very good idea...

 

[Robertio]

Carlton's handling of Houston gave us a very good idea...

They didn't want to pay for a back flanker and they handled it perfectly.

 

[Fadge]

I'm arguing that you are no good at making predictions on Carltons finishing position, particularly last year and the year before that.
Who takes you seriously around here apart from your soggy biscuit brigade ?

You sound a bit angry.

Calm down, it's only a game.

 

[Worm4]

Carlton simply don't have the list profile and balance to contend for a premiership.

Lol, what's the list profile and balance requirements?
list management guru - go

 

[Fadge]

They didn't want to pay for a back flanker and they handled it perfectly.

You keep telling yourself that...

 

[Fadge]

Lol, what's the list profile and balance requirements?
list management guru - go

Do I really need to repeat myself for the 16th time?

 

[Robertio]

You keep telling yourself that...

Nah i was telling you mate, pick 3 in a superdraft or a 29 year old half back flanker, only Pies fans would go for the latter.

 

[Ctracks]

Nah i was telling you mate, pick 3 in a superdraft or a 29 year old half back flanker, only Pies fans would go for the latter.

Are you sure Dan is 29....maybe he is 37?

 

[Fadge]

Nah i was telling you mate, pick 3 in a superdraft or a 29 year old half back flanker, only Pies fans would go for the latter.

Oh, it's now a 'Superdraft' and Houston is now 29 years old and just a 'half back flanker'...

 

[Robertio]

Oh, it's now a 'Superdraft' and Houston is now 29 years old and just a 'half back flanker'...

I'm catching shit off of you mate.

 

[Robertio]

Are you sure Dan is 29....maybe he is 37?

29 in April mate but he has been coached by Ken Hinkley for 10 years so lets even it out at 45.

 

[Fadge]

I'm catching shit off of you mate.

Maybe that's why Carlton moved on from Houston - they thought he was 29 and forgot he is coming off consecutive All-Australians.

Nothing would surprise me with that club.

 

[Fadge]

29 in April mate but he has bee coached by Ken Hinkley for 10 years so lets even it ot at 45.

Where on earth do you guys get your information?

He's 29 in May. In 2026.

OMFG

 

[Robertio]

Where on earth do you guys get your information?

He's 29 in May. In 2026.

OMFG

He still has 15 years to go at the Pies then, good trade.

 

[carlton_99]

Where on earth do you guys get your information?

The hypocrisy is truly astonishing

 

[Fadge]

The hypocrisy is truly astonishing

Isn't it amazing there are approximately 5 billion people in this world that haven't seen Carlton win a premiership?

I wonder if it can get to 6 billion?

7 billion?

8 billion?

I reckon it can.

 

[carlton_99]

Isn't it amazing there are approximately 5 billion people in this world that haven't seen Carlton win a premiership?

I wonder if it can get to 6 billion?

7 billion?

8 billion?

I reckon it can.

I bet close to 8 billion haven't seen Collingwood win a premiership

 

[Fadge]

The hypocrisy is truly astonishing

By the way, where does the 99 in your username come from?

 

[Fadge]

I bet close to 8 billion haven't seen Collingwood win a premiership

Oh, great retort.

 

[adammania9]

Our core is all at or near 30?

Our best players in order

Cripps (29)
Curnow (27)
Weitering (27
Walsh (24)
McKay (27)
TDK (25)
Cerra (25)
Newman (31)
Saad (30)
Elijah Hollands (22)
George Hewett (28)

Wtf are you smoking lmao.

This age profile really peaked at 5th on the ladder?
This list has Elijah Hollands in its top 10 players?

Crikey

What seriously went wrong at Carlton?

 

[Fadge]

What seriously went wrong at Carlton?

Everything.

 

[carlton_99]

This age profile really peaked at 5th on the ladder?
This list has Elijah Hollands in its top 10 players?

Crikey

What seriously went wrong at Carlton?

You look at that age demographic and come to the conclusion that Carlton have peaked?

 

[carlton_99]

Oh, great retort.

I just stick to the facts