Game Day Carlton v Essendon Gameday Discussion - Rd 3, 2014 *No trolls or lurking likers*

[T2B_]

Not sure keeping Kennedy would help he's not exactly setting WCE on fire... One good season in amongst some ordinary ones.

We wouldn't be able to get the ball to him anyway, i think forward presence is hardly our only issue.

 

[LanceRomance]

marcjudd please don't mention Josh Kennedy as I will start to cry. Plus I haven't had a great weekend. Lucky I picked Essendon in my footy tips.

were you crying when you tipped essendon?

 

[Cringle]

Lol. This is embarrassing.

 

[El Topo]

Not usually one for hyperbole, but this mob are a disgrace to the jumper. Always have been mediocre, alway will be. Put a line through this generation and plan for the next one.

 

[Sharks On A Plane]

Bucks, Rowe, Gibbs, Jamo, Yarran have had a crack. The rest are scaring me.

 

[LanceRomance]

Why are you so surprised?

Curnow has never been AFL quality, David Ellard is 100% the footballer he is with smarts,courage and disposal, but didn't get a game over curnow.

Malthouse has and will be the biggest mistake the club has ever made.

No, over-rating the abilities of our list in '11 was the mistake.

 

[murphbf08]

brett ratten must be laughing at this we were beating dons by 100 points when he was around.what happened. malthouse you are finished should have retired gracefully, but instead we were stupid enough to pay you 1.5 mill for this crap.

 

[BM123]

Wake up loss.

Playing Robinson who is injured and has been awful lately over Lucas is pathetic.

 

[alfo]

it's pretty hard to single out one bloke tonight, but Garlett doesn't want to play in the navy blue...
it has been the case for a while
move him on...

 

[Tish]

Thank god for buckley. Guy is a gun, future brownlow medalist

 

[outabounds]

LOL at the 7 commentators mentioning 1970. Dream on

 

[Loramarthalas]

Somewhere, on a lonely hillside, 40yearblue is crying into his beer mug and whispering that he told us this would happen.

 

[rp84]

Is there a Jeremy Cameron in this draft or something? We sure look like we're going for it.

MM is heading for some serious questions. Took over an ok team expecting finals each year. If we lose next week, the sakc mick brigade will be out.

Time to blow this team up, trade the tradeable, delist the shite, develop the kids under someone like a bomber thompson or even cam ling or tom harley. This team of senior players is an absolute disgrace. So soft. No leadership. Time to start again. This list is an unmitigated disaster. Anyone saying the opposite has their head in the sand. Very sad day.

 

[ODNBlue]

Expecting a fair spike in Rake ratings tonight.

If only Rake was on...

 

[Tish]

I have to say though, footballers are a bunch of complete soft^%&s compared to Test cricketers. Ryan Harris has been playing with pain every game for 3 years and he plays 5 straight days....

 

[invinciBlues]

Why isn't anyone smashing Goddard's face in for giving Buckley a hard time?

Where the hell has the team spirit gone?

The kid's copping a spray and none of the veterans are putting their hand up to help.

Been that way since that campaigner Milburn cleaned up SOS.

 

[le dominateur]

Walker's kicking is embarrassing, Carrazzo failed to execute a handpass 3 times in a 2 minute period, Gibbs is plodding around like a headless chook. FML.

 

[Login]

I can't wait to see Cripps play

 

[Cringle]

Buckley, Rowe, Yarran, Gibbs and Jamison have been decent. Menzel made a couple of mistakes but is having a crack.

 

[kingkingston]

can we give the best and fairest to Kade Simpson already

 

[Vin Catoggio]

Players I'd like to see get a decent run: McInness, Watson, Cripps, Armfeild, Casboult, Bell, Graham, Temay and Docherty.

 

[pepalenko]

Chris Judd, im sorry.
Also sorry you have to be on seven right now.

 

[ESKIE]

Somewhere, on a lonely hillside, 40yearblue is crying into his beer mug and whispering that he told us this would happen.

Thats funny

 

[LanceRomance]

Thank god for buckley. Guy is a gun, future brownlow medalist

steady on

 

[Old Dark Blues]

I have no idea who I support.

Entirely different approaches against Port, Tigers and Bombers.

Either way - we can not beat a top 8 team - another season and this is proven to be the case.

Sorry, hate to say it - but blow torch is on Mick now. Such profound inconsistency ? Failure to address first quarter blow outs ? Absolutely nothing up forward, nothing.