Unofficial Preview Changes for week one of Finals (Out: Madgen, Murphy, Ox : In: Treloar, Howe, Goldsack)

[Unknown Identity]

An underdone Kennedy will still rip Madgen a new one.

We have to roll the dice on Goldsack or Reid to take him.

We are conceding 4+ goals to him otherwise.

 

[Jonno94]

An underdone Kennedy will still rip Madgen a new one.

We have to roll the dice on Goldsack or Reid to take him.

We are conceding 4+ goals to him otherwise.

Moore apparently training strongly today, I don't care who but either of those 3 needs to play over Madgen. I would even beg Keeffe to come back and play a couple of games.

 

[TimothyJ23]

IN: Treloar, Howe & Goldsack
OUT: Madgen, Oxley & Murphy

I'm probably way out with the backline reshuffle but it'll sort itself out, Bucks knows better than a newbie pleb like me. Anyway, Aish bench, Murph out, Treloar into the half forward line.

B: Maynard Goldsack Langdon
HB: Crisp Howe Greenwood
C: Varcoe Pendlebury Phillips
HF: Mihocek Treloar De Goey
F: Thomas Cox Mayne
Fol: Grundy Adams Sidebottom

INT: WHE Stephenson Sier Aish

#flagpies is ON

 

[good4footy]

From the Apple updates from training it seems to me as Treloar will not be picked and it will be :

Howe & Goldy for Oxley & Murphy.

At the start of the game the commentators will fall for Magden being 'attcked' by Eagles forwards, when in fact it will be all of them rushing to be the one to play on him.

 

[deano_66]

From the Apple updates from training it seems to me as Treloar will not be picked and it will be :

Howe & Goldy for Oxley & Murphy.

At the start of the game the commentators will fall for Magden being 'attcked' by Eagles forwards, when in fact it will be all them rushing to be the one to play on him.

Think Treloar has to come in. Buckley said if he trains today gets through it then he gets picked and he got through training

 

[Scodog10]

From the Apple updates from training it seems to me as Treloar will not be picked and it will be :

Howe & Goldy for Oxley & Murphy.

At the start of the game the commentators will fall for Magden being 'attcked' by Eagles forwards, when in fact it will be all them rushing to be the one to play on him.

You’ll need to explain this one to me given Apples tweeted that he thinks it’ll be Howe and Treloar in for Oxley and Murphy?..

 

[jackcass]

Having Treloar back is blowing my mind.

Why? It was suggested when he did it that it'd be an 8-10 week injury meaning a potential return last weekend in the VFL which was 10 weeks from the R14 injury.

 

[TimothyJ23]

With respect to Apples training updates this is on Twitter from a Ten News journo

 

[good4footy]

You’ll need to explain this one to me given Apples tweeted that he thinks it’ll be Howe and Treloar in for Oxley and Murphy?..

He provides the ongoing posts and from those he and I come up with different outcomes. In regards to what actually happens I hope it is all three of Howe, Goldy and Treloar.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

If true then that's pretty much the game.

NaH, I would say without him we are not certain to win.

 

[CFC2010]

You’ll need to explain this one to me given Apples tweeted that he thinks it’ll be Howe and Treloar in for Oxley and Murphy?..

As per Apples a supporter asked Treloar if he will play...…..his response was dunno.

Apples did say Goldy is likely.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

How can Grundy be a late out when he isn’t even an in yet ??????

Pedant

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Hope I’m wrong on Sier but watch this space.
In Treloar, Howe, Goldsack
Out - Magden, Oxley, Sier

Sier not going anywhere.

He's far ahead in the pecking order over Murphy as an example.

Adds a dimension to our pressure.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Richmond loses tonight, sets us up against them in the Prelim

Unless we lose too

 

[Scodog10]

As per Apples a supporter asked Treloar if he will play...…..his response was dunno.

Apples did say Goldy is likely.

Haha what’s he supposed to say “shit yeah I’m in”? They’ve been toeing the party line for a month on Treloar being unlikely so he’s not going to blurt our anything to a supporter as he leaves the field. Apples updates are great because we don’t get anything these days, but I wouldn’t read anything into them from a predictive perspective.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

It's Osher.
This is Usher....

Correct.
Osher is his name and obviously a Hebrew derivative as to Osher's back ground. Very Israeli in sound and style.

An Usher is a person working in a theatre and such.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Hadn't heard that. He cant play in a knockout final. so imo he is done for the year.

Why?

Of course he can; it's not perfect but an ok Moore frees far more than an underdone Goldsack in my view and certainly more than a fully going Madgen or Oxley.

Not ideal but you take what you have.

 

[CFC2010]

Haha what’s he supposed to say “shit yeah I’m in”? They’ve been toeing the party line for a month on Treloar being unlikely so he’s not going to blurt our anything to a supporter as he leaves the field. Apples updates are great because we don’t get anything these days, but I wouldn’t read anything into them from a predictive perspective.

Sorry I should have expanded...….he said Goldy is likely as he left with the main group. (While Murphy, Browns, Reid etc kept training)

It looks like it will be Howe, Treloar & Goldy

Good ins if that is the case.

 

[good4footy]

Haha what’s he supposed to say “shit yeah I’m in”? They’ve been toeing the party line for a month on Treloar being unlikely so he’s not going to blurt our anything to a supporter as he leaves the field. Apples updates are great because we don’t get anything these days, but I wouldn’t read anything into them from a predictive perspective.

You don't think Oxley and Murphy staying out to do extra work with other players not in the mix, as per one of Apple's post, is not predictive?

As i said in my response to you Apples and I can come to a different outcome from the info he is providing, which was what you first questioned.

 

[akneal]

Howe Goldsack and Treloar are all in. Moore could be too but I’m not sure. The first three definitely are though

 

[ThePhantom777]

Big call on Goldy....back for a final coming off a knee? I don't like it at all.

 

[Pragmatic Shill]

Grundy hamstring tightness? He trained today. That makes no sense.

 

[Quicky]

Assuming Goldsack and Howe are the inclusions for Madgen and Oxley. It'll be interesting to see who makes way for Treloar out of Aish, Mayne and Murphy. I'd assume it's Murphy personally with Aish and/or Varcoe playing more defensive minutes.

 

[Quicky]

Grundy hamstring tightness? He trained today. That makes no sense.

That's because someone made it up. It was a lie.

 

[MagpieBat]

An underdone Kennedy will still rip Madgen a new one.

We have to roll the dice on Goldsack or Reid to take him.

We are conceding 4+ goals to him otherwise.

Kennedy will destroy anyone who stands him. He booted 5 on Goldsack last time when he was fully fit, will do much the same this time on him underdone. Reid or Moore will break down and then where will we be?

The trick is whole team defence and not letting it get down there too often...