Scodog10
Brownlow Medallist
Saw that. In the act of contesting the ball sort of like how Dangerfield uses his body as a missile (ala the Noble contact) he’s fine.
Strategy Changes & Pre-match Discussion - Round 23 vs. Brisbane, Marvel, Fri 18/08, 7:50pm
- Thread starter unplugged
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
76woodenspooners
Brownlow Medallist
That Smith Handball to Jezza was a strange one.
I’d imagine that the boundary umpire didn’t have the authority to blow his whistle even if he saw it (or maybe was unclear)
The field umpire probably thought that if he didn’t hear the boundary umpire’s whistle, then it would even occur to him what happened (given he was busy setting the mark)
And the MRO in the ARC is probably constrained to only reviewing the sequence from the kick to when it passes through the goals, so the handball was out of scope.
An all round total cockup that makes the game look bad. I’d imagine that the AFL would be ensuring that the boundary umpires blow their whistle if they ever see that again.
Mollythedolly
Norm Smith Medallist
- Oct 21, 2021
- 6,899
- 8,344
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Not a Sidebottom fan?
- Sep 29, 2014
- 3,586
- 7,469
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
We look pretty well sorted barring centre bounces.
Out Cameron , In Cox
Out Moore , In Sidey
JDG isn't providing the speed out of CBA I was expecting and we look slow. Not sure how we fix it looking at our depth unless we train up Beau for CBA.
Out Cameron , In Cox
Out Moore , In Sidey
JDG isn't providing the speed out of CBA I was expecting and we look slow. Not sure how we fix it looking at our depth unless we train up Beau for CBA.
- Jul 2, 2017
- 8,900
- 18,682
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Daniher is going to kick a bag next week even if Moore was playing. Sadly there's just those players that exist that turn it on against us regardless of best efforts.
I feel like Markov hasn't been a whipping boy since May now? Pies fans love him. He's a genuine favourite in the Ponsford.
- Jul 2, 2017
- 8,900
- 18,682
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Sadly I don't get to the Ponsford much, that's great to hear.
- Aug 21, 2009
- 6,083
- 8,221
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Liverpool
With Frampton back, Cox replaces Moore
If Sidey fit , not sure which mid goes out. Maybe WHE. Personally I would rest Titch at Marvel and freshen him up.
The match ups for Daniher Hipwood and Cameron are bad for us. At least we don’t desperately need the win next week
If Sidey fit , not sure which mid goes out. Maybe WHE. Personally I would rest Titch at Marvel and freshen him up.
The match ups for Daniher Hipwood and Cameron are bad for us. At least we don’t desperately need the win next week
lyfsux
Premium Platinum
Because Cameron is playing so you drop him then Cox will "SIMPLES"
ground is an issue .... will tax ageing legs so this should be a consideration
- Mar 16, 2022
- 5,971
- 9,009
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Nope, I’m talking about the games Cox was first ruck and Cameron wasn’t playing.
- Jul 29, 2017
- 3,210
- 6,120
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- 76ers
Assuming he’s still out as no word either way, so until someone from the club says he’s available then he’s out, pretty simple really.
IN: Sidebottom
OUT: Moore
B: J.Noble - B.Frampton - B.Maynard
HB: I.Quaynor - N.Murphy - J.Crisp
C: J.Daicos - S.Pendlebury - S.Sidebottom
HF: B.Hill - B.Mihocek - B.McCreery
F: J.Howe - D.McStay - J.Elliott
R: D.Cameron - J.DeGoey - T.Mitchell
I: O.Markov - P.Lipinski - T.Adams - J.Ginnivan
S: W.Hoskin-Elliott
Big test for Frampton V Daniher. Murphy will take Hipwood with Maynard having to take Gunston.
The argument would be you could bring in AJ/Kreuger/Cox for Moore and roll Howe back, however I think we need to see Howe forward again.
OUT: Moore
B: J.Noble - B.Frampton - B.Maynard
HB: I.Quaynor - N.Murphy - J.Crisp
C: J.Daicos - S.Pendlebury - S.Sidebottom
HF: B.Hill - B.Mihocek - B.McCreery
F: J.Howe - D.McStay - J.Elliott
R: D.Cameron - J.DeGoey - T.Mitchell
I: O.Markov - P.Lipinski - T.Adams - J.Ginnivan
S: W.Hoskin-Elliott
Big test for Frampton V Daniher. Murphy will take Hipwood with Maynard having to take Gunston.
The argument would be you could bring in AJ/Kreuger/Cox for Moore and roll Howe back, however I think we need to see Howe forward again.
Sidebottom's injury was a foot, was it not? I'd be surprised if he's back after one week. Foot injuries can be troublesome for a while.
Cox in for Moore for me. Obviously with no Moore we'd lose the flexibility to ruck with Billy, and Cameron can't solo ruck.
I would also have Ginnivan start at the expense of one of the outside runners, as they won't likely have as much influence at Marvel. Hoskin-Elliott played a brilliant first half I thought, but feel like he's the unlucky one.
B: Brayden Maynard - Nathan Murphy - Isaac Quaynor
HB: Jack Crisp - Billy Frampton - Oleg Markov
C: Josh Daicos - Tom Mitchell - Patrick Lipinski
HF: Bobby Hill - Brody Mihocek - Jeremy Howe
F: Jamie Elliott - Dan McStay - Jack Ginnivan
R: Darcy Cameron - Scott Pendlebury - Jordan De Goey
I: Taylor Adams - Beau McCreery - John Noble - Mason Cox
Sub: Will Hoskin-Elliott
Cox in for Moore for me. Obviously with no Moore we'd lose the flexibility to ruck with Billy, and Cameron can't solo ruck.
I would also have Ginnivan start at the expense of one of the outside runners, as they won't likely have as much influence at Marvel. Hoskin-Elliott played a brilliant first half I thought, but feel like he's the unlucky one.
B: Brayden Maynard - Nathan Murphy - Isaac Quaynor
HB: Jack Crisp - Billy Frampton - Oleg Markov
C: Josh Daicos - Tom Mitchell - Patrick Lipinski
HF: Bobby Hill - Brody Mihocek - Jeremy Howe
F: Jamie Elliott - Dan McStay - Jack Ginnivan
R: Darcy Cameron - Scott Pendlebury - Jordan De Goey
I: Taylor Adams - Beau McCreery - John Noble - Mason Cox
Sub: Will Hoskin-Elliott
Cox in and Moore out. I can't abide watching McStay in the ruck and shudder to think Fly is going down that line of thought with finals just around the corner. Imagine McStay taking a centre bounce in the last term of a prelim or the GF. We struggle enough in the centre square and Gawn or The Big O would tear us a new one if we do it.
Cameron dropped everything that came his way tonight. His hands are terrible at the moment. The leeway he gets after games like tonight compared to the lanky Yank is a joke.
Cameron dropped everything that came his way tonight. His hands are terrible at the moment. The leeway he gets after games like tonight compared to the lanky Yank is a joke.
- Apr 17, 2017
- 1,790
- 2,496
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Banned
- #42
Out Moore
In Ruscoe
Out Noble
In Ginnivan
Sub Sidebottom
In the first half, when the Cats were all over us, Markov and WHE were great!
He may have been rusty in the first 5 minutes, but Ginnivan was EXCELLENT.
Lipinski help us turn it around in the centre.
Howe was dangerous up forward. The cats defenders had to be accountable. Maybe that helped Checkers get his 5?
If Sidebottom is sore, nurse him in.
Of all our defenders, Noble looks like the weakest link.
In Ruscoe
Out Noble
In Ginnivan
Sub Sidebottom
In the first half, when the Cats were all over us, Markov and WHE were great!
He may have been rusty in the first 5 minutes, but Ginnivan was EXCELLENT.
Lipinski help us turn it around in the centre.
Howe was dangerous up forward. The cats defenders had to be accountable. Maybe that helped Checkers get his 5?
If Sidebottom is sore, nurse him in.
Of all our defenders, Noble looks like the weakest link.
Cousin of Daicos
HEY MAGPIE ARMY!
Sounds to me like Moore might actually play next week
In: Sidebottom I guess, Cox
Out: Cameron, Adams (I know it won’t happen no matter how bad he continues to be)
But if Darcy misses then I guess Krueger?
In: Sidebottom I guess, Cox
Out: Cameron, Adams (I know it won’t happen no matter how bad he continues to be)
But if Darcy misses then I guess Krueger?
Visions
Brownlow Medallist
- Oct 2, 2007
- 12,624
- 16,524
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Liverpool FC, HNS Vatreni
On the flip side, imagine Cox against Gawn in a GF with Cox chasing Gawn's tail for 120 minutes around the ground. Doesn't have the tank.
Last edited:
Whether it’s tightness or a strain, Moore needs to rest…testing will show signs of susceptibility to injury. Tightness is one such a sign.
Lippa showed last year that he’s best 22, he isn’t at the moment. I’m bringing Macrae back in to take some load of our aging on ball brigade and Jordy who will also probably miss or need a break.
Out: Moore, Jordy, Lippa
In: Cox, Macrae Sidebottom
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
What’s he done to be dropped ? He’s not setting the world on fire at the moment, but he’s going ok. Also injured earlier in the year, you just don’t know how we’ll he’s recovered and how long it will take for him to play with fitness and confidence again.
I do prefer Cox though, he has X factor. Whether he’s on ball giving deft back heels to open players or clunking a grab…he’s also quicker than Cameron and deadly at full forward with quick delivery.
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
Cameron out; Cox in. Straight swap in ruck. Cameron had a better 2nd half but was weak & uncompetitive in 1st half.
Moore out; Ruscoe in. Ruscoe takes Gunston, Murphy on Hipwood and Frampton on Daniher. Frampton takes 2nd ruck duties when Daniher rolls in there.
Howe stays forward, helps defensively against Andrews and uses footy IQ to stay involved offensively.
Quaynor or Markov vs C.Cameron.
Not sure Marvel concrete park is suitable for Sidey coming back from foot injury. But if he’s ready to go give Mitchell a rest.
Moore will be out for weeks. He grabbed high on his hamstring and pulled up mid sprint so I can’t see how that’s innocuous. Bizarrely, no ice applied after he came off, which might mean ….
Moore out; Ruscoe in. Ruscoe takes Gunston, Murphy on Hipwood and Frampton on Daniher. Frampton takes 2nd ruck duties when Daniher rolls in there.
Howe stays forward, helps defensively against Andrews and uses footy IQ to stay involved offensively.
Quaynor or Markov vs C.Cameron.
Not sure Marvel concrete park is suitable for Sidey coming back from foot injury. But if he’s ready to go give Mitchell a rest.
Moore will be out for weeks. He grabbed high on his hamstring and pulled up mid sprint so I can’t see how that’s innocuous. Bizarrely, no ice applied after he came off, which might mean ….
Jen2310
Premium Platinum
Um..
Lippa had 25 disposals. 8 tackles. 13 contested possessions, 7 score involvements, 5 clearances.
Tonight is not a game where there was any merit to drop him.
- Status
