Preview Changes: R4 vs Fremantle, Saturday April 8, 1.15pm ACST @ Adelaide Oval

[Kane McGoodwin]

Good to hear the care over Fog and Parnell

Berry either plays this week and misses next week or misses this week and plays next

I think likely Fog, Parnell, Pedlar, Berry & McAdam all come in for Carlton game... which is not a bad thing with a shorter turnaround.

 

[George Kramer]

I think likely Fog, Parnell, Pedlar, Berry & McAdam all come in for Carlton game... which is not a bad thing with a shorter turnaround.

Don’t think Nicks will want to make 5 changes, especially if we hope it’s a winning side.

Fog, Pedlar and McAdam are hopefully are certain starters but McAdam has missed 3 games.

Parnell only came in when Milera pulled out, doubt he plays.

Berrys form hasn’t been good, so if Schoenberg comes in and plays well, can’t see Berry replacing any of our mids.

 

[Brett Cummings]

Don’t think Nicks will want to make 5 changes, especially if we hope it’s a winning side.

Fog, Pedlar and McAdam are hopefully are certain starters but McAdam has missed 3 games.

Parnell only came in when Milera pulled out, doubt he plays.

Berrys form hasn’t been good, so if Schoenberg comes in and plays well, can’t see Berry replacing any of our mids.

No way mcadams playing sanfl lol.

 

[cleanhands]

No way mcadams playing sanfl lol.

But if we use Burns theory, he’ll come in and kick 5

 

[Burtonsgottago]

Agree that Mchenry is the right selection for Pedlar if we are doing a like for like replacement, but they may just want to get Jones in after his game last week. But yes will need to reshuffle if Jones does come in. Will be interesting to see which way they go.

Don’t you ever say McHenry is like-for-like for Pedlar again

 

[MsTopG]

Agree that Mchenry is the right selection for Pedlar if we are doing a like for like replacement, but they may just want to get Jones in after his game last week. But yes will need to reshuffle if Jones does come in. Will be interesting to see which way they go.

I don't want to see Ned play for us ever again. I would rather Cook or Nank.

 

[Burtonsgottago]

Nicks basically said McHenry today.

we have better options than Ned

 

[Rory Walkerfield]

I'm far from a Hately fan but he should be considered in front of Brown this week if only for the reason we need to see if he's got it as an inside misfielder or quickly move on. He's basically playing for his AFL career this season so you would think he'd go hard and give it all he's got. He's really not proven to be versatile at AFL level so it's midfield or bust for him IMO.

Neither Brown nor Hateley should be considered unless we have 20 on the injury list.

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Jones and Pedlar play different roles, it’s McHenry for Pedlar. Given Jones can’t play midfield, if Berry misses, to keep Jones in the team they will need a reshuffle. So possibly Sloane to the middle and Jones wing.

But the less disruptive will be Schoenberg in, Jones sub. 2 weeks in a row as sub now isn’t the same as when it was medical sub, they can still give Jones decent game time. O’Brien has been Carlton’s sub for the first 3 games.

What about Sloane forward to take Pedlar spot ( but also to rotate thru inside mid at times ) and Jones to wing

Ned to sub ?

Don’t think it’s the most likely chance which is prob Pedlar out and Ned in and Chayce sub again but I’d prob go for the former

 

[Brett Cummings]

Why not replace pedlar with taylor. He'd be way more dangerous than mchenry.

 

[cleanhands]

Why not replace pedlar with taylor. He'd be way more dangerous than mchenry.

Would be nice to see how he goes with better quality players around him

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Don’t think Nicks will want to make 5 changes, especially if we hope it’s a winning side.

Fog, Pedlar and McAdam are hopefully are certain starters but McAdam has missed 3 games.

Parnell only came in when Milera pulled out, doubt he plays.

Berrys form hasn’t been good, so if Schoenberg comes in and plays well, can’t see Berry replacing any of our mids.

We should be looking to rotate players any way, particularly where we have shorter breaks.

This week...

Ins: Keane, Schoenberg, McHenry (sub)
Out: Butts (managed), Berry (injured), Pedlar (suspended)

B: Michalanney, Murray, Keane
HB: Milera, Doedee, Hinge
C: Jones, Dawson, Sholl
HF: Sloane, Walker, Keays
F: Gollant, Thilthorpe, Rankine
R: O'Brien, Rachele, Laird
I: Smith, Soligo, Schoenberg, Murphy
Sub: McHenry

Following game v Carlton

In: Fogarty, McAdam, Pedlar, Butts, Berry, Parnell
Out: Walker (managed), Gollant, Schoenberg, Keane, McHenry, Smith (managed)

B: Michalanney, Murray, Butts
HB: Parnell, Doedee, Hinge
C: Sloane, Dawson, Sholl
HF: Pedlar, Fogarty, Keays
F: McAdam Thilthorpe, Rankine
R: O'Brien, Rachele, Laird
I: Milera, Berry, Jones, Soligo
Sub: Murphy

 

[SellarStardom]

Freo this week they have Taberner (198), Jackson (199) and Amiss (196).

If Butts isn't right is Nicks seriously going with Murray (194), Doedee (189) and Dawson (191), he can't be that dumb surely.

Has to bring in one of Keane (194), Borlase (192) or Himmelberg (199) as defender. Personally I would go Murray on Taberner, Himmelberg on Jackson and Doedee on Amiss with Michalanney on Walters

 

[Eagleboy2011]

Neither Brown nor Hateley should be considered unless we have 20 on the injury list.

Hately is a good player. Its his disposal that lets him down. I thought he played very well in the SANFL last week.

 

[Crows I Am]

Don’t you ever say McHenry is like-for-like for Pedlar again

Like for like structure wise, not skill and talent wise. Obviously Pedlar is the better player but he is unavailable this week. If we want to keep the same structure we will likely bring McHenry in to replace Pedlar. If we want to reshuffle then likely Jones I'd say.

 

[MsTopG]

Injuries
Butts?, Berry? , Walker? Fogarty Worrell Parnell

Suspension:
McAdam Pedlar

Freo Game

Out: Butts inj Pedlar susp Berry inj
In: Keane Jones Schoenberg

Jones Keane Doedee
Smith Murray Michalanney
Dawson Laird Hinge
Murphy Thilthorpe Rachele
Rankine Walker Gollant

ROB Soligo Schoenberg

Sloane Sholl Keays Milera

Carlton game

In: Worrell?(if fit or Smith if not fit), McAdam Pedlar Fogarty Berry
Out: Smith? Walker(rested if inj)/Gollant Milera/Keays Sholl/Murphy Schoenberg

Jones Keane Doedee
Worrell/Smith Murray Michalanney
Soligo Laird Hinge
McAdam Thilthorpe Rachele
Rankine Fogarty Pedlar

ROB Berry Dawson

Gollant/Walker Sloane Sholl/Murphy Milera/Keays

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Port haven’t got the money to invest in development coaches for the sanfl side…

they’ve given it all to Ken!…

kochie.. the gift that keeps on giving!..

Actually fairly true !

 

[FR0GGY]

I kinda lean to if Burgess says he's fine, he's fine.

He's not playing that poorly at the moment. Mainly being hung out to dry by our defensive structures falling apart.

Murray not being hung out to dry as much?

 

[MsTopG]

I expect it'll be something like Pedlar and Berry OUT, Crouch and McHenry IN.

Crouch is a possibility but I would rather Schoenberg.

 

[George Kramer]

Port haven’t got the money to invest in development coaches for the sanfl side…

they’ve given it all to Ken!…

kochie.. the gift that keeps on giving!..

Their sanfl side sucks so badly, they’ve got **** all depth. A bad run of injuries and they are bottom 4

 

[jackster83]

Think it will be Jones in for Pedlar, McHenry in for Berry if he doesn't get up and Schoenberg sub.

 

[Burtonsgottago]

Like for like structure wise, not skill and talent wise. Obviously Pedlar is the better player but he is unavailable this week. If we want to keep the same structure we will likely bring McHenry in to replace Pedlar. If we want to reshuffle then likely Jones I'd say.

I understand what you are saying but Ned can’t even play the role that Pedlar has been playing. He just doesn’t have it. Let’s try someone else to see if they can or move Sloane there for one week allowing Jones to start on the wing.

 

[MsTopG]

After watching Nick's it sounds like Butts is playing even though he didn't train this week and sounds injured, Berry won't play but probably back for Carlton, McHenry will be in for Pedlar. Schoenberg or Crouch in for Berry. Probably Crouch. Bit of a danger game this week. Hopefully Nick's gets the selection right.

 

[1970crow]

Sloane replaces Pedlar up forward with occasional run on ball.

Jones replaces Sloane on a wing.

Schoenberg replaces Berry on ball, but spends time up forward too with more players rotated through.

Sloane will be more midfield than not with Berry making way in the 2s or via injury.

 

[Golumless]

Murray not being hung out to dry as much?

I've got nothing for this, seeing Butts offensive game has also dropped this year.

I've mainly noticed I'm frustrated by other things, i.e. our lack of protecting leading lanes, or not killing a contested marking situation then I have been with Butts defensive efforts.