Preview Changes: R5 vs Richmond - Saturday April 16, 4.05pm ACST @ Adelaide Oval

Will Crouch or Sloane be dropped this season?

  • Crouch will be dropped

  • Sloane will be dropped

  • Both Crouch and Sloane will be dropped (separate weeks)

  • Both Crouch and Sloane will be dropped (together)

  • Neither will be dropped this season


Results are only viewable after voting.

Remove this Banner Ad

Interesting vision of Sloane arguing with Nick's at training. I wonder if this was the discussion of its time for you to move out of the midfield for the benefit of the team. There shouldn't be any discussion.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Interesting vision of Sloane arguing with Nick's at training. I wonder if this was the discussion of its time for you to move out of the midfield for the benefit of the team. There shouldn't be any discussion.
If we were fair dinkum we would drop Sloane to the sanfl to find form.

If 2 leaders Sloane & ROB were dropped this week, it would send a strong message that it doesn't matter who you are, you need to perform.
 
Channel 7 news. Nick's laughed it off when questioned in his presser but it looked like Sloane didn't enjoy what Nick's was saying. Probably not used to be called out I guess.
The story on 9 was there was some confusion on game plan and Nicks said glad they had that session so they could sort it out and not on game day. But concerning that there could be confusion 5 games in.
 
But hey some here want to drop crouch , sloane , keays , great idea let,s play all the kids let them get smashed and drain all their confidence and then watch the same people abuse the coach because we had no experience to help them out
 
But hey some here want to drop crouch , sloane , keays , great idea let,s play all the kids let them get smashed and drain all their confidence and then watch the same people abuse the coach because we had no experience to help them out
They need to start introducing some of the kids into the midfield, I don’t think anyone has said drop all of them especially Keays.
 
They need to start introducing some of the kids into the midfield, I don’t think anyone has said drop all of them especially Keays.
Dont disagree playing some of them but you need experience also unless you wanna end up like carlton rebuild 10 years later
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Looks like Berry in for Schoenberg and McAdam in for Rowe/McHenry based on what Nick's said. We should be dropping underperforming senior players and getting more games into our future. I would also like to see Hamill in for Jones and Strachan in for ROB.

The SANFL coach said that Sloane is just unlucky and it’ll turn for him soon abs he’ll accelerate fast to playing selectable footy again.

It’s an ingrained culture and only like minded losers get a second interview.
 
If we were fair dinkum we would drop Sloane to the sanfl to find form.

If 2 leaders Sloane & ROB were dropped this week, it would send a strong message that it doesn't matter who you are, you need to perform.
As has been pointed out, GWS dropped Cogniglio so this can't drop captain crap is just that.
 
Actually no, you made that up
Really hmm maybe go back and read posts bearded clam and i quote keays shouldn.t be in our side we should drop sloane and crouch yeah great ****ing idea welcome to carlton mark 2 with that logic 20 year rebuild here we come thank god spuds like that dont hold positions in our club
 
You also went on and on after last week’s selection about how we should play Tex in the Twos.

Shouldn’t we drop him as well?

Or were you WRONG last week?

No, Tex shouldn’t be dropped. And he did perform well. But that’s an outlier when rushing players back after many months out. How did Junior go? How did Sloane go after a week off? You’ve been found out old son. You’ve no idea, I bet you supported Sloane’s inclusion despite carrying an injury.

Naturally, as the insufferable tool that you are, your first response is that it was brilliance designed to shave 4 points off our ladder position and maximise our draft capital. You truely are a very simple shill. At least your comrades lack your ignorance and arrogance.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Preview Changes: R5 vs Richmond - Saturday April 16, 4.05pm ACST @ Adelaide Oval

Back
Top