Preview Changes: R5 vs Richmond - Saturday April 16, 4.05pm ACST @ Adelaide Oval

[Scorpus]

IN:
McAdam, Cook, Berry

OUT:
Hinge, Rowe, Schoenberg

Hinge dropped and named as an emergency, not injured

 

[Bearded Clam]

Milera for Hinge.

Hately sub.

Back the rest of them in.

Milera has been stinking it up in the sanfl.. his field kicking is totally off.. way too many turnovers..

Would rather gove Parnell or Davis a run at it..

 

[Pugsley]

Milera has been stinking it up in the sanfl.. his field kicking is totally off.. way too many turnovers..

Would rather gove Parnel or Davis a run at it..

I'd give Parnell a run.

 

[Bearded Clam]

Out:

The “Stacked” midfield and the useless big lump of clumbsyness (ROB)..

In:

A better midfield using guys like Berry, Hatley, Pedlar.. and Strawnie.

 

[Scorpus]

You could throw a blanket over a dozen of our SANFL players who could come in and make an impact

Midfield - Berry, Hately, Soligo, Pedlar, Taylor (is he injured?)
Forwards - Thilthorpe, Cook (full game)
Defense - Hamill, McPherson (is he injured?), Worrell, McAsey (time to see what he has?)
Ruck - Strachan

 

[hey shorty]

You could throw a blanket over a dozen of our SANFL players who could come in and make an impact

Midfield - Berry, Hately, Soligo, Pedlar, Taylor (is he injured?)
Forwards - Thilthorpe, Cook (full game)
Defense - Hamill, McPherson (is he injured?), Worrell, McAsey (time to see what he has?)
Ruck - Strachan

Personally I think Cook is still a step or 2 off. Easy to forget how little of any footy he's played.

 

[Mego Red]

Anyone willing to suggest anything realistic?

Zero chance a rebuilding club drops it's captain.

Close to zero that they drop Crouch, but MAYBE. He's had a long time out and he's not really impacting. They could see it as a way for him to find his feet in a lower stress environment.

ROB could perhaps be rested for a week, as he just doesn't seem physically up to it.

Jones and McHenry were better, so they probably stay. I think Frampton stays for a couple more weeks, until McAsey is really demanding it.

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Frampton needs to be played as a half back in the position of Smith or Hinge - he can't play anywhere else

That means he gets dropped

 

[Scorpus]

Realistic is

Out: Hinge (injured)
In: Milera

Sub: Berry

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Personally I think Cook is still a step or 2 off. Easy to forget how little of any footy he's played.

I loved the energy Cook brought , let him make some mistakes . That’s all part of it

We need to absorb some errors from our talented ones if they are trying to do the right thing

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Realistic is

Out: Hinge (injured)
In: Milera

Sub: Berry

It Hately doesn’t play this week it makes no sense he’s on our list

Not saying it will happen though

 

[NTRabbit]

Frampton needs to be played as a half back in the position of Smith or Hinge - he can't play anywhere else

In place of Doedee

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Anyone willing to suggest anything realistic?

Zero chance a rebuilding club drops it's captain.

Close to zero that they drop Crouch, but MAYBE. He's had a long time out and he's not really impacting. They could see it as a way for him to find his feet in a lower stress environment.

ROB could perhaps be rested for a week, as he just doesn't seem physically up to it.

Jones and McHenry were better, so they probably stay. I think Frampton stays for a couple more weeks, until McAsey is really demanding it.

Ins Hately Worrall

Outs M Crouch Hinge ( inj)

 

[Scorpus]

It Hately doesn’t play this week it makes no sense he’s on our list

Not saying it will happen though

Suggesting we pick on SANFL form is unrealistic, we don't seem to do that

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Suggesting we pick on SANFL form is unrealistic, we don't seem to do that

Yep we shall see

 

[latinoheat]

Ins Hately Worrall

Outs M Crouch Hinge ( inj)

No thilthorpe for himmelberg?

Also the other change id make is berry in, McHenry out

 

[MRB37]

ROB in the leadership group now so can't see him getting dropped either given our inexperience.

 

[hey shorty]

Suggesting we pick on SANFL form is unrealistic, we don't seem to do that

It's the only conceivable reason Frampton is playing

 

[Crow_68]

We know Sloane is not going to be dropped under any circumstances.

It will be:
In Hately, out Schoenberg
And if Hinge is hurt, in Hamill

There should be other changes, but I reckon that’s what they go with.

 

[Jeffcrowe]

No thilthorpe for himmelberg?

Also the other change id make is berry in, McHenry out

Getting close re TT , I think Himmelberg did enough and was still presenting late

Wouldn’t mind TT in the ruck but we need him to develop as a forward

 

[hey shorty]

No thilthorpe for himmelberg?

Also the other change id make is berry in, McHenry out

Himmelberg was fine, and if Keays had've spotted him a 40m kick he'd have had 3 goals and kicked the match winner.

 

[Golumless]

It Hately doesn’t play this week it makes no sense he’s on our list

Not saying it will happen though

I disagree, out of the two, you select Berry.

Whilst Hately played well, it wasn't exactly a performance that should have given you any confidence he has an AFL game in him.

 

[LeftyLuke]

Out: ROB Sloane McHenry Jones Frampton Brown Murphy

In: Strachan Berry Pedlar Hamill Murray/Worrell/Borlase Parnell Newchurch/McAdam

Parnell Butts Doedee
Smith Murray/Worrell/Borlase Hamill
Dawson Laird Hinge
Cook Himmelberg Pedlar
Rachele Walker Gollant

Strachan Schoenberg Berry

Keays Newchurch/McAdam Crouch Rowe

 

[hey shorty]

I disagree, out of the two, you select Berry.

Whilst Hately played well, it wasn't exactly a performance that should have given you any confidence he has an AFL game in him.

I think there's room for both based on what we saw from our midfield.

 

[Jeffcrowe]

I disagree, out of the two, you select Berry.

Whilst Hately played well, it wasn't exactly a performance that should have given you any confidence he has an AFL game in him.

I wouldn’t mind either way , one of them should be playing

 

[crows dude]

In Murray, McAsey, Berry, Hately, Worrell Strachan

Out Hinge inj, Sloane, Crouch, Jones, McHenry Rob

F. Murphy Himmelberg Rowe
HF. Rachele Walker Gollant
C. Dawson Berry. Sholl
HB. Smith Murray Laird
B. McAsey Butts Doedee
Ruck. Strachan Keays Schoenberg
Inter. Worrell Brown Frampton Cook
Sub Hately