Preview Changes v Saints Rd 6

[VitalDread]

Imagine the meltdown when Cordy retains his spot

I wouldn't see a problem with it

 

[BEaston]

Cordy will be better under the roof. Don't mind if Minno comes in for him but happy to just roll with the match commitee on this one. Seems like Cordy will stay based on Bev's comments.

 

[Morris Major]

I wouldn't see a problem with it

Neither, but judging from this thread it looks like most would

 

[Dogs_R_Us]

Everyone wants to drop Cordy but we've done alright with him in the team. Bevo is satisfied with his output and that's all that matters.

 

[VitalDread]

NICK Riewoldt and Leigh Montagna are expected to line up against the Western Bulldogs on Saturday as St Kilda looks to replicate Sunday's four-quarter effort against Essendon.

 

[JTCWBFC]

NICK Riewoldt and Leigh Montagna are expected to line up against the Western Bulldogs on Saturday as St Kilda looks to replicate Sunday's four-quarter effort against Essendon.

I'd rather play them with those blokes in so they can't bitch and moan when we smash them and say, if only we had Roo and Tags

 

[lachy]

Everyone wants to drop Cordy but we've done alright with him in the team. Bevo is satisfied with his output and that's all that matters.

I think its more the case everyone would like to drop Cordy but the alternatives do not fit in with our defensive zones and structures

 

[yebiga]

cordy had his chance
It's campbell time

I don't believe this had anything to do with minson
We had to give Cordy a chance
Aside from being the worst ruck man we have ever played he can go down back on a tall which neither minno or Campbell can do as well as Cordy
But Cordy is no defender

So it's campbell soup time

Always tricky trying to read the thinking of new coach - that my take

 

[who_let_the_dogs_out]

Bit of a danger game this one, back at the dome and going in as favourites, as opposed to nothing-to-lose underdogs.

Hope we keep the same intensity.

 

[JTCWBFC]

cordy had his chance
It's campbell time

If we're changing the set up we may as well play Minson, they are both as immobile as eachother and Minson is still the better player.

TC can go forward, but as the sole ruck he wouldn't get that chance anyway really.

 

[yebiga]

If we're changing the set up we may as well play Minson, they are both as immobile as eachother and Minson is still the better player.

TC can go forward, but as the sole ruck he wouldn't get that chance anyway really.

Time to see how Campbell goes as first ruck
If Cordy deserved the chance then Campbell has earned it

 

[JTCWBFC]

Time to see how Campbell goes as first ruck
If Cordy deserved the chance then Campbell has earned it

Cordy has a much better tank than TC.

 

[Dannnnnnnnnn]

OUT: Jong
IN: Dale

 

[Hrovat24]

Can't play Cordy against longer and hickey , he will get destroyed isn't strong enough

 

[Dogs54]

Can't play Cordy against longer and hickey , he will get destroyed isn't strong enough

I thought you weren't going to mention Cordy again!

 

[Hrovat24]

I thought you weren't going to mention Cordy again!

Only in selection I won't carry on that his shit etc

 

[GreatSouthWest]

Can't play Cordy against longer and hickey , he will get destroyed isn't strong enough

That has absolutely no relevance. Winning the hit out and being out-muscled by everyone is overrated. Playing in a team is about defensive zones and structures.

 

[Hrovat24]

That has absolutely no relevance. Winning the hit out and being out-muscled by everyone is overrated. Playing in a team is about defensive zones and structures.

Yeah no worries you believe that

 

[yebiga]

Cordy has a much better tank than TC.

Cordy can't mark can't kick can't ruck
TC is leaner and fitter than last year - we have to give him a chance
I don't believe Cordy is any quicker
It's great to be winning with 17.5 on the field but if we want to play finals and maybe win one or two - we should consider playing the aloted 18.

 

[VitalDread]

cordy had his chance
It's campbell time

I don't believe this had anything to do with minson
We had to give Cordy a chance
Aside from being the worst ruck man we have ever played he can go down back on a tall which neither minno or Campbell can do as well as Cordy
But Cordy is no defender

So it's campbell soup time

Always tricky trying to read the thinking of new coach - that my take

Campbell IMO is still two vfl games away for fitness level, still building on his tank

 

[yebiga]

Campbell IMO is still two vfl games away for fitness level, still building on his tank

There is no reason for that he has played enough games and match fitness comes from matches
The saints is the perfect opponent for him

 

[Rors]

NICK Riewoldt and Leigh Montagna are expected to line up against the Western Bulldogs on Saturday as St Kilda looks to replicate Sunday's four-quarter effort against Essendon.

Fair call. If we somehow manage to win (unlikely), just promise you guys wont be saying "if only we had Lin Jong..."

 

[Cudi]

Out: Cordy, Jong, Smith
In: Minson, Hunter, Biggs

B: Roberts Roughead Wood
HB: Murphy Talia M Boyd
C: Biggs Bont Macare
HF: Hrovat Crameri Hunter
F: Stringer T Boyd Dickson
Foll: Minson Picken Dahl
INT: Honeychurch Stevens JJ SUB: Webb

 

[VitalDread]

No way webb is sub
blokes all class down back

 

[doggies ftw]

I'd be okay with Webb sub, it's a long season and he'd really add something coming on for the last. Although if he's coping with the load well enough (and only the club knows if he is or isn't, then give him another full game. Reckon if he went into the midfield he'd rack up 25+ already