- Oct 3, 2012
- 12,971
- 25,145
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Lmao, if he played for your club this year he would've got the 2nd most tackles and 5th most contested possessions.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Traded Chris Yarran [to Richmond for Pick 19]
- Thread starter living_in_syd
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Which is why my first sentence was that we would have to find a second rounder elsewhere. Weren't you paying attention?
You're missing the point - I'm making it clear why they are no longer dealing with us. The point I'm making is: only Richmond is dealing with Carlton, because they can't get the deal done. Yes 17 is fine, so Richmond better go get it done soon.
And on averages he wouldn't get a game
ARES
Cancelled
ARES
Cancelled
Yeah right, like Carlton are going to offer him more than $450K
He is better off staying at CFC, collecting $450K, cruise along the year since you will bottom out again then skipping over to the mighty Tigers
Catching up with news for the full day of trade talks via clubs it is very much sounding like Richmond in the end will trade 17 to use once they get a deal done with Brisbane. I not heard directly talk of Astbury plus a pick to Lions for pick 17 they got for Redden, but if that happens almost a certainty Carlton and Richmond will sign off on Yarran to Richmond for pick 17 within 24 hours of that.
Puts the Redden and Yarran of similar worth in overall market which looks about right.
Puts the Redden and Yarran of similar worth in overall market which looks about right.
We are rebuilding, we must have picks inside the top 20. Otherwise, we force Yarran to stay and see what happens - we have plenty of money to match a FA offer, which by the valuations of Richmond supporters we will easily match for no pain whatsoever.
He'll go to Richmond but it will be for a top18 pick. 17 or some deal involving 12.
You started by suggesting you should keep pick 17 and offer the same 2nd round pick to carlton, I told you that you won't have it yet when you reply you again finish with "He'd end up ours for pick 31 or whatever it is."
Your either very forgetful or ignorant, I really don't care which it is.
There are only 7 kids in this draft rated well enough to say they will make a club b&f top 10 (3 of which are academy picks), 13 other kids that might make best 22 quality and outside those top 20 your looking 50:50 if they will even make the grade (Outside Pick 38 your looking at maybe role players if you are lucky). Based on that picks 8-20 are value for someone like yarran, 21+ would be rubbish.
Quite clearly most clubs draft teams are on board with that which is why so many trades have been completed thus far, all except the tigers who have missed out on everything they have looked at.
If he coasts he will lose out on his one big pay check, he won't do it unless he wants to end up in a centrelink office 3 years after retirement.
ARES
Cancelled
Carltons rebuilding should not have a say on Yarrans worth
You will not match money for a player that drags his feet and walks out a second time.
ARES
Cancelled
He won't lose out. There will be a club that will pay $ to get him...probably Melbourne the way they have been going in the draft...
ARES
Cancelled
Again, what the draft is is not any ones concern that Carlton is rebuilding. You base a players worth based on what he has done over his career
BlueWoof_#39
Senior List
Exactly right...that's why it's stupid for Carlton to give him away willy nilly. I agree 12 is just a couple of picks generous of what he's worth but bottom line he's contracted. If he was a real man he would show resilience and mental strength by proving his worth at Carlton under a new regime...which would lead into a decent paycheck. As Bolton said its a blank canvas...but with his track record he'll prob just sook it up even more.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Exactly Yarran is contracted and bound to us.
If RFC wants us to release him to them they pay the price or wait under year and see how things turn out.
Silvani hopefully will hold very firm for their Pick12.
We should not give in to these poachers, the RFC demenour has been poor.
Obviously Yarran is well worth pick 12 it's not over paying.
Dan Richardson has stated pick15 to 18 is about the mark.
So get it done or walk away simple, all this consternation and child'a play over his actual value.
If RFC wants us to release him to them they pay the price or wait under year and see how things turn out.
Silvani hopefully will hold very firm for their Pick12.
We should not give in to these poachers, the RFC demenour has been poor.
Obviously Yarran is well worth pick 12 it's not over paying.
Dan Richardson has stated pick15 to 18 is about the mark.
So get it done or walk away simple, all this consternation and child'a play over his actual value.
lol, worth pick 12? The him he's dreamin..
- Oct 5, 2004
- 13,295
- 13,982
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Richmond
Agree. Don't see value in the flaky flanker who picks and chooses when he wants to play. Time for Bolts to get into Yarrans ear and get him back on track for the blues next year.
BlueWoof_#39
Senior List
My name geoff
Premiership Player
- Jul 2, 2015
- 4,523
- 6,097
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Was referring to freeman
My name geoff
Premiership Player
- Jul 2, 2015
- 4,523
- 6,097
- AFL Club
- Carlton
I'm amazed at this Richmond rating system.
We as Carlton fans are telling you that if we get pick 12 for Yarran, we LOSE this trade. Yarran is a top 5 player for us, if he didn't want to leave there is no way we would accept a pick 12 for him. Pick 12 is the discounted, bad attitude, wants to leave but still contracted value of Yarran
Tiger fans continually trying to tell us yarrans worth is a waste of time as we know exactly how much he is worth.
More than everyone on our list other than Murphy, Gibbs, Cripps
Last edited:
You're kidding aren't you.
