List Mgmt. COLLINGWOOD Trade and F/A Discussion 2023

[KinderSmock]

Would like to use both our top picks this year
Hopefully someone like Reid at our first (or that tall back from Vic)
Then I’d be moving up a bit with our second to grab Moir - if that guy gets his mojo back we’d have a jet off the wing

We wouldn't need to move up to take Moir. He's on a slide. A bit like Draper, but without the injury concerns.

 

[SchuPie]

Not sure how we'd do that though? Have to throw in a future?

I’d say so

 

[gouki88]

A fast young bull mid like Newcombe
A mobile big defender

Are the highest priorities by the stretch of the MCG

And that’s only the tip of our problems

Anyone who thinks that we can persist with more than 30% of the below and win a flag is delusional

Ginn
Adams
Sidebottom
WHE
Lipinski
Mitchell
Crisp
Pendles ( more so age)
Howe

Your crusade against Ginnivan is hilarious in its delusion.

 

[Roverjg]

This.

If Allan and Reef come on I think our midfield woes will be short-lived. 2x quick/tall mids.

Big ‘if’.

A shame McKay from North is so pricey. Could be the FB we need.

I was keen for McKay last year. He has been extremely poor this year. Part due to giving too much of a start & lack of defensive support. In the games I watched he appeared all at sea vs Lions Daniher monstered him and kicked 5, as did King (St.K). Both Finlayson & Buddy could have had days out on him but for bad kicking. Langford at Essendon was too quick for him and kicked 4. Champion data indicates 2.2 av kicked on him

He is not worth the $$$ being bandied around for him.

 

[SchuPie]

I was keen for McKay last year. He has been extremely poor this year. Part due to giving too much of a start & lack of defensive support. In the games I watched he appeared all at sea vs Lions Daniher monstered him and kicked 5, as did King (St.K). Both Finlayson & Buddy could have had days out on him but for bad kicking. Langford at Essendon was too quick for him and kicked 4. Champion data indicates 2.2 av kicked on him

He is not worth the $$$ being bandied around for him.

Agree, nor the compensation

 

[TradeDraft]

I was keen for McKay last year. He has been extremely poor this year. Part due to giving too much of a start & lack of defensive support. In the games I watched he appeared all at sea vs Lions Daniher monstered him and kicked 5, as did King (St.K). Both Finlayson & Buddy could have had days out on him but for bad kicking. Langford at Essendon was too quick for him and kicked 4. Champion data indicates 2.2 av kicked on him

He is not worth the $$$ being bandied around for him.

Might do better with a Better playing at a Good Club

 

[manicpie]

We wouldn't need to move up to take Moir. He's on a slide. A bit like Draper, but without the injury concerns.

They won't let Moir slip too far, has too much talent and there would be heaps of clubs who would think they could get the best out of him. Moir and Archer would be a dream draft for us

 

[manicpie]

James Jordan and ned Flanders would go a long way to helping our age profile and pace issues

 

[Drought Break]

James Jordan and ned Flanders would go a long way to helping our age profile and pace issues

stupid sexy Flanders, need some of that maximum mobility

 

[manicpie]

stupid sexy Flanders, need some of that maximum mobility

I actually wrote ned just for a flanders gif but I love it

 

[Piewithsauce13]

Watching the giants game would love Briggs! He is a competitive beast. Imagine him in the middle withJDG, NDaicos!

 

[Jen2310]

Watching the giants game would love Briggs! He is a competitive beast. Imagine him in the middle withJDG, NDaicos!

GIANTS LOOK TO LOCK IN EMERGING RUCK​

GREATER Western Sydney has moved to lock in emerging ruckman Kieren Briggs early, following a stunning second half of 2023.

The 23-year-old signed a two-year deal at the end of last season through to the end of 2024 after playing nine games across his first four seasons at the Giants.

But now Greater Western Sydney is working on a deal to extend the 201cm ruckman's contract through to free agency at the end of 2026.

Power backman re-signs, Eagle eyes extension, Crow presses for new deal

Check out all the latest trade news from around the League

www.afl.com.au

 

[stormskye]

Watching the giants game would love Briggs! He is a competitive beast. Imagine him in the middle withJDG, NDaicos!

I’d love a few of their list

 

[windchimes]

A fast young bull mid like Newcombe
A mobile big defender

Are the highest priorities by the stretch of the MCG

And that’s only the tip of our problems

Anyone who thinks that we can persist with more than 30% of the below and win a flag is delusional

Ginn
Adams
Sidebottom
WHE
Lipinski
Mitchell
Crisp
Pendles ( more so age)
Howe

So who'll run out and play for us if we're sacking all of those guys, some of our best and most consistant performers?

Straughnie?

 

[Roverjg]

It does not appear like Kreuger is going to make it as a forward, nor Begg as a ruckman. There are rave reviews on Steene but some think he is a bit small for a ruck but will be a KPF. Can any of these 3 be developed into a FB?

On SM-N975F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[TradeDraft]

It does not appear like Kreuger is going to make it as a forward, nor Begg as a ruckman. There are rave reviews on Steene but some think he is a bit small for a ruck but will be a KPF. Can any of these 3 be developed into a FB?

On SM-N975F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Steene is 201cm-204cm so he is Tall Enough

 

[stormskye]

It does not appear like Kreuger is going to make it as a forward, nor Begg as a ruckman. There are rave reviews on Steene but some think he is a bit small for a ruck but will be a KPF. Can any of these 3 be developed into a FB?

On SM-N975F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Only kreuger could play at fb. Good agility for a tall, he was playing down back for Geelong

 

[manicpie]

It does not appear like Kreuger is going to make it as a forward, nor Begg as a ruckman. There are rave reviews on Steene but some think he is a bit small for a ruck but will be a KPF. Can any of these 3 be developed into a FB?

On SM-N975F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Short answer is no

 

[manicpie]

Only kreuger could play at fb. Good agility for a tall, he was playing down back for Geelong

Geelong played him in defence and he was terrible. Doesn't have any footy smarts to play defence

 

[GreekLunatic]

I’d even go after riccardi from gws

 

[manicpie]

Just a lazy 36 disposals from the UN signed Sam Flanders. Get it done pies

 

[sr36]

What's the issue with Ginnivan? I haven't been his biggest supporter but I felt he played well last night.

We lost. Some want to burn the place down with as many in it as possible.

 

[sr36]

Just a lazy 36 disposals from the UN signed Sam Flanders. Get it done pies

It might be hard to juggle working for the UN and footy.

 

[No SPIN]

Cant go into another season with Mitchell, pendles, Lipinski, Adams anywhere near the midfield. With sidey and Howe also nearing retirement we need to flag this season before the dreaded "rebuild" word starts to arise.

We also have the weakest ruck division in the comp. Amazed we are still top of the ladder.

Maybe we are on Top because the alarm in your post is exaggerated?

 

[Rusty Beam]

Just a lazy 36 disposals from the UN signed Sam Flanders. Get it done pies

If we are after Flanders, I also want Hollands. Package them up together.

Probably willing to offer up our first for both with some kind of combo of later (third/fourths) coming back our way.