List Mgmt. COLLINGWOOD Trade and F/A Discussion 2023

[Bianconeri]

Matthieson would struggle to get a run in our twos.

He’d be our clear best mid in the twos.

 

[BigVic]

Have faith in Wrighty

 

[manicpie]

He’d be our clear best mid in the twos.

Easily

 

[Apex36]

He’d be our clear best mid in the twos.

Yeah I don’t understand why people come up with stuff like that. He’s probably a touch above VFL level but not quite good enough to be a genuine AFL mid.

He’d easily be our best mid in the VFL and honestly is going to be a very good acquisition for any club that lands him, assuming nobody takes him as a SSP signing.

 

[sr36]

He might have broken his hand while signing the contract so they decided to keep it quiet

I just hope that he did it electronically on docusign. That bloke could get a paper cut that severed a finger

 

[Hong Kong Pie]

Is the talk around Smith for next year or 2025?

 

[Apex36]

Is the talk around Smith for next year or 2025?

Next year, he’s OOC in 2024.

 

[Chrispiesssss]

What a midfield , Smith , Naicos , De Goey,

Thats some wheels

More importantly the best looking midfield in the comp

It gets better…. Naicos & Jaicos commented.

 

[localfootylegend23]

Between Reid and Kelly, that jumper has seen about 7 games in the last 10 years.

The curse of the #20 is real

 

[Anzacday]

It gets better…. Naicos & Jaicos commented.

Could be sooner than later…

The 2024 mid-season trades that just make sense as it stands

The official trade period ended last Wednesday, and we’ve already seen significant trade stories break since.

www.sen.com.au

 

[neilk]

It gets better…. Naicos & Jaicos commented.

What does he mean by "Barry's Trifecta"?

 

[sr36]

What does he mean by "Barry's Trifecta"?

Barry's is an workout brand.

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

Barry's is an workout brand.

 

[SchuPie]

It gets better…. Naicos & Jaicos commented.

So Smith at mid-year and Holmes at end of year...?

 

[manicpie]

He's a gorgeous man with a ripping body. I could have been like that if I wasn't so ugly and lazy. It's a no for smith based on my jealousy

 

[sr36]

He's a gorgeous man with a ripping body. I could have been like that if I wasn't so ugly and lazy. It's a no for smith based on my jealousy

Forget Smith. Delist Lippa. Chase Clarry. Draft a couple of Cameron Ling types.

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

What does he mean by "Barry's Trifecta"?

AFL, NRL Stars Ready as BARRY Vodka Launches Nationwide

BARRY is here.Alter Ego Drinks is proud to announce the launch of BARRY, a new Australian-made ready-to-drink product made with Shochu, Vodka, and

www.miragenews.com

 

[WakeUpPies]

He's a gorgeous man with a ripping body.

Are you referring to Naicos or Pendles or both?

(Or Taz)

 

[manicpie]

Forget Smith. Delist Lippa. Chase Clarry. Draft a couple of Cameron Ling types.

then that wouldn't be fair on them because not even the manic is that ugly

 

[manicpie]

Are you referring to Naicos or Pendles or both?

(Or Taz)

I'm not a polygamist so i'd have to say Pendles

 

[Gone Critical]

Yep. It's a growing trend. Here in the Southern villages as well.
A bit of fun for the kids.

Spread far and wide then. Us of Celtic/Irish heritage could either claim appropriation or pride that our little fetivities have spread so wide. The wide part probably comes from the Yanks pinching it.

 

[Pistol Night]

Forget Smith. Delist Lippa. Chase Clarry. Draft a couple of Cameron Ling types.

 

[Gone Critical]

What I didn't bring up, is that, in his career at the Brions he was never the 1st or 2nd banana.

He has that chance now, I also was probably a bit simplistic in the 'development' part.

Mcstay was third tall behind big Joe and Hipwood
I think our role allows him to flourish more as key forward
He looked so good in preliminary

This is one that keeps being bought up but its not true. McStay was mainly no 1 or 2 KPF at Brissie. Daniher was there for his last 2 seasons only and the Daniher/Hipwood/McStay combo only stepped out in 20 something games.

Dan was exactly what we wanted this year. 2IC to Brody who is our dominant KPF. At Brissie he usually ranked around 4th to 7th in the teams goal scoring table and was around a similar mark this year for us although could have gone higher with more games.

It's unlikely he boosts production score wise much past what its been over 10 seasons but by all means hope. But he has spent plenty of time as 1 or 2 main KPFs at Brisbane in the past. 1 to 1.5 goals per game is an excellent output for him IMHO

 

[sr36]

This is one that keeps being bought up but its not true. McStay was mainly no 1 or 2 KPF at Brissie. Daniher was there for his last 2 seasons only and the Daniher/Hipwood/McStay combo only stepped out in 20 something games.

Dan was exactly what we wanted this year. 2IC to Brody who is our dominant KPF. At Brissie he usually ranked around 4th to 7th in the teams goal scoring table and was around a similar mark this year for us although could have gone higher with more games.

It's unlikely he boosts production score wise much past what its been over 10 seasons but by all means hope. But he has spent plenty of time as 1 or 2 main KPFs at Brisbane in the past. 1 to 1.5 goals per game is an excellent output for him IMHO

The ranking of the respective forwards in a team isn't really how it works. His role has changed with us. For Brisbane his main role was hitting up the ground, for us it's providing a contest in the hotspot.

He's unlikely to kick as many goals as Checkers because he's not as complete a player with less avenues to score. His goals will mainly come from marking contests in the hotspot, whereas Checkers gets them in a multitude of ways.

 

[whiskeytown]

This is one that keeps being bought up but its not true. McStay was mainly no 1 or 2 KPF at Brissie. Daniher was there for his last 2 seasons only and the Daniher/Hipwood/McStay combo only stepped out in 20 something games.

Dan was exactly what we wanted this year. 2IC to Brody who is our dominant KPF. At Brissie he usually ranked around 4th to 7th in the teams goal scoring table and was around a similar mark this year for us although could have gone higher with more games.

It's unlikely he boosts production score wise much past what its been over 10 seasons but by all means hope. But he has spent plenty of time as 1 or 2 main KPFs at Brisbane in the past. 1 to 1.5 goals per game is an excellent output for him IMHO

With his accuracy Mcstay could’ve kicked close to 40 goals this year had he had continuity in his football

Got a good run at it in his last 9 games and kicked 17.4 as a result

Definitely capable of more than 1 goal a game average.

More like 1.5-1.8 goals a game average… like mihocek

I struggle to seperate them into #1 or #2 KPF

And don’t see a need to.