List Mgmt. Our Trade/FA, Suburban & Country Town Thread

Remove this Banner Ad

Perryman attracted interest from Port Adelaide, Adelaide and Hawthorn throughout the year, but the Magpies made a significant offer that turned his head late in the season.
Collingwood had learned that running defender John Noble wanted a trade to the Gold Coast and then key defender Mark Keane decided against pursuing a trade that would have seen him return to the Magpies and instead extended his time with the Crows.

That cleared room for Perryman to not only fill several roles but arrive without having cost a draft pick with the Giant shaping as a perfect replacement for Steele Sidebottom when his career ends. The Magpies are keen to add a tall defender to the mix to replace premiership defender Nathan Murphy who was forced into early retirement due to concussion.
Perryman spent the weekend weighing up his offers before deciding to join the club his family has long supported. He is expected to play a range of roles at Collingwood including in the midfield as well as defence after showing his talent as a reliable defender in 129 matches for the Giants.

Perryman was a major attraction for several clubs as he is an unrestricted free agent, meaning he can move to his club of choice without being traded. He would likely command compensation at the end of the first round for the Giants due to the length and potential size of his contract.

From the Riverina, Perryman is one of several Giants considering their future, with Isaac Cumming joining Adelaide as an unrestricted free agent.
The Giants remain hopeful of retaining in-demand midfielder James Peatling, who has several clubs including Melbourne, St Kilda, Collingwood and Adelaide interested, while Conor Stone may also remain as opportunities to play AFL open up.
Midfielder Xavier O’Halloran has attracted interest from the Western Bulldogs and swingman Wade Derksen wants to join Melbourne, but the Giants say they are contracted and won’t be traded.
Collingwood is also waiting on a decision from small forward Joe Richards who is yet to decide whether to continue with the Magpies



Pick 18 also on the table.



The Lions have picks 18, 56, 69 and 92 in their hand and will likely look to maximise the value of pick 18 to accumulate enough points to match the bid.

Half the clubs in the competition are putting their most serious bids to the Gold Coast to get pick 12 as the Suns need points for academy graduate Leo Lombard, but they may turn their attention to pick 18 once that question is resolved.

The Lions will also need to keep in mind that academy prospect Daniel Annable is also due to graduate ahead of the 2025 national draft with clubs pondering whether they may have to trade out a required player at some point to achieve that goal.
 
As Jen said earlier and others have said prior

I think pies future 1st + Noble = GC pick 12

It’s a win - win

GC

  • get rid of a pick they don’t want
  • get noble
-still have points for academy kid
- still have pick 6 for Rioli (and additional tigers later or future picks)

PIES

  • turn noble exit into lemonade
  • ditch the future first they won’t want to use on mcguane next year
  • in the process switch 1st rd picks into a better draft

~~~~~~~

The only way another club gets it is to offer up a likely better future 1st pick… eg St Kilda

Otherwise no other club will offer up a future first for it and a player they want

GC only really targeting Rioli and Noble

So I think it gets done ✅

Edit: maybe a GC future third comes back as part of the deal for mcguane points

The question is what do pies do with pick 12?

Macrae publicly stating he wants established players

Or are picks this high, in a strong draft the exception?
 
Last edited:
As Jen said earlier and others have said prior

I think pies future 1st + Noble = GC pick 12

It’s a win - win

GC

  • get rid of a pick they don’t want
  • get noble
-still have points for academy kid
- still have pick 6 for Rioli (and additional tigers later or future picks)

PIES

  • turn noble exit into lemonade
  • ditch the future first they won’t want to use on mcguane next year
  • in the process switch 1st rd picks into a better draft

~~~~~~~

The only way another club gets it is to offer up a likely better future 1st pick… eg St Kilda

Otherwise no other club will offer up a future first for it and a player they want

GC only really targeting Rioli and Noble

So I think it gets done ✅

The question is what do pies do with pick 12?

Macrae publicly stating he wants established players

Or are picks this high, in a strong draft the exception?
Based on where we finished this year our future first alone should do that trade given both clubs benefit (don’t think Tom is a lock top 20 prospect yet though)… so in my eyes giving noble away for free
 

Log in to remove this ad.

As Jen said earlier and others have said prior

I think pies future 1st + Noble = GC pick 12

It’s a win - win

GC

  • get rid of a pick they don’t want
  • get noble
-still have points for academy kid
- still have pick 6 for Rioli (and additional tigers later or future picks)

PIES

  • turn noble exit into lemonade
  • ditch the future first they won’t want to use on mcguane next year
  • in the process switch 1st rd picks into a better draft

~~~~~~~

The only way another club gets it is to offer up a likely better future 1st pick… eg St Kilda

Otherwise no other club will offer up a future first for it and a player they want

GC only really targeting Rioli and Noble

So I think it gets done ✅

The question is what do pies do with pick 12?

Macrae publicly stating he wants established players

Or are picks this high, in a strong draft the exception?
So we are effectively giving away Noble for free? Fck that!
 
Bartel would be a massive coup. Very good operator.

My favourite non Pies player. Won many a game for Geelong sitting back on the goal line like a goal keeper when no one else in the league even thought of doing that intercepting shots that would have otherwise gone through.

Smart footballer, if that is transitioned across to the operations side would be a good get.
 
As Jen said earlier and others have said prior

I think pies future 1st + Noble = GC pick 12

It’s a win - win

GC

  • get rid of a pick they don’t want
  • get noble
-still have points for academy kid
- still have pick 6 for Rioli (and additional tigers later or future picks)

PIES

  • turn noble exit into lemonade
  • ditch the future first they won’t want to use on mcguane next year
  • in the process switch 1st rd picks into a better draft

~~~~~~~

The only way another club gets it is to offer up a likely better future 1st pick… eg St Kilda

Otherwise no other club will offer up a future first for it and a player they want

GC only really targeting Rioli and Noble

So I think it gets done ✅

The question is what do pies do with pick 12?

Macrae publicly stating he wants established players

Or are picks this high, in a strong draft the exception?
I reckon we would want a 2nd round pick or a future 2nd coming back to us to do that deal. If we finish in a similar position as we did this year, then we would get virtually nothing for Noble in your original scenario.
 
As Jen said earlier and others have said prior

I think pies future 1st + Noble = GC pick 12

It’s a win - win

GC

  • get rid of a pick they don’t want
  • get noble
-still have points for academy kid
- still have pick 6 for Rioli (and additional tigers later or future picks)

PIES

  • turn noble exit into lemonade
  • ditch the future first they won’t want to use on mcguane next year
  • in the process switch 1st rd picks into a better draft

~~~~~~~

The only way another club gets it is to offer up a likely better future 1st pick… eg St Kilda

Otherwise no other club will offer up a future first for it and a player they want

GC only really targeting Rioli and Noble

So I think it gets done ✅

The question is what do pies do with pick 12?

Macrae publicly stating he wants established players

Or are picks this high, in a strong draft the exception?

No way on earth would I be doing that deal. I would rather trade Noble for pick 20 and go from there
 
The level of interest. So much for his QF performance settling his future at GWS 😂
Play one bad game and everyone forgets about the good ones silly
If we can get him it will be great
As for Houston we would be silly not to try and get him, dam good player
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

As Jen said earlier and others have said prior

I think pies future 1st + Noble = GC pick 12

It’s a win - win

GC

  • get rid of a pick they don’t want
  • get noble
-still have points for academy kid
- still have pick 6 for Rioli (and additional tigers later or future picks)

PIES

  • turn noble exit into lemonade
  • ditch the future first they won’t want to use on mcguane next year
  • in the process switch 1st rd picks into a better draft

~~~~~~~

The only way another club gets it is to offer up a likely better future 1st pick… eg St Kilda

Otherwise no other club will offer up a future first for it and a player they want

GC only really targeting Rioli and Noble

So I think it gets done ✅

The question is what do pies do with pick 12?

Macrae publicly stating he wants established players

Or are picks this high, in a strong draft the exception?
How about 26 for noble and we change pick 12 for our F1 in two seperate transactions?
 
As Jen said earlier and others have said prior

I think pies future 1st + Noble = GC pick 12

It’s a win - win

GC

  • get rid of a pick they don’t want
  • get noble
-still have points for academy kid
- still have pick 6 for Rioli (and additional tigers later or future picks)

PIES

  • turn noble exit into lemonade
  • ditch the future first they won’t want to use on mcguane next year
  • in the process switch 1st rd picks into a better draft

~~~~~~~

The only way another club gets it is to offer up a likely better future 1st pick… eg St Kilda

Otherwise no other club will offer up a future first for it and a player they want

GC only really targeting Rioli and Noble

So I think it gets done ✅

The question is what do pies do with pick 12?

Macrae publicly stating he wants established players

Or are picks this high, in a strong draft the exception?
Noble + future second > pick 12 would be more reasonable.
 
As Jen said earlier and others have said prior

I think pies future 1st + Noble = GC pick 12

It’s a win - win

GC

  • get rid of a pick they don’t want
  • get noble
-still have points for academy kid
- still have pick 6 for Rioli (and additional tigers later or future picks)

PIES

  • turn noble exit into lemonade
  • ditch the future first they won’t want to use on mcguane next year
  • in the process switch 1st rd picks into a better draft

~~~~~~~

The only way another club gets it is to offer up a likely better future 1st pick… eg St Kilda

Otherwise no other club will offer up a future first for it and a player they want

GC only really targeting Rioli and Noble

So I think it gets done ✅

The question is what do pies do with pick 12?

Macrae publicly stating he wants established players

Or are picks this high, in a strong draft the exception?
It’s mad that posters actually think this is a good outcome!
 
Tom Morris said today Melbourne asked him to explore options, but Clarry wants to stay. Conversely, Petracca wants out but Melbourne want to keep him, he would move tomorrow if he could. So two different scenarios, if Clarry goes I suspect it is to St Kilda as they have the room to fit his salary in. The only thing stopping us getting Trac is draft capital, next year however we can trade 2 years into the future and all bets are off.
Perhaps by shipping Oliver off and improving culture the dees are more hopeful of retaining Petracca?
 
I thought we managed to put that scenario to bed the day the Noble trade request was made public too
Apparently not! I genuinely don’t get it my best guess is they basically want to salary dump Noble 🤷‍♂️
 
It’s not for free… it’s for a pick upgrade.

Pies upgrade a higher pick next year into a lower pick this year
Not if we miss the 8 again, in which case it becomes Noble + top 10 for pick 12.

We haven’t done well with trading future picks previously
 
It’s cliche that you are always right and everyone else always wrong !

(We’ll just ignore the plenty times you are wrong 😉)

I think you should nominate yourself for coach and president
I definitely wouldn’t do a worse job than you if we’re going off this suggestion!
 

Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. Our Trade/FA, Suburban & Country Town Thread

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top