List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade and FA

[Horaceg]

So let’s say Houston deal falls through, what would we get for Richards

I think we could get 30-40 goals

 

[stormskye]

Nope

This would be a weeks holidays on your precious board

 

[Mollythedolly]

I wish I could make money out of getting drunk and talking shit like Pete and Dud did.

Just need a sponsor for your BF posts.

 

[jimmy35]

The way Cornes is really hammering home the Collingwood doomsdaying makes me think he’s heard there’s a good chance we’re getting Houston

Between the Perryman shit talking and now the “cliff is coming” stuff when we were mentioned in the Houston dealings, it feels like he knows something and is super salty about it

Could very well be, sooky campaigner of the highest order.

 

[tmpies01]

Will be shocked if Houston isn’t a Collingwood player by mid next week. If GC and Port want our players then be prepared to give us what we want

Media are pushing Carlton into this because they know we’re his only landing spot now and wouldn’t that be boring for them…

 

[JuniorB]

Sticking it up the scum would just be a delightful side effect.

 

[Doc1763]

Will be shocked if Houston isn’t a Collingwood player by mid next week. If GC and Port want our players then be prepared to give us what we want

Media are pushing Carlton into this because they know we’re his only landing spot now and wouldn’t that be boring for them…

unfortunately, even if everything is agreed to, they wont be allowed to announce it until just before the deadline.

 

[whiskeytown]

What’s the go with Charlie Clarke?
He is someone we could look to bring in to replace Richards’ spot as a developing small forward.

From what I’ve gathered at VFL level he has been ordinary and was ordinary in his afl debut.

I think he gets delisted so would be available

 

[jmac70]

Will be shocked if Houston isn’t a Collingwood player by mid next week. If GC and Port want our players then be prepared to give us what we want

Media are pushing Carlton into this because they know we’re his only landing spot now and wouldn’t that be boring for them…

Don’t be too confident. It’s not done yet.

 

[whiskeytown]

So let’s say Houston deal falls through, what would we get for Richards

Ports pick in the late 30s or a future 2nd (much the same)

 

[MooreDaicos]

What’s the go with Charlie Clarke?
He is someone we could look to bring in to replace Richards’ spot as a developing small forward.

I would love Charlie Clarke. From memory, he's the one I wanted in his draft year. Can't remember how he played but I must've seen something to really want him. He's a Pie supporter too.
Anyone got his draft video handy?

 

[Bramax]

Nope

If you think that, you should read it then

 

[BEEG]

Out
Future 1st
Richards
Noble

In
Perryman
Houston
Tomilson

That's a huge trade period.

 

[Axl the great]

All we need is a healthy list next year to be back in contention. These 2 will be the icing on the cake

Spot on, if we had taken 2 or 3 more moments this year we end up in 5th or 6th spot.
Even with everything against us the margins are that small.

 

[Jafo]

I can't believe that JFN is leaving us without a premiership medal around his neck. A more deserving player I cannot think of.

Yeah, JFN is one of my favs over last few years. Wish him well like Adz Treloar.

The number one player for me that I believe deserved a Flag was Bucks.

 

[No SPIN]

unfortunately, even if everything is agreed to, they wont be allowed to announce it until just before the deadline.

Why?

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Out
Future 1st
Richards
Noble

In
Perryman
Houston
Tomilson

That's a huge trade period.

Not convinced we need Tomlinson though given limited list spots. Can’t see if he’s much different to Frampton, just another of the same ilk? I’d rather hold on to Dean and put some hope in eyres fitness rather than just list Tomlinson for a year or so until he retires at the same time as a lot of players. Trying reef in defence too is another option

We perhaps should back in the players we have.

 

[Pragmatic Shill]

The one thing I'm half-concerned on is the claim that we have great small forward depth so Richards leaving doesn't really hurt us. While our best 23 small forward brigade is as good as any, the depth we have to my knowledge is Harrison who will obviously miss the majority of next year. What happens if we get an injury there?

 

[Pragmatic Shill]

Why?

It's the deal Hutchy cooked up with the AFL.

 

[No SPIN]

I would love Charlie Clarke. From memory, he's the one I wanted in his draft year. Can't remember how he played but I must've seen something to really want him. He's a Pie supporter too.
Anyone got his draft video handy?

Wasn’t he the big bodied kid with poor skills and no pace?

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

The one thing I'm half-concerned on is the claim that we have great small forward depth so Richards leaving doesn't really hurt us. While our best 23 small forward brigade is as good as any, the depth we have to my knowledge is Harrison who will obviously miss the majority of next year. What happens if we get an injury there?

We bat deep with goal kicking midfielders, it’s an easy enough spot to cover

 

[stormskye]

Not convinced we need Tomlinson though given limited list spots. Can’t see if he’s much different to Frampton, just another of the same ilk? I’d rather hold on to Dean and put some hope in eyres fitness rather than just list Tomlinson for a year or so until he retires at the same time as a lot of players. Trying reef in defence too is another option

We perhaps should back in the players we have.

If Leppa wants him and thinks he could
Improve us, I’d be confident in backing that. One of the best defenders ever to play AFL so reckon he knows how to improve us there.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Wasn’t he the big bodied kid with poor skills and no pace?

And an idiot brother who got a lifetime ban running onto the ground for Bruzzys 200th. That’s enough of a red flag for me!

 

[MooreDaicos]

Wasn’t he the big bodied kid with poor skills and no pace?

TBH I can't remember. I need to watch his highlights again unless I'm confusing him with another.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

If Leppa wants him and thinks he could
Improve us, I’d be confident in backing that. One of the best defenders ever to play AFL so reckon he knows how to improve us there.

Would be a shame to see Kreugs and Dean delisted for a 31 year old backup. We still need some open slots for the ND as well, possible we only will have one live pick