- May 12, 2016
- 1,537
- 2,615
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Reef at 40 kgs is Better than TomlinsonHe'd want to stack on a ton of muscle
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
AFLW 2024 - Round 8 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Reef at 40 kgs is Better than TomlinsonHe'd want to stack on a ton of muscle
Cmon bro, that's not even remotely close to being true. I hope you won't be one that hangs shit on reef when he's playing HB and getting destroyed. Reef is lucky not to have been delisted, it's like putting your faith in a country footballerReef at 40 kgs is Better than Tomlinson
The point I’m trying to make is about TomlinsonCmon bro, that's not even remotely close to being true. I hope you won't be one that hangs shit on reef when he's playing HB and getting destroyed. Reef is lucky not to have been delisted, it's like putting your faith in a country footballer
Fair enough but reef isn't the answer and Frampton and Dean aren't eitherThe point I’m trying to make is about Tomlinson
I don’t rate him at all.. he’s hopeless
He gets lost in aerial
Contests , hardly spoils ,has poor decision making and won’t offer us anything other than being classified as a tall defender
And I do rate reef and see a future for him
Let’s see what happens with reefFair enough but reef isn't the answer and Frampton and Dean aren't either
Don't forget that reef has only played 2 games in defence and they were pretty average. It's not something I'd be hanging my hat on. I'm not even sure he'll get games next year, purely a depth optionLet’s see what happens with reef
I still think he will make it
Frampton is average but he has done some very nice jobs for us and can be more than serviceable
I do share some of your lack of excitement. When he was at the giants, I was hopeful we could land him. But since going to The demons, I’ve seen nothing that screams “pick me”. Guy is 31 with an average of 9 games per season over past 5 years…The point I’m trying to make is about Tomlinson
I don’t rate him at all.. he’s hopeless
He gets lost in aerial
Contests , hardly spoils ,has poor decision making and won’t offer us anything other than being classified as a tall defender
And I do rate reef and see a future for him
I’m not sure what the clubs plans for reef areDon't forget that reef has only played 2 games in defence and they were pretty average. It's not something I'd be hanging my hat on. I'm not even sure he'll get games next year, purely a depth option
I’m just disappointed that if Tomlinson is the answer, how did we get to the point where we needed to ask that question?!Fair enough but reef isn't the answer and Frampton and Dean aren't either
Membrey kicked 30 goals last year and has plenty of times, he has shown over 10 years that he is a decent AFL player, how could you even compare him with Krueger who finally got a run at it this year and proved that he is not much good.I do share some of your lack of excitement. When he was at the giants, I was hopeful we could land him. But since going to The demons, I’ve seen nothing that screams “pick me”. Guy is 31 with an average of 9 games per season over past 5 years…
And whilst we’re on it, Membrey also seems a reach. There’s a reason saints delisted him, with him almost being the biggest afl headline / tragedy in recent memory.
Krueger must really be a liability body wise, for him to offer less at his age
Krueger is a terrible mark, kind of defeats the purpose being tall and quick if you can’t mark.Membrey kicked 30 goals last year and has plenty of times, he has shown over 10 years that he is a decent AFL player, how could you even compare him with Krueger who finally got a run at it this year and proved that he is not much good.
I’m just disappointed that if Tomlinson is the answer, how did we get to the point where we needed to ask that question?!
Haha De Mattia is an inside mid.De mattia is not an inside mid.
The key missing element is inside mid.
(Nor is Perryman an inside mid)
He could be anything or nothing, it’s ludicrous to be putting a ceiling on what he can do without giving him the opportunity to prove himself.Haha De Mattia is an inside mid.
He had good foot skills and was able to inch his way to become a great full back.Dustin Fletcher was built like a ruler
I'd like it. I was a fan of him in his draft. Grew up a pies fan too.