List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2015

[Ant85]

Who knows what will happen with Trelor but what a lot of people forget is Bucks coached most of the GWS kids in the U16s

By all reports they loved him that was one of the reasons we landed Adams

Hope it works this time around.

 

[Bucksboys]

Witts to the Bulldogs is the word.

That's smart, the Bulldogs are going to be a serious threat, doing everything right lately where it counts

 

[Men of Steele]

Pi

That's smart, the Bulldogs are going to be a serious threat, doing everything right lately where it counts

Pick 14ish they may have, could be just about right for Weideman. Minson is out

 

[loki04]

Why exactly do you think this? Based on what information?

Its been flogged to death so I'll let you do the research.

Lets put it this way if he asks for a trade at the end of his next contract ie end of next year I wouldn't be surprised in the least.

 

[Apex36]

And you might be disappointed.

Doubt it, chump.

 

[Buena]

W

Its been flogged to death so I'll let you do the research.

Lets put it this way if he asks for a trade at the end of his next contract ie end of next year I wouldn't be surprised in the least.

who are you talking about here?

 

[loki04]

Witts to the Bulldogs is the word.

For what exactly?

Are clubs trying to "gift" them a flag for equalization purposes?

 

[soreplums]

Witts to the Bulldogs is the word.

first rounder and minson? Or do we ask for libba?

 

[loki04]

first rounder and minson? Or do we ask for libba?

Lol libba. Type not needed.

-I'd ask for stringer and throw our 1st rounder in to seal it too.

 

[soreplums]

Lol libba. Type not needed.

-I'd ask for stringer and throw our 1st rounder in to seal it too.

I like the way you think!

Ok so the plan is Witts and first round for stringer.

Scharenberg first round from Adelaide/port plus top up for treloar

 

[loki04]

I like the way you think!

Ok so the plan is Witts and first round for stringer.

Scharenberg first round from Adelaide/port plus top up for treloar

Im there!

 

[loki04]

W

who are you talking about here?

 

[Ketchup]

I love how the worse case scenario comes in. The article says "until.he works his way into seniors" it could be a lot worse. It could say "he is wanting to go home"

 

[Madagascar]

FFS we traded pick 15 for Woods

Exactamundo.

If you look at what past ruckmen have been traded for in the past, Witts is worth a pick between 5-10 IMO. In fact, wouldn't be surprized if he nets Essendon's pick 4.

 

[Madagascar]

If it's between us and Richmond for Treloar, it might not be clear sailing.

The more Richmond win these big games, the more ahead of us they are in terms of premiership contenders, the more attractive they are to someone like Treloar.

Agreed but on the flip side, the worse position they are to trade for Treloar. I worry about this too, I hope Richmond finish 5-8 and win one final and get spanked in the second round of finals. Perfect result.

What's in our favour is we have some decent blokes, quite a few in fact around Treloar's age, that is the bigger key in my opinion in obtaining the services of Treloar.

 

[Bard]

If it's between us and Richmond for Treloar, it might not be clear sailing.

The more Richmond win these big games, the more ahead of us they are in terms of premiership contenders, the more attractive they are to someone like Treloar.

I don't know.. Normally I'd agree but for a player willingly leaving GWS (and easily in their best 22) Premierships can't be his #1 priority.

 

[Madagascar]

One of the things in Collingwood's favour is that we have ANZAC day, so you're guaranteed that if you're a gun and injury free you'll play in the second most anticipated game of the year behind the granny.

 

[Bucksboys]

We are the Blockbuster club

 

[mike123]

mike123 wouldn't be able to hand that much Indigenous talent in one trade period, on top of Varcoe last season.

 

[BEEG]

Witts to the Bulldogs would be for there 1st pick so good chance they make the 8 let's say pick 12 I think that's pretty fair

No way we get anything less we better sign up Grundy long term if that's the case

 

[Bucksboys]

Kennedy and Scharenberg for the Crouch brothers

Everyone goes home

 

[Jelly Bean]

That's the problem.. the pick 6 curse.. hardly anyone escapes it

Our last pick 6 was Danny Roach but there have been far worse for other clubs

It's the Devil's triangle of picks

Roach was pick 7

 

[Jelly Bean]

If it's between us and Richmond for Treloar, it might not be clear sailing.

The more Richmond win these big games, the more ahead of us they are in terms of premiership contenders, the more attractive they are to someone like Treloar.

GWS need draft pick points. Our first rounder will be a lot more valuable to them than Richmond's. I think Treloar will see the value in our list.

 

[Quicky]

Leigh brown was a much underrated player

He was a much overrated player.

 

[Rusty Beam]

If cox marking improves out of sight u can play him as a key forward. Just as athletic as white is, but he has another foot in height. Imagine if he starting clunking them at 213cm. Oh boy wowee

IMO that's just not true. Cox is a fair way from being as athletic as white.

White is actually a ridiculous athlete. The problem is that he is mediocre footballer.

Cox is really athletic for a bloke his size.

Having said that I'm genuinely impressed by the continual improvement of Cox and it just pushes me even further into the trade witts camp.