List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2015

[Leviathan Pie]

Not stressing, looking at scenarios. He wants to stay im great with that, if not, he can go. Still an unknown quantity as far as im concerned.

Its just we've blown pick 6 on the guy

 

[Bucksboys]

Its just we've blown pick 6 on the guy

That's the problem.. the pick 6 curse.. hardly anyone escapes it

Our last pick 6 was Danny Roach but there have been far worse for other clubs

It's the Devil's triangle of picks

 

[popin]

Phantoms have Weideman going around pick 18

So phantom drafts on Bigfooty saying this then?

 

[Bucksboys]

So phantom drafts on Bigfooty saying this then?

What was it you said before?

Oh yes.. just stop

 

[BEEG]

Going after Vickery screams to me we are trading a ruck

I don't think Witts and Grundy can play in the same team

 

[popin]

What was it you said before?

Oh yes.. just stop

So it was a bigfooty phantom draft, it must be 100% right then

 

[Bay Pie]

Who do you want for Witts then it would be a mistake to trade him

I don't know much about the drafts, but it appears there may be some decent talls there.

BTW, I'm not advocating trading Witts, merely speculating, if the club decided too.

 

[Seedsfan]

Going after Vickery screams to me we are trading a ruck

I don't think Witts and Grundy can play in the same team

White, Lynch and Vickery all meant to be the quick fix all shit

 

[Bucksboys]

So it was a bigfooty phantom draft, it must be 100% right then

Or 100% phantom

 

[TradeDraft]

White, Lynch and Vickery all meant to be the quick fix all shit

Who said we are Definitely Chasing Vickery?

 

[Seedsfan]

Who said we are Definitely Chasing Vickery?

Not sure

 

[Bucksboys]

White, Lynch and Vickery all meant to be the quick fix all shit

Well it is the shit truck position, they don't have to be stars if you have the 2 quality key forwards, they are just there to do the Leigh Brown role and help out in the ruck now and then so we can carry the extra midfielder instead of 2 lumbering ruckmen

 

[PieMan!]

Going after Vickery screams to me we are trading a ruck

I don't think Witts and Grundy can play in the same team

I think they can, Grundy is starting to take those marks, and at least both ruckmen make a contest and kill the ball and bring it to ground, they both getting in the correct posture to take a mark and i think we need to give them time

 

[Ant85]

If it's between us and Richmond for Treloar, it might not be clear sailing.

The more Richmond win these big games, the more ahead of us they are in terms of premiership contenders, the more attractive they are to someone like Treloar.

 

[Seedsfan]

Well it is the shit truck position, they don't have to be stars if you have the 2 quality key forwards, they are just there to do the Leigh Brown role and help out in the ruck now and then so we can carry the extra midfielder instead of 2 lumbering ruckmen

Lynch was just cooked when we got him and White is no good. It is a hard spot to play well Brown did a great job of it

 

[Bucksboys]

Lynch was just cooked when we got him and White is no good. It is a hard spot to play well Brown did a great job of it

Yeah he had a purple patch just as we hit our window.. I think he was crap before and after but you can't deny the Anvil when the whips were cracking, he wrecked Geelong in that prelim

 

[ClaytonM]

You might be surprised at how much a player like Witts is worth to the right club.

And you might be disappointed.

 

[Seedsfan]

Yeah he had a purple patch just as we hit our window.. I think he was crap before and after but you can't deny the Anvil when the whips were cracking, he wrecked Geelong in that prelim

Leigh brown was a much underrated player

 

[ClaytonM]

Yeah I remember doesn't mean it will go the same way and I think Broomhead was very close to leaving tbh.

Why exactly do you think this? Based on what information?

 

[TradeDraft]

If it's between us and Richmond for Treloar, it might not be clear sailing.

The more Richmond win these big games, the more ahead of us they are in terms of premiership contenders, the more attractive they are to someone like Treloar.

Agree - Tigers could be a Major Threat as they can say we can win the Flag Next Year while we say we are a Few Seasons Away.

 

[Bucksboys]

Vickery would be no worse than anyone else, forwards that can ruck and do both well are like hens teeth

 

[BEEG]

Who knows what will happen with Trelor but what a lot of people forget is Bucks coached most of the GWS kids in the U16s

By all reports they loved him that was one of the reasons we landed Adams

 

[Bucksboys]

Agree - Tigers could be a Major Threat as they can say we can win the Flag Next Year while we say we are a Few Seasons Away.

Or he could see a club that hasn't been in the hunt for 35 years, is always one step from catastrophe and always teases

 

[Men of Steele]

Only because GWS can't take players, doesn't mean we won't trade Witts to someone else for one of the picks to satisfy GWS

"but Witts would not be part of that deal despite speculation"

Witts to the Bulldogs is the word.

 

[nahnah]

didn't richmond beat hawks and sydney last year then won 9 in a row to make the finals ..and lost by 100 week 1? Wont be worried about losing him to them until they actually win a final or 2