List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2015

[MeisterBot]

I would love us to Sign Mason Shaw as a De-Listed Free Agent

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2015-09-17/recruit-wagner-one-of-five-delisted-by-power

If Mitch Harvey has been delisted, we need to go for him. Insane that Port are getting rid of him and Shaw. Letting go of one was a possibility but I didn't imagine they'd turf both. They don't have any developing key forwards left, do they?

Harvey IMO would make for a good Hawkins type full forward if we can get the best out of him. Question marks on whether it'll happen, but hell he's delisted. It's a free hit and I'd rather have him at FF in the VFL than Gault.

 

[spartan-magpie]

Melksham to the Dees on 1.6 million over 4 years.

Madness.

Good. Hopefully they price themselves out of keeping hogan. He will be lovely up forward with Moore in a couple of seasons..

 

[mike123]

If Mitch Harvey has been delisted, we need to go for him. Insane that Port are getting rid of him and Shaw. Letting go of one was a possibility but I didn't imagine they'd turf both. They don't have any developing key forwards left, do they?

I think they're getting Dixon though?

 

[spartan-magpie]

$400k per year is absurd for a player of Melksham's modest talent no matter which way you spin it.

So what's your opinion on the rumoured 600k for kreuzer?

 

[MeisterBot]

I think they're getting Dixon though?

Probably, but I'm thinking about depth. They're losing Schulz for Dixon aren't they? They don't have any other developing key targets in the SANFL who are ready to step into the AFL soon.

I would be filthy if the club doesn't at least give Harvey a look. Put him at FF in the VFL and hope he turns into our Tom Hawkins. He won't be as good, but a similar kind of player.

 

[Apex36]

So what's your opinion on the rumoured 600k for kreuzer?

Also absurd.

 

[AshW]

Mitch Harvey is definitely worth a look. He is Matt Rendell's nephew as well.

 

[MooreTreloar]

Harvey is the nehew of Rendell isn't he?

Not that it makes a difference.

 

[JOELY]

They kept Butcher over both those guys. And my 60 old father is literally a better kick at goal than Butcher.

 

[spartan-magpie]

They kept Butcher over both those guys. And my 60 old father is literally a better kick at goal than Butcher.

Probably based on his marking ability. I'd definitely rookie him. 100%. Then get him kicking at goals 5-6 hours per day till round one. Would have to improve.

 

[Ketchup]

Who's this Harvey bloke? Im down for anyone who can play key forward. Gotta be better than gault

 

[Hardas]

If Mitch Harvey has been delisted, we need to go for him. Insane that Port are getting rid of him and Shaw. Letting go of one was a possibility but I didn't imagine they'd turf both. They don't have any developing key forwards left, do they?

Harvey IMO would make for a good Hawkins type full forward if we can get the best out of him. Question marks on whether it'll happen, but hell he's delisted. It's a free hit and I'd rather have him at FF in the VFL than Gault.

It seems a no-brainer for us, given our list needs.

 

[Bard]

Redden might be worth a look at along with Gorringe if we trade Witts. Would be better VFL back-up than Kreuzer in regards to TPP.

 

[ksardog]

$400k per year is absurd for a player of Melksham's modest talent no matter which way you spin it.

Wasnt clinton young on about the same money for us? Guarantee he plays more games than him

 

[Harry O]

Treloar - done.
Scharenberg - done.

Over to you Danger.

 

[ksardog]

Is Mitch Harvey who was de-listed from Port Adelaide worth a look at?

Wanted him in his draft year.

I think its rendells nephew, may get a chance with us. Though if he cant get a game ahead of butcher do u really think its worth getting him. No thanks

 

[Apex36]

Wasnt clinton young on about the same money for us? Guarantee he plays more games than him

Pretty sure Young was on $350k, max.

 

[Apex36]

Who's this Harvey bloke? Im down for anyone who can play key forward. Gotta be better than gault

Rendell's nephew. Forward/ruck from memory?

 

[ksardog]

Pretty sure Young was on $350k, max.

Hmm, still way overs

 

[Pedro]

They kept Butcher over both those guys. And my 60 old father is literally a better kick at goal than Butcher.

I was going to say the same thing. If Butcher can get games in front of Harvey and Shaw, how good could they possibly be?

 

[Hardas]

Wasnt clinton young on about the same money for us? Guarantee he plays more games than him

Touche [kinda] - I think Melbourne will regret that deal.

 

[Lefthanded]

Let's imagine the draft order isn't pushed back by Kreuzer or PP and that Richmond offer pick 12 for Treloar this year (and say 15 next year) and that GWS have the points to land Hopper by themselves with pick 8. They get Hopper and pick 12.

But if the draft order remains the same and GWS get Hopper, under our offer they get Hopper and pick 7.

I've bracketed Richmond's 1st round next year and our second round this year. But next years draft is better and our second round this year will help make up the points for Matthew Kennedy.

I understand that points can be carried over but I don't think GWS want to smash up a pick for points. It's far better imv from a GWS perspective that they land a top 5 pick in Hooper, land a top 7/8 pick in the draft which they get from us and Kennedy from points. Three top 20 picks and then close shop.

I agree with that so you got a like. It is however different to your original post.

 

[Apex36]

Hmm, still way overs

At the time it wasn't. He'd had a good year with the Hawks, was a premiership player, would have had a Norm Smith if he hadn't been injured. Hawks were offering the same cash, but 2 years instead of 3.

 

[ksardog]

Touche [kinda] - I think Melbourne will regret that deal.

Im saying melksham is a way better pick up than young was for us, infinately better.

 

[ksardog]

At the time it wasn't. He'd had a good year with the Hawks, was a premiership player, would have had a Norm Smith if he hadn't been injured. Hawks were offering the same cash, but 2 years instead of 3.

Hes crap, didnt want him from the get go. Kicking was always totally overated