Collingwood's Rolling Best 22

Remove this Banner Ad

Tarkyn_24 said:
Borderline. On promise will probably get games put into him but I have Josh Thomas in front personally.

Lol just read about your bet. You may as well pony up to your mate now. He'll be on our list in 2018. In fact the way he's projecting he'll be on our list in 2023 as well. A lot of upside, I just don't think he's quite best 22 at the moment
Click to expand...
Coming from a long way back JT is going to have to earn his way back in
 
My likely START OF SEASON best 22 based on recent games on the board and immediate need, I think the following will get the gig. If they have recently come off an extended period on the sidelines they'll need to compete and prove their worth I believe. Against the dogs I can't see too many surprises including Keefe, Elliott, Scharenberg or Ramsay for a few weeks unless they run riot pre-season. Don't think Bucks will chance it.

B - Maynard Dunn Smith
Hb - Reid Howe Adams
C - Pendlebury Greenwood Crisp
R- Grundy Wells Treloar
Hf - Fasolo Moore Sidebottom
F - Mayne White Varcoe
Bench - Aish Broomhead Goldsack JDG

Possible first round next in line, out of -
B Schade Keefe Ramsay
Hb Sinclair Scharenberg
C Phillips Oxley
R Wills Cox
F Crocker Blair
Hf WHE Elliott

Team looks pretty effective if they can gel!
 
B: Jeremy Howe, Lynden Dunn, Tom Langdon
HB: Brayden Maynard, Ben Reid, Taylor Adams
C: Daniel Wells, Jordan De Goey, Jack Crisp
HF: Chris Mayne, Jesse White, Steele Sidebottom
F: Alex Fasolo, Darcy Moore, Jamie Elliott
R: Brodie Grundy, Scott Pendlebury, Adam Treloar
Int: Levi Greenwood, Lachlan Keeffe, Travis Varcoe, Jackson Ramsay
Emergency: Rupert Wills, Josh Smith, Will Hoskin-Elliott

VFL:

B: Tyson Goldsack, Sam McLarty, Ben Sinclair
HB: Matthew Scharenberg, Henry Schade, Liam Mackie
C: Adam Oxley, Rupert Wills, Josh Smith
HF: Will Hoskin-Elliott, Mason Cox, Callum Brown
F: Tim Broomhead, Mitch McCarthy, Ben Crocker
R: Max Lynch, Josh Thomas, James Aish
Int: Jarryd Blair, Brayden Sier, Tom Phillips, Josh Daicos, Kayle Kirby
 

Log in to remove this ad.

ride56 said:
My likely START OF SEASON best 22 based on recent games on the board and immediate need, I think the following will get the gig. If they have recently come off an extended period on the sidelines they'll need to compete and prove their worth I believe. Against the dogs I can't see too many surprises including Keefe, Elliott, Scharenberg or Ramsay for a few weeks unless they run riot pre-season. Don't think Bucks will chance it.

B - Maynard Dunn Smith
Hb - Reid Howe Adams
C - Pendlebury Greenwood Crisp
R- Grundy Wells Treloar
Hf - Fasolo Moore Sidebottom
F - Mayne White Varcoe
Bench - Aish Broomhead Goldsack JDG

Possible first round next in line, out of -
B Schade Keefe Ramsay
Hb Sinclair Scharenberg
C Phillips Oxley
R Wills Cox
F Crocker Blair
Hf WHE Elliott

Team looks pretty effective if they can gel!
Click to expand...
Senior team might be the worst back 3 in the whole competition.
 
ride56 said:
My likely START OF SEASON best 22 based on recent games on the board and immediate need, I think the following will get the gig. If they have recently come off an extended period on the sidelines they'll need to compete and prove their worth I believe. Against the dogs I can't see too many surprises including Keefe, Elliott, Scharenberg or Ramsay for a few weeks unless they run riot pre-season. Don't think Bucks will chance it.

B - Maynard Dunn Smith
Hb - Reid Howe Adams
C - Pendlebury Greenwood Crisp
R- Grundy Wells Treloar
Hf - Fasolo Moore Sidebottom
F - Mayne White Varcoe
Bench - Aish Broomhead Goldsack JDG

Possible first round next in line, out of -
B Schade Keefe Ramsay
Hb Sinclair Scharenberg
C Phillips Oxley
R Wills Cox
F Crocker Blair
Hf WHE Elliott

Team looks pretty effective if they can gel!
Click to expand...

I like it, but Sidebottom would play on the wing, and Greenwood changing off half-forward (they all kinda play midfield now anyway of course). Elliot is definitely in the best 22 when/if fit. I think Ramsay is a better defended than Smith -- more punishing on the counter.
 
B: Goldsack Dunn Smith
HB: Adams Keefe Howe
C: Wells Pendlebury Varco
HF: Sidebottom White Mayne
F: Reid Moore Kirby
R: Grundy, Treloar, DeGoey
I: Elliot, Fasolo, Crisp, Aish

I've gone for flexibility in this selection. Goldsack included so Reid can go forward if needed. Playing one of our mids as a HB instead of a dedicated back like Ramsay/Sinclair is a no-brainer if you ask me. Gives us much greater flexibility. Adams showed he's good at the role.
Kirby included because he's Kirby. Realistically you might put Elliot there and Greenwood or Wills on the bench instead of him.
 
Finnishpie said:
I like it, but Sidebottom would play on the wing, and Greenwood changing off half-forward (they all kinda play midfield now anyway of course). Elliot is definitely in the best 22 when/if fit. I think Ramsay is a better defended than Smith -- more punishing on the counter.
Click to expand...
Yeah I agree but I see Greenwood and Sidebottom swinging through half forward, at least that's my hope. I think those guys coming out of injury or suspension like Ramsay, Keefe and Elliott will push into the team it'll probably just take a few warm ups in the magoos.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

doodles98 said:
B: Goldsack Dunn Smith
HB: Adams Keefe Howe
C: Wells Pendlebury Varco
HF: Sidebottom White Mayne
F: Reid Moore Kirby
R: Grundy, Treloar, DeGoey
I: Elliot, Fasolo, Crisp, Aish

I've gone for flexibility in this selection. Goldsack included so Reid can go forward if needed. Playing one of our mids as a HB instead of a dedicated back like Ramsay/Sinclair is a no-brainer if you ask me. Gives us much greater flexibility. Adams showed he's good at the role.
Kirby included because he's Kirby. Realistically you might put Elliot there and Greenwood or Wills on the bench instead of him.
Click to expand...
I like the thought processes here. There's a couple of personnel we could argue about ut I wouldn't be worried if that team lined up Round 1 sans Kirby and adding Greenwood/WHE/or half a dozen others
 
Countrypie said:
I like the thought processes here. There's a couple of personnel we could argue about ut I wouldn't be worried if that team lined up Round 1 sans Kirby and adding Greenwood/WHE/or half a dozen others
Click to expand...
Yeah Kirby was the only "joke" in that... a joke I really hope turns totally serious. I have a silly gut feeling he's going to be a real good surprise for us! I don't rate Goldsack much tbh but at round 1 next year he will be our best option if the objective is winning games and flexibility to play Reid forward. But then hopefully by the end of the year Scharenberg or Ramsay or someone has taken his place. Flexibility is something we can have an edge in I think... it is a huge advantage if you can pull it off. Makes injury coverage much easier and makes it hard for the opposition to plan, plus gives you an out in games where things aren't going well. If Moore gets injured then I think we have to look at the strong possibility of Reid going forward again. Our KPP stocks are a bit thin at both ends unfortunately.
 
doodles98 said:
B: Goldsack Dunn Smith
HB: Adams Keefe Howe
C: Wells Pendlebury Varco
HF: Sidebottom White Mayne
F: Reid Moore Kirby
R: Grundy, Treloar, DeGoey
I: Elliot, Fasolo, Crisp, Aish

I've gone for flexibility in this selection. Goldsack included so Reid can go forward if needed. Playing one of our mids as a HB instead of a dedicated back like Ramsay/Sinclair is a no-brainer if you ask me. Gives us much greater flexibility. Adams showed he's good at the role.
Kirby included because he's Kirby. Realistically you might put Elliot there and Greenwood or Wills on the bench instead of him.
Click to expand...

If you think Kirby should start over Elliott then you have serious problems
 
Crooked Girth said:
If you think Kirby should start over Elliott then you have serious problems
Click to expand...
It is WHE, Elliott is in the team ;)
I would keep Reid back and throw up Howe fwd. Rather a med size that plays tall then a tall that plays like a med. We keep another tall defender at the back line and Dunn kick ins are better then Howe.
 
Collingwood

B. Scharenberg ~ Keeffe ~ Maynard
HB. Howe ~ Reid ~ Adams
C. Wells ~ Treloar ~ Sidebottom
HF. Mayne ~ Moore ~ Hoskin-Elliot
F. Elliot ~ Cox ~ Fasolo
R. Grundy ~ Pendlebury (c) ~ De Goey
I. Crisp ~ Varcoe ~ Ramsay ~ Aish
C. Buckley


Collingwood Reserves

B. Goldsack ~ Dunn ~ Smith
HB. Langdon ~ McLarty ~ Sinclair
C. Phillips ~ Greenwood ~ Brown
HF. Crocker ~ White ~ Broomhead
F. Kirby ~ McCarthy ~ Daicos
R. Lynch ~ Wills ~ Blair
I. Schade ~ Sier ~ Oxley ~ Thomas ~ Mackie
 
Saintly Viewed said:
Collingwood

B. Scharenberg ~ Keeffe ~ Maynard
HB. Howe ~ Reid ~ Adams
C. Wells ~ Treloar ~ Sidebottom
HF. Mayne ~ Moore ~ Hoskin-Elliot
F. Elliot ~ Cox ~ Fasolo
R. Grundy ~ Pendlebury (c) ~ De Goey
I. Crisp ~ Varcoe ~ Ramsay ~ Aish
C. Buckley


Collingwood Reserves

B. Goldsack ~ Dunn ~ Smith
HB. Langdon ~ McLarty ~ Sinclair
C. Phillips ~ Greenwood ~ Brown
HF. Crocker ~ White ~ Broomhead
F. Kirby ~ McCarthy ~ Daicos
R. Lynch ~ Wills ~ Blair
I. Schade ~ Sier ~ Oxley ~ Thomas ~ Mackie
Click to expand...
That's a really strong reserves team. Add the VFL boys in there and they should definitely be going for the flag.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Collingwood's Rolling Best 22

Similar threads

PonsfordMagpie
  • Locked
Autopsy Round 22 = Sydney 89-86 Collingwood.
32 33 34 35 36
Replies
892
Views
27K
Anzacday
Anzacday
jmac70
Prediction The Roll
2
Replies
37
Views
2K
JLC
J
DIDAIC0S
Opinion Best Collingwood games of 2023
Replies
15
Views
1K
Tarkyn_24
Tarkyn_24
Jen2310
Best 23 in 2025
2 3 4 5
Replies
122
Views
7K
celestial
C
DinoSoar
Oppo Camp Other Games Rolling Thread 2024 Edition
652 653 654 655 656
Replies
16K
Views
354K
Sweeetleftfoot
Sweeetleftfoot
Bianconeri
Strategy Best 23 - 2025
Replies
3
Views
339
Bianconeri
Bianconeri
1
COLLINGWOOD. NEXT 5 YEARS?
5 6 7 8 9
Replies
200
Views
7K
sr36
sr36

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top