Confirmed Dan Houston - Joins Collingwood as part of 3-way trade with Port and GC

[Jeremias]

For anyone who missed the prior warning:

Take the Carlton v Collingwood shit fight elsewhere.

Infractions will be handed out.

 

[carlton_99]

I suspect they think that when Houston declares his hand, that club will get desperate.

Could also backfire, as the other club may just withdraw.

Whilst Houston hasn’t declared, it makes for interesting reading.

I was always of the belief that even if Houston did have a preference when it came to who he wanted to join he wouldn't nominate until a Vic club guaranteed they could do the deal. But now it seems clubs won't know if they can do the deal until the deal for 13 is sorted which won't happen now til Houston nominates. Going around in circles it seems

 

[Tristan34]

Imo, pick #13 & Richards would be fair for Houston.

However, can the Pies land pick #13...

Wow!!! That's heaps for a HBF.

 

[Buget]

I was always of the belief that even if Houston did have a preference when it came to who he wanted to join he wouldn't nominate until a Vic club guaranteed they could do the deal. But now it seems clubs won't know if they can do the deal until the deal for 13 is sorted which won't happen now til Houston nominates. Going around in circles it seems

It would be a little funny if North pounce, by spitting pick 2 or someone completely random like St Kilda enters the fray (although highly unlikely)

Would tell you that Houston was actually serious about getting to Victoria.

 

[carlton_99]

It would be a little funny if North pounce, by spitting pick 2 or someone completely random like St Kilda enters the fray (although highly unlikely)

Would tell you that Houston was actually serious about getting to Victoria.

Longer it drags out more chances for other clubs to get involved. Will be interesting to see if we get a Houston nomination in the coming days

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Wow!!! That's heaps for a HBF.

Imo, it's fair as a neutral..but Port apparently want more & Blues want to give less.

Seems Pies value him more & will be a 3 way deal with Suns involving Lukosius, Noble & Richards.

 

[Brian McGee]

It’s called a Future 1st bro

How are you getting 13 if you have a future first still available to add to it once you have it?

 

[demon21]

Why would GC care where Houston wants to go with so many clubs chasing pick 13 surely GC should just take the best deal for them, It's not up to them to help get the Houston deal done.

 

[jackag24]

Why would GC care where Houston wants to go with so many clubs chasing pick 13 surely GC should just take the best deal for them, It's not up to them to help get the Houston deal done.

They're nice guy FC.

just happy to be involved in the action

 

[Jirik13]

They're nice guy FC.

just happy to be involved in the action

A bit surprised that Trade Week reported that Luko for F1 should happen tomorrow. I expected it would be linked to Houston deal.

They also reported that pick 13 saga resolved within 48 hours.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Mega trade... what do you think?

Port
In: Lukosius, Richards, Pick #13
Out: Houston, F2nd

Collingwood
In: Houston, Port F2nd
Out: Noble, Richards, F1st

Gold Coast
In: Noble, Pies F1st
Out: Lukosius, Pick #13

 

[beerbandit]

Port would be robbing you blind

Yeah we I’d think we’d need a couple of picks coming back our way as a sweetener.

 

[Jirik13]

Mega trade... what do you think?

Port
In: Lukosius, Richards, Pick #13
Out: Houston, F2nd

Collingwood
In: Houston, Port F2nd
Out: Noble, Richards, F1st

Gold Coast
In: Noble, Pies F1st
Out: Lukosius, Pick #13

On Trading Day they were pretty confident that Luko deal (F1) will be done tomorrow separately.

 

[Brian McGee]

Mega trade... what do you think?

Port
In: Lukosius, Richards, Pick #13
Out: Houston, F2nd

Collingwood
In: Houston, Port F2nd
Out: Noble, Richards, F1st

Gold Coast
In: Noble, Pies F1st
Out: Lukosius, Pick #13

I don’t think gc go for that.

 

[perplexed]

Hi Dan. You've been great for us, AA's in the first two years of your contract is exceptional. You have way outperformed others on the list who are getting paid much more. We agree that it would be great for you if you could go home and get the pay increase you deserve. Thanks for saying all the right things to help us in negotiations, we really appreciate that. We've had some offers, they are reasonable, but the thing is Dan, we don't give a flying ...k about that or you. If we can't screw over the club you are going to (and hopefully GC as well), you aren't going anywhere. Good luck. Port

 

[GCS in 11]

If Luko does get done separately tomorrow, I think that does almost take Collingwood out of the running for Houston.

There’ll be no mega trade and makes us much more likely to just give 13 to the highest bidder which is Carlton

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

Mega trade... what do you think?

Port
In: Lukosius, Richards, Pick #13
Out: Houston, F2nd

Collingwood
In: Houston, Port F2nd
Out: Noble, Richards, F1st

Gold Coast
In: Noble, Pies F1st
Out: Lukosius, Pick #13

Collingwood come out absolutely laughing

 

[carlton_99]

Yeah we I’d think we’d need a couple of picks coming back our way as a sweetener.

Or just Butters should do it - McRae likes players not picks remember

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

I don’t think gc go for that.

Imo, they can't expect a F1st value if you pick up all Lukosius $950k pa salary.

 

[Brian McGee]

Imo, they can't expect a F1st value if you pick up all Lukosius $950k pa salary.

I agree. Happy to offer up a future first but would expect something along with lukosious for it.

 

[Pleasedontfail11]

They don't care, they are hoping the longer they wait the more desperate the bids for pick 13 will get.

Collingwood are the ones they want to krumble as it gets them noble cheaper, pick 13 for noble and the pies F1 without the 23 going back to the pies is the desperation bid they are hoping for by waiting but until houston nominates pies aren't going that deep for pick 13.

If he doesn't nominate i'd almost lock in pick 13 to carlton for a future 1st plus 2nd, we want the pick anyway regardless of houston or not.

There's no point in us doing that. Port wouldn't take pick 13, 36 (our current pick) and Richards for Houston imo. That's all we could offer after we accept that deal.
I feel if we don't get 23 with 13 then we won't trade Noble.
I think a 3 way trade may fix some of the issues. But we first need to get Huston to say he is happy to go to Collingwood.

 

[beerbandit]

It isn't just giving up the early pick, Carlton's salary cap is already bulging so bringing in another top end player will make for interesting list strategy in the coming 18 months.

This, with Weitering & TDK out of contract soon

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Collingwood come out absolutely laughing

Feel free to offer your own version...

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

Mega trade... what do you think?

Port
In: Lukosius, Richards, Pick #13
Out: Houston, F2nd

Collingwood
In: Houston, Port F2nd
Out: Noble, Richards, F1st

Gold Coast
In: Noble, Pies F1st
Out: Lukosius, Pick #13

Despite the Port downvotes, seems about right for them. Luko is an F1, Richards F2 so that makes sense to me.

I think the Port F2 goes to Gold Coast instead of Pies though. Noble and Richards are picks in the 30s really and Pies F1 should be worth less than 13 in this market

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Mega trade version 2... what do you think?

Port
In: Lukosius, Richards, Pick #13
Out: Houston, F2nd

Collingwood
In: Houston, Gold Coast F3rd
Out: Noble, Richards, F1st

Gold Coast
In: Noble, Pies F1st, Ports F2nd
Out: Lukosius, Pick #13, F3rd

 

[Brian McGee]

On Trade Week they were pretty confident that Luko deal (F1) will be done tomorrow separately.

What is trade week?