Mega Thread Delist/Trade/Draft Supermegaultrathread - Trade Period Edition

[QS]

super stupid

I assume you mean my post above.. if so, yes; ****ing stupid!

 

[eaglespremiers]

Mail is that the first five picks are somewhat set (I wouldn't bank on it though):
1. Boyd
2. Kelly
3. Billings
4. Bontempelli
5. Kolodjashnij
8. McDonald

So that leaves Collingwood with 2 picks, Brisbane with a pick and Melbourne with a pick.
McCarthy is suggested to go to either Collingwood or Brisbane.
Then there are players like Scharenberg and Aish.
Either Melbourne or Collingwood (pick 10) will have to choose out of another player, word is Freeman is preferred option of Melb and Salem for Collingwood but these could be simply rumours.
With that in mind we'd have to be unlucky not to have the option of Sheed available to us.

 

[Obeanie1]

Okay. I've teed up a date playing supa golf tomorrow arvo. How stupid am I.

You have internet access on your phone don't you!

 

[Obeanie1]

Is anyone else concerned about Robertson's injury history?

Sure great he attacks the contest hard but that not much help if he keeps breaking.

 

[Keys]

Is anyone else concerned about Robertson's injury history?

Sure great he attacks the contest hard but that not much help if he keeps breaking.

Someone has to replace beau waters eventually

 

[eagles rule]

4pm WST?

some press reports said 6 pm WST

 

[QS]

You have internet access on your phone don't you!

She is an avid Dockers supporter, so I suppose I could get away with it under the guise of updates for both of us... pretty early in the piece to be starting that shit though haha!

 

[Obeanie1]

Someone has to replace beau waters eventually

That's the point I'm making.

 

[ep2018]

some press reports said 6 pm WST

After the Ashes apparently

 

[Small Moves]

some press reports said 6 pm WST

4PM WST.

 

[larrikin]

4PM WST.

Yeah, no way it's going to run at 9pm on the East Coast.

 

[Yamumluvsbigcox]

Can't understand why dogs would take bontempelli at pick 4 after they went out on a limb with grant a few years back . They need genuine outside class to go with all there inside players . My money is they will pick aish .
I also can't see why GCS don't take Burg if they want a HBF
Just for something different
1 Kelly ( pick 1 to take spotlight off Boyd)
2 Boyd
3 Billings
4 Aish
5 Scharenberg
6 bontempelli ( so lions don't take him )
7 McCarthy
8 macdonald
9 Freeman
10 Salem
11 Sheed

 

[Hank93]

Good luck guys, hope you manage to steal this kid with a name that is bound to make him awesome



http://www.news.com.au/sport/afl/af...clubs-first-pick/story-fnelctok-1226764679332

 

[dajesmac]

The notion that Sheed is a big-time goal-kicker is getting ridiculous.

 

[WAFLfan1969]

I've heard that Richmond are taking Dom Sheedy under father and son rule, Kevin played 251 games for the Tigers

 

[Shupe]

I've heard that Richmond are taking Dom Sheedy under father and son rule, Kevin played 251 games for the Tigers

If Kevin had children, they'd be in football retirement by now.

 

[WAFLfan1969]

If Kevin had children, they'd be in football retirement by now.

Umm pretty sure I wasn't serious but that's okay

 

[eagles rule]

Yeah, no way it's going to run at 9pm on the East Coast.

too bad the night would just be getting started ..

 

[Shupe]

Umm pretty sure I wasn't serious but that's okay

I got that . I was just calling Kev old.

 

[DivideandMultiply]

Obviously don't remember Travis gaspar very we'll then foot issues destroyed his promising career

It depends what kind of injury. I should have been more clear. Tarsal/metatarsal stress fractures don't really present an ongoing concern, if the fragments are properly aligned and initial treatment or recovery is well managed and successful.

Generally a 6-8 week process. It is not terribly uncommon in some sports, especially soccer and has low recidivism rates.

 

[Eastern Rangers]

Can't understand why dogs would take bontempelli at pick 4 after they went out on a limb with grant a few years back . They need genuine outside class to go with all there inside players . My money is they will pick aish .
I also can't see why GCS don't take Burg if they want a HBF
Just for something different
1 Kelly ( pick 1 to take spotlight off Boyd)
2 Boyd
3 Billings
4 Aish
5 Scharenberg
6 bontempelli ( so lions don't take him )
7 McCarthy
8 macdonald
9 Freeman
10 Salem
11 Sheed

Bontempelli is genuine outside player and he's hugely versatile. Play him as a half back flanker, wingman or marking forward. If they develop him right he could be a genuine star and give them much needed versatility that Aish won't ever bring.

Grant is irrelevant, that was six years ago and since then they've loaded up on short inside types and now some height and some outside ability is just what they need. Last year they picked up Macrae, Stringer, Hvorat and Hunter (F/S). The year before Clay Smith, Micheal Talia. They've really turned their drafting around IMO.

Kolodjashnij can play shorter than Scharenberg, he's faster and more athletic and his production is about the same. His performances against division one sides stack up. GCS aren't in the business of playing it safe and making predictable moves, they're trying to build a dominant side with weapons on every line. I like the move to be honest.

 

[Eastern Rangers]

The notion that Sheed is a big-time goal-kicker is getting ridiculous.

Just an average week. 28 and 4.

 

[Spooky17]

Top 10 chance?

 

[Underdog]

The notion that Sheed is a big-time goal-kicker is getting ridiculous.

To be fair, he averages about the same amount of goals as Simon Black...

 

[Yamumluvsbigcox]

Bontempelli is genuine outside player and he's hugely versatile. Play him as a half back flanker, wingman or marking forward. If they develop him right he could be a genuine star and give them much needed versatility that Aish won't ever bring.

Grant is irrelevant, that was six years ago and since then they've loaded up on short inside types and now some height and some outside ability is just what they need. Last year they picked up Macrae, Stringer, Hvorat and Hunter (F/S). The year before Clay Smith, Micheal Talia. They've really turned their drafting around IMO.

Kolodjashnij can play shorter than Scharenberg, he's faster and more athletic and his production is about the same. His performances against division one sides stack up. GCS aren't in the business of playing it safe and making predictable moves, they're trying to build a dominant side with weapons on every line. I like the move to be honest.

I agree the dogs drafting has been very good but apart from stringer and his leg they have not had any speculative picks . Bontempelli seems very speculative at 4 especially when a ready made outside gun in aish is still around .
I also would have thought that Scharenberg and his foot problems would have been more of a risk than Kolodnashnij who seems like the safe pick !