Discussion thread: Things you just wont change my opinion on:

[Wally Matera]

Ok, l'm bored... its the off-season, the list is finalised and there aint much to have a good ole decent debate over.

Everyone has the preferred players, opinions on administration and coaching staff, finances, thoughts on future success, reasons for past failings and as much as we all discuss and debate them over different threads being created, we all go away at some point thinking everyone is just flat out wrong and cant be persuaded on understanding others views.

What are your non-negotiables regarding Richmond? No matter how strong the argument, your opinion cant be changed. You dont need to provide any reasoning, just your opinion/s.

Here's mine:

1) Daniel Jackson and Jake King are absolute cannon fodder.

2) Kevin Bartlett and son can go to hell. Absolute waste of time and energy.

3) Tony Free on the Board is laughable and destined for disaster.

Discuss

 

[getthefooty]

Here's beaver's

1. Richmond has a shit list, we won't win a premiership in the next 5 years.
2. The Mcmahon trade wasn't worth it.
3. Riewoldt can play.

 

[RichoRox12]

I thought Beaver's would be:

1. I hate life.

 

[beaver fever]

You seem to make a habit of predicting my posts GTF. Either rightly or wrongly.

 

[getthefooty]

And mine:

1) Kane Johnson is a good player and a valuable member of our 22.
2) TW is a good coach.
3) Cleve Hughes has a future as our FF.
4) Jay Schulz is an absolute hack.

 

[getthefooty]

You seem to make a habit of predicting my posts GTF. Either rightly or wrongly.

Rightly or wrongly this time?

 

[Captain_Brown_7]

1. Richmond was named after Matthew Richardson
2. Trent Cotchin is the only 19 year old male that you can have a hard on for and not feel dirty about it
3. Jarryd Oakley Nicholls is f**king useless

 

[DoItForCaptBlood]

1. Hart is the best CHF in the 150 years of the games history.

2. Spud is the worst coach in the 150 years of the games history.

3. I hope I can see another GF win before another 150 years is over!

 

[Wally Matera]

Geez, you're all going out on a limb there... here's everyone's chance to put a few knackers on the line

 

[beaver fever]

1. Richard Tambling will never become the midfielder we all hoped he would.

2. Adam Pattison is in limbo. Not a ruckman, not a forward.

3. JON is the worst player on our list. Quite possibly in the bottom 5 players in the entire league that has played a game of AFL.

 

[JSFish]

1) Terry Wallace is a very good coach
2) Brett Deledio will win the 09 Brownlow
3) We will make top 4 at least once between now and the end of 2011, with a case for twice
4) Tambling is good. Edit: hehe, wrote that without having seen Beave's post.

 

[getthefooty]

1. Richard Tambling will never become the midfielder we all hoped he would.

2. Adam Pattison is in limbo. Not a ruckman, not a forward.

3. JON is the worst player on our list. Quite possibly in the bottom 5 players in the entire league that has played a game of AFL.

As much as I disagree with you about Richmond beave, I completely agree with your post above.

 

[Captain_Brown_7]

1. Richard Tambling will never become the midfielder we all hoped he would.

Might not become the midfielder we had all hoped for, but mark my words, he will be an integral part of our team going forward.

 

[getthefooty]

And mine:


2) TW is a good coach.

1) Terry Wallace is a very good coach

Sheesh. No wonder people think we are gay you ********.

 

[JSFish]

You didn't give him enough credit.

 

[Themi#9]

1) Deledio and Cotchin will win a Brownlow!
2) Cleve Hughes is our next CHF and will breakout in 09!
3) Richo is god!
4)JON is pathetic!
5)We will make top 5 in 09!

 

[one eyedtiger]

1. Wallace will coach us to our next finals campaign (We will play finals in 09)
2. Polo will turn out to be a good player if he' given the opportunity
3. Trent Cotchin is the best thing since sliced bread.
4. Richo will play another 2 years at least

 

[Wally Matera]

Ok, enough of the pusy-footing around... here's a few more:

4) Jordan McMahon is a squib

5) Chris Newman as Captain is the wrong decision

 

[beaver fever]

4. Richmond should pick up 5 kids a year onto the senior list as a minimum.

5. Trent Cotchin will be the next captain of the RFC, and Jack Riewoldt will be his vice captain.

 

[Cousins_Tiger]

1) Jackson is and will be a very good player
2) Bowden is one of the most important players on our list
3) Cotchin will be listed as the best midfielder of his generation
4) Cousins will turn our midfield from good to freaking awesome
5) Richo will never retire
6) Tambling will be in our top 5 players next year
7) Wallis has done a great job rebuilding the list we owe him a lot
8) Deledio is a freak who will silence all critics in 09
9) Tucky is highly underrated by us and opposition fans

 

[_RT_]

Here we go:
1. Richmond will be a better side when Richo retires.
2. Moore is not a full time KP defender.

 

[Wally Matera]

7) Wallis has done a great job rebuilding the list we owe him a lot

Shows how little you know... is that Dean Wallis or Terry Wallace?

 

[beaver fever]

Here we go:
2. Moore is not a full time KP defender.

Yes he is. It's just that he would be better as a HBF.

 

[Wally Matera]

2. Moore is not a full time KP defender.

Not having a dig here mate, serious question... what is he then?

 

[_RT_]

Not having a dig here mate, serious question... what is he then?

Beaver answered your question below.

Yes he is. It's just that he would be better as a HBF.

I didn't say he can't play there at all, just that like you I think he will be much better value coming off a HBF where he can play on blokes like S.Johnson, C.Jones, Williams, O'Keefe and other mid sized forwards who we really struggle to find a decent match up for. Then we can have him as a plan B/C if Thursfield/McGuane/Rance are struggling on the bigger KP forwards.