Do we need May and why, or not

[jackcass]

We may run the risk of being forced to use our first rounder on Quaynor if we keep it so wouldn't it make sense to trade it first?

We aren't forced to do anything. It's means we have to make a choice. Who knows where Hine would have a cut off point to match bids for IQ and Kelly. I doubt he'd match a bid in the 1st round anyway.

 

[Roverjg]

Don't worry about May - i'll you the tip, Pies are preparing a godfather type deal for josh kelly at end of 2019. He is viewed as the pendlebury replacement

Yep.... I heard that about Lynch in 2015, 2016 and 2017 and that got us what? Let us know about Kelly in a year's time

 

[wicksy]

We aren't forced to do anything. It's means we have to make a choice. Who knows where Hine would have a cut off point to match bids for IQ and Kelly. I doubt he'd match a bid in the 1st round anyway.

I think he would for Quaynor so it would make sense to get rid of our first and try and trade in some late picks to have enough points available for the IQ and Kelly selections.

 

[Go Pie5]

I thought gcs will get rid of may if he wont commit. If so i think we should sit back and wait to see what they can get for him, i dont think they will get a 1st round pick because hes just not that good.2nd round and maybe a fringe player at best.

 

[buzzbuzz]

But it's a deficiency now due to injury, not because we don't have options on the list. Acquiring May during the trade period won't alter that.

Neither Dunn nor Scharenberg are likely to play at all next year. Moore is injury prone. Reid is injury prone and old. What other options do we have?

 

[Brent24]

Neither Dunn nor Scharenberg are likely to play at all next year. Moore is injury prone. Reid is injury prone and old. What other options do we have?

Why isn't Dunn likely to play? I'll bet you he plays before the half way mark of the season.

 

[BPikkers]

Neither Dunn nor Scharenberg are likely to play at all next year. Moore is injury prone. Reid is injury prone and old. What other options do we have?

What options did we have previously? We brought in an older bloke playing VFL from Melbourne who turned out fine before doing his knee this year. We also brought in a rookie defender playing in the VFL who has turned out to be a great forward. The point being we can always find a defender in the VFL and WA/SA state leagues. They don’t need to be superstars. They just need to do their job which is made easier with a defence that helps each other as we have seen this year.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Neither Dunn nor Scharenberg are likely to play at all next year. Moore is injury prone. Reid is injury prone and old. What other options do we have?

Mr McLarty

 

[buzzbuzz]

What options did we have previously? We brought in an older bloke playing VFL from Melbourne who turned out fine before doing his knee this year. We also brought in a rookie defender playing in the VFL who has turned out to be a great forward. The point being we can always find a defender in the VFL and WA/SA state leagues. They don’t need to be superstars. They just need to do their job which is made easier with a defence that helps each other as we have seen this year.

So you'd prefer not to get a superstar?

 

[TradeDraft]

Guess we don’t have to Worry about May

 

[Baltimore Jack]

Neither Dunn nor Scharenberg are likely to play at all next year. Moore is injury prone. Reid is injury prone and old. What other options do we have?

Why will Moore and Reid always be "injury prone"?

 

[legendstatus]

Guess we don’t have to Worry about May

What else would you expect them to say?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[frizzle]

Neither Dunn nor Scharenberg are likely to play at all next year. Moore is injury prone. Reid is injury prone and old. What other options do we have?

I wouldn't be at all surprised if Dunn plays round 1 next year.

 

[buzzbuzz]

Why will Moore and Reid always be "injury prone"?

Because they always have been.

 

[jackcass]

So you'd prefer not to get a superstar?

Are you satisfied that May is a superstar?

 

[Cousin of Daicos]

https://www.triplem.com.au/shows/th...ay-will-go-to-the-pies-if-deal-can-be-reached

 

[OniAu]

As long as we don't rip the core/chemistry out of our team to get him , then we should go for him

 

[TradeDraft]

https://www.triplem.com.au/shows/th...ay-will-go-to-the-pies-if-deal-can-be-reached

So would cost us a Fair Bit

 

[Jasper84]

 

[Cousin of Daicos]

Why will Moore and Reid always be "injury prone"?

Not sure if serious

 

[Baltimore Jack]

Because they always have been.

Not sure the world works like that

 

[Baltimore Jack]

Not sure if serious

Damn, you stole my line

 

[left at home]

May, Quaynor and Kelly and a smokie from this trade/draft period would be above a pass grade you would think, as long as we retain Moore.

If it is true about Lynch going to the tigers, then keeping Darcy is a must, then add the others l would Agree.
If Dunn is back earlier then we can swing Darcy forward or even Dunn forward as he can also can play that role

 

[Gaben]

So you'd prefer not to get a superstar?

Are we still in the Steven May thread or did I get lost?

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

As long as we don't rip the core/chemistry out of our team to get him , then we should go for him

I assume if we had the cap room for Lynch then we have the cap room for May (as long as we keep Moore too)