Rumour Draft Rumours 2024 - No rumours allowed

[Wild Bill]

There’s talk that this draft is pretty overrated.

I don’t know if it’s an overreaction or if that’s even the right word. But there’s a feeling that even though there’s a lot of depth in this draft, it’s hardly a super draft.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

There is no JHF, Sheezel or Reid - a lot of good/decent talent but the top end isn’t anywhere near previous years.

An even draft more than super.

 

[Mofra]

Dane Swan was 58

Oldest draftee ever

 

[Better Loosen Up]

Great deal for North they get the player they want and another pick #11
But wont happen and way too much to give up for player thats 1 of 7 possible top picks

Richmond is not wed to any player in this group and will just take the highest rated
But i can see #6 + #18 / #20 maybe if they did want to move up

Blair is a tough negotiator and has danced with Brady before

Berry and Allan are the big movers

Lol. Why would we trade pick 2 for LESS than what it's worth?

Normally you would have to pay a bit of a premium to upgrade from 6 to 2. However given this draft is more even than usual, then it's reasonable to trade based on even points. If you go by the revised draft points system beginning next year, 6 and 10 or 6 and 11 is right in that ballpark. 6 and 18 is a flat out joke.

There's still a big difference between pick 2 and 6, even in this draft. Pick 2, you get whoever you want. Pick 6, you get whoever is left.

 

[Mutineer]

I'd say that too if our first pick was in the 50s.

Pick 58 Lachie Neale

 

[Coach_Required]

Richmond is going to trade out all their top picks after pick 1 in a deep draft for Norths pick 2 and F1.

 

[Lord of the Wings]

I hear Richmond might trade pick 1 for pick 2.

 

[Wild Bill]

Richmond is going to trade out all their top picks after pick 1 in a deep draft for Norths pick 2 and F1.

Any trade for 2 will be how highly you rate the 2 best in the draft.

I would prefer to keep 2 and take Lalor or FOS. The raffle starts after that IMO.

 

[GoEaglesGoSGIO]

Oldest draftee ever

Right up the West Coast Eagles alley from what I can see . Fits the list strategy perfectly

 

[richoatthedisco]

Any trade for 2 will be how highly you rate the 2 best in the draft.

I would prefer to keep 2 and take Lalor or FOS. The raffle starts after that IMO.

Who do you want at pick 62?

 

[Wild Bill]

Who do you want at pick 62?

Don’t care. We got a lot of 1st round talent in the last few years. Tigers are where we were in 2020.

I would rather quality than quantity and just bring in FOS or Lalor.

 

[richoatthedisco]

Don’t care. We got a lot of 1st round talent in the last few years. Tigers are where we were in 2020.

I would rather quality than quantity and just bring in FOS or Lalor.

Yeah but Willy T hearts Tauru. Big throb.

Tauru at 2? Nah. You're trading back. Tauru and a good kid is better than Tauru and a dreg. You'll be able to get a good kid at 24.

 

[Lord of the Wings]

Any trade for 2 will be how highly you rate the 2 best in the draft.

I would prefer to keep 2 and take Lalor or FOS. The raffle starts after that IMO.

My best offer is 6 & 24 for 2 & F2. Take it or leave it. Every chance pick 6 is a better player anyway so why would I bother?

 

[Wild Bill]

My best offer is 6 & 24 for 2 & F2. Take it or leave it. Every chance pick 6 is a better player anyway so why would I bother?

lol every chance??

McKercher V Sanders
Ashcroft V Humphrey
Darcy v Rachele
Thiltorpe V DGB
Anderson V McAsey
Lukosius V B King
A Brayshaw V Stephenson
Taranto V SPS
Schache V Francis
Petracca V Marchbank
J Kelly Scharenberg


Only once in the last 11 years has 6 been better than 2. Lets just say you have a 10% chance 6 is better than 2.

 

[perplexed]

Yeah but Willy T hearts Tauru. Big throb.

Tauru at 2? Nah. You're trading back. Tauru and a good kid is better than Tauru and a dreg. You'll be able to get a good kid at 24.

So North are desperate for Tauru, but willing to risk not getting him by dropping back a few spots for some trinkets?

Whilst Richmond supporters are clearly obsessed with pick 2, the club may not be. If they want pick 2 they'll pay a reasonable price to get it, if not they won't. No amount of postering and hubris will change that.

 

[CatToTheFuture]

Dane Swan was 58

Yeah feels like a draft where you get Shai Bolton and Tom Stewart late but McGrath goes pick 1

 

[Sarcoidevo]

Haha .... Tigger supporters desperate for Pick 2 but aren't willing to cough up enough to North

Pick 6 & 11 thanks

 

[Mogumber]

Pretty even I reckon, its top weighted with Vic Metro mids, but there will be some diamonds in the later picks.
Lawson Humphries again perhaps?

 

[Lord of the Wings]

lol every chance??

McKercher V Sanders
Ashcroft V Humphrey
Darcy v Rachele
Thiltorpe V DGB
Anderson V McAsey
Lukosius V B King
A Brayshaw V Stephenson
Taranto V SPS
Schache V Francis
Petracca V Marchbank
J Kelly Scharenberg


Only once in the last 11 years has 6 been better than 2. Lets just say you have a 10% chance 6 is better than 2.

You've compared the wrong pick. Given the Ashcroft bid is coming within 6 you need to compare it to pick 7.

Pick 7 includes Ryder, J Selwood, D Rich, J Lewis, Scrimshaw, Hopper, H Young & Windsor.

Its also the most even 1st 7 in most recruiters memories.

Nice try but we ain't given you 2 picks for 2.

 

[tigs2010]

Haha .... Tigger supporters desperate for Pick 2 but aren't willing to cough up enough to North

Pick 6 & 11 thanks

Almost as desperate as Saints wanting North to have 6 so they take a tall and leave one of the main 6 mids for them

 

[Wild Bill]

Haha .... Tigger supporters desperate for Pick 2 but aren't willing to cough up enough to North

Pick 6 & 11 thanks

We had 5 picks in the top 25 last year - we aren't desperate for picks and unless we get a good offer just take the 2nd best 18 year old in the country.

 

[Lord of the Wings]

Haha .... Tigger supporters desperate for Pick 2 but aren't willing to cough up enough to North

Pick 6 & 11 thanks

I hear the Saints are gonna trade picks 7 & 8 for pick 2. Same value as 6 & 11

 

[Wild Bill]

You've compared the wrong pick. Given the Ashcroft bid is coming within 6 you need to compare it to pick 7. Leave it with ya

Yet you said pick 6 will be as good as pick 2?

McKercher V Windsor
Ashcroft V mcKenzie
Darcy v Ward
Thiltorpe V Hollands
Anderson V Young
Lukosius V Smith
A Brayshaw V Clark
Taranto V Scrimshaw
Schache V Hopper
Petracca V Ahern
J Kelly v Aish

Easily pick 2 again. Maybe do some research before posting.

 

[Lord of the Wings]

We had 5 picks in the top 25 last year - we aren't desperate for picks and unless we get a good offer just take the 2nd best 18 year old in the country.

Not sure how many times we need to tell you this. We don't want pick 2!!!!!! We are happy with what we have. We'll trade our last couple for 1st rounders next year and take at least 6 1st rounders this year.

 

[Lord of the Wings]

Yet you said pick 6 will be as good as pick 2?

McKercher V Windsor
Ashcroft V mcKenzie
Darcy v Ward
Thiltorpe V Hollands
Anderson V Young
Lukosius V Smith
A Brayshaw V Clark
Taranto V Scrimshaw
Schache V Hopper
Petracca V Ahern
J Kelly v Aish

Easily pick 2 again. Maybe do some research before posting.

I see you left out J Selwood. That one didn't suit your narrative?

 

[Wild Bill]

I see you left out J Selwood. That one didn't suit your narrative?

Lol you want me to go back 18 years???

Just when i thought you hit rock bottom you now start to dig.....