Werewolf Gralin's Brutal Werewolf - Day Ten- Village Wins

[rye]

i am making naturaldisaster my retribution

the truth does not fear inquisition

 

[RU_]

I’m just a villager who tailed Clarke’s vote.

 

[Strigoi]

Nope. Probably run out of food before someone swings.

 

[thewizardmelon]

i am making naturaldisaster my retribution

the truth does not fear inquisition

I did wonder if there was merit earlier to calling the village to all retri on one target. But it seems fraught with danger to attempt.

If the village (while hidden or not), all coordinates their retri on one target, that person surely dies or evil dies. Issue is, if that agrees upon target is village aligned it goes horribly wrong

 

[MWPP]

I did wonder if there was merit earlier to calling the village to all retri on one target. But it seems fraught with danger to attempt.

If the village (while hidden or not), all coordinates their retri on one target, that person surely dies or evil dies. Issue is, if that agrees upon target is village aligned it goes horribly wrong

The retri coordination idea (which I was musing about earlier too hence disclosing mine ) could well be the way forward . It does risk exposing any info you have on good that evil may not have, at this early stage

I am surprised more haven’t disclosed their targets…

I’m wondering if I should change mine if only because my current one is an obvious vig target and I don’t really want to waste it unless it’s unavoidable

There are enough crumbs to work with if I do switch though

 

[MWPP]

Edit - someone could have failed the modkill and just only lost one life. We wouldn’t know. * this sh*t is hard.

The lack of a claim post deadline suggests that it was either on somebody who hasn’t shown up post deadline
( Tarkyn_24 came across as intimidated at one point today but later on, not so much) or an inactive, or a failed action on someone dead or protected

 

[MWPP]

Seems too early to be wasting it on a self intimidation so ruling that possibility out…

 

[Pie 4 Life]

The retri coordination idea (which I was musing about earlier too hence disclosing mine ) could well be the way forward . It does risk exposing any info you have on good that evil may not have, at this early stage

I am surprised more haven’t disclosed their targets…

I’m wondering if I should change mine if only because my current one is an obvious vig target and I don’t really want to waste it unless it’s unavoidable

There are enough crumbs to work with if I do switch though

I wondered if the vig hits a suspected night immune they could change it to them, like if I seered evil I would have changed it to them.

 

[Gralin]

Read the Rules

Or don't

 

[Frederico_WA]

I wondered if the vig hits a suspected night immune they could change it to them, like if I seered evil I would have changed it to them.

Would it be more valuable for the vig to claim (if hitting night immune) so village can change their retri for the 1/3 its SK?

Vig in the open wouldn't be lynched so with a doc and flog protect should get through 4 extra night phases

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Would it be more valuable for the vig to claim (if hitting night immune) so village can change their retri for the 1/3 its SK?

Vig in the open wouldn't be lynched so with a doc and flog protect should get through 4 extra night phases

The only time the vig should claim (if not outed) is if they can be guaranteed they hit night immune. As in make sure they don't come out only to reveal they've hit the protected doc, or someone protected. It's a fine line. I came out last game because I knew 100% Dingster was night immune so it was worth the risk. If I wasn't 100% sure I'd wait until I was before coming out.

 

[rye]

Read the Rules

Or don't

im just joshing around!

 

[por_please_ya]

Because people need to die twice lol it makes it hard for the vig to know if someone is night immune or if they simply still have the extra life.

I'm expecting carnage soon enough with retributions.

 

[Frederico_WA]

Because people need to die twice lol it makes it hard for the vig to know if someone is night immune or if they simply still have the extra life.

I'm expecting carnage soon enough with retributions.

Vig should still get an unsuccessful message I'd think

 

[Itsmyshow]

But yeah, RU and IMS would be my top 2 on reflection but can make a case for those other names too
wiz should be able to fine tune that further

 

[thewizardmelon]

Would it be more valuable for the vig to claim (if hitting night immune) so village can change their retri for the 1/3 its SK?

Vig in the open wouldn't be lynched so with a doc and flog protect should get through 4 extra night phases

Important to note Fred the floggies only get a seer and kill in this game.

Will reveal what we’ve used and when in due time, or my compatriots will if I don’t make it through the night

 

[Tarkyn_24]

The lack of a claim post deadline suggests that it was either on somebody who hasn’t shown up post deadline
( Tarkyn_24 came across as intimidated at one point today but later on, not so much) or an inactive, or a failed action on someone dead or protected

I wasn’t intimidated, just struggled to engage so was having a bit of fun. I’m switched on now

 

[MWPP]

Also in case anyone is interested , these are the votes . I make no promises around their accuracy but at least the timestamps should make them easier to verify

Some notes:
-despite mc’s chopping and changing I’m inclined to think he’s a villager she to his opening remark. Also moving a vote around is more like his old school villager game
-boncer’s presence on the wagon is partly what made me reevaluate my initial hunch that the wagon was accelerated by evil after wiz got it started
-a few revenge votes in that list, typical for day one (and yes, including my own). I find revenge votes without other reasons quite tricky to interpret as I revenge in either alignment
-There were more votes on ND than I realised , and it was also more of a slow burn than I realised
___________
Cadsky - NaturalDisaster (0912)
croweater 41 - NaturalDisaster(1645) , originally boncer34 (1637)
Dingster - sante (2119)
Kurve - Chipmunk (1115)
SSwans2011 - crowwy (1540)
NaturalDisaster - Beerfish (1643)
BEaston - crowwy (1320)
RU_ - RU_ (1604)
rye - no vote
dogs105 - NaturalDisaster (1743), originally MWPP (944)
boncer34 - crowwy (1258)
Frederico_WA - Kurve (1001)
Strigoi - crowwy (1658)
Beerfish - crowwy (1642)
ClarkeM - boncer34 (1647)
MP_ - dogs105 (1315)
The Majestic - dogs105 (1355)
Pie 4 Life - omgfridge (1335)
thewizardmelon - crowwy (1132)
omgfridge - pie 4 life (1917)
MC Bad Genius - crowwy (2039) , originally Tandy (1233), Jhye Clark (1241), NaturalDisaster (1754), Dingster (1958)
Tarkyn_24 - NaturalDisaster (1648), originally Wiz (930) and crowwy (1254)
Jhye Clark 13 - DERO (1145)
sante - Tandy (1000)
Pickitt - Dingster (2006)
por_please_ya - crowwy (1512)
Itsmyshow - Pickitt (1632)
Chipmunk - Kurve (839)
MWPP - DERO (1112) , originally Pickitt (927)
DERO - MWPP (946)
Tandy - sante (1013

Which in turn makes the crowy votes potentially fertile ground to start? Someone must have successfully targeted him night one, and three out of four kills were controlled by evil.

Having slept on it , and looking back at the crowey voters; I’m less suspicious of the porps , MC , SSwans , Clarkey crowwy votes due to other play but granted I could have been reading too much into the mc /clarkey n1 exchange . Jury’s out on BE, Beerfish, Strig votes. I also better agree with the case for ND as that switch from boncer to crowwy was after such a short interval. With a seer claimed uncontested and no fake in this one, plus being comfortable based on other posts that he isn’t the doc or vig or mystic, I’d be less opposed to voting nd today despite his question to me about ding . Again wiz is best place to discern if any of these were hidden good.

Once again the IMS vote for pick mid wagon and the timing of it stands out , and the RU vote too for similar reasons .

 

[MWPP]

I just realised that I missed Beerfish’s switch to ND on Monday . The closeness of the final count does make it seem like they wouldn’t be aligned :

 

[Frederico_WA]

I wasn’t intimidated, just struggled to engage so was having a bit of fun. I’m switched on now

Evil be like "TURN IT OFF, TURN IT OFF!"

 

[thewizardmelon]

Evil be like "TURN IT OFF, TURN IT OFF!"

Do you mean his own evil faction or the other one?

 

[Tarkyn_24]

Do you mean his own evil faction or the other one?

Ffs please look at me so that you stop this

 

[thewizardmelon]

Ffs please look at me so that you stop this

You old hands don’t let anyone fish anymore

 

[Gralin]

DEADLINE

 

[Tandy]

Love a good deadline