Werewolf Gralin's Brutal Werewolf - Day Ten- Village Wins

[thewizardmelon]

Depends if they have used it yet, or better yet, used it and the target was either not a vanilla starter or was otherwise protected if you get my drift .

I’m more interested in why after 3 nights there are 0 final factional kills

Depends if they have used it yet, or better yet, used it and the target was either not a vanilla starter or was otherwise protected if you get my drift .

I’m more interested in why after 3 nights there are 0 final factional kills

Where does it say it’s a one off action?

 

[Frederico_WA]

Seer as good until they completely turn too. It could be anyone P4L has already seered ... it could even be someone like MWPP or Chip who we have as confirmed villager. Ugh indeed!

It does read as the victim is a villager, so that rules out any surprises that one of your flog mates could turn haha

 

[MWPP]

Seer as good until they completely turn too. It could be anyone P4L has already seered ... it could even be someone like MWPP or Chip who we have as confirmed villager. Ugh indeed!

I do think they are the least of our worries as it stands with every other evil /neutral role at large, but yes, worth remembering for those townies fortunate enough to make it to the mid /end game

 

[thewizardmelon]

I thought so??

Who else have you guys seered/who do you think is evil?

 

[Frederico_WA]

Where does it say it’s a one off action?

Gralin is too thorough and perfect to omit an important detail like that. So it must be unlimited.

This would have been really handy for my wolf pelt rug last game BEaston

 

[thewizardmelon]

Never mind, re-read OP

 

[MP_]

It does read as the victim is a villager, so that rules out any surprises that one of your flog mates could turn haha

interesting, does that mean if they tried to infect someone with a role it would come back unsuccessful ?

 

[MWPP]

chance to infect one bitten villager if they don't die. Only one infected per game.

thewizardmelon , depends how you interpret this
One total infected , or one infected opportunity ?
I am hoping the latter

The latter makes more sense as it‘s a bonus member compared to Mafia regardless

Also means that it they can retry the attempts double as a seer

It wasn’t a question Gralin answered and I sense it was for good reason as he was happy to answer my many other questions

If anyone else wants to try their luck with different wording feel free

 

[thewizardmelon]

interesting, does that mean if they tried to infect someone with a role it would come back unsuccessful ?

That’s the conclusion I’d draw yeah

 

[Frederico_WA]

Gralin is too thorough and perfect to omit an important detail like that. So it must be unlimited.

This would have been really handy for my wolf pelt rug last game BEaston

Disregard. Past-Fred is so stupid. Gosh!

I re-read the OP too. It was hiding in the faction description.

 

[MWPP]

That’s the conclusion I’d draw yeah

The use of the word “chance” also gives me once off attempt vibes but I suppose I’ll find out for sure on the other side

 

[MP_]

That’s the conclusion I’d draw yeah

seems unfairly powerful to the wolves because then they know a person has a role, plus they already have a seer.

 

[MWPP]

thewizardmelon MWPP Result is another boring one RU_ is a villager.

I’m starting to wonder if he’s a head.
Something to mull over on another day but gosh he has been deliberately unhelpful.

 

[thewizardmelon]

seems unfairly powerful to the wolves because then they know a person has a role, plus they already have a seer.

Sure does, but Gralin didn’t promise balance. A once off chance seems the most likely Interpretation

 

[MWPP]

If one of the 2ICs was known IMO they would absolutely be the play before ND for the reason above (with wasting retris on them being the main alternative )
If we are confident that Nd was Lynched and not dero yesterday , this becomes even more true

In theory could go:
Lynch 2IC
Vig or Flog 2IC
Lynch ND

Could even try for an ND /2IC multi thewizardmelon , anyone not cooperating would be outed, no manipulator etc to account for

 

[thewizardmelon]

Anyway, we’ve decided lynching ND can be taken care of another day.

Strigoi thanks Gralin

 

[MWPP]

If the multi failed due to lynch shenanigans etc only one of the two would be Lynched . Doesn’t seem like a bad outcome.

 

[MC Bad Genius]

I think we leave ND and try to hit someone else we think is evil. If they are actually good, they'll put their retribution down to take out ND.

So, the stinkiest for me is Cadsky, thanks Gralin.

 

[The Majestic]

Anyway, we’ve decided lynching ND can be taken care of another day.

Strigoi thanks Gralin

So does that mean I've gotta be nice and not have a noose around the guys neck?

 

[MWPP]

Strigoi Gralin

 

[MC Bad Genius]

Why strigs?

 

[BEaston]

Anyway, we’ve decided lynching ND can be taken care of another day.

Strigoi thanks Gralin

Happy with this tact.

Strigoi

Gralin

 

[The Majestic]

Why strigs?

I am keen to figure that one too.

 

[BEaston]

my retri will be on ND.

 

[thewizardmelon]

Why strigs?