Traded Jake Carlisle [traded w/ #23 and #44 for #5, #24 and Craig Bird]

[eth-dog]

Really - well fair enough. I guess you rate Melksham higher more power to you lol

I do, but he's shit as well. Melksham's slightly harder at the pill

 

[pinot]

Yarran as a 19 year old



Yarran as a 22 year old

 

[eth-dog]

Yarran as a 24 year old:

 

[Seb78]

Would you accept pick 1 for Carlisle?

Of course I would.... but purely and simply cause he wants to leave, but not if he wanted to stay with us. I dont know what the number 1 pick will turn out to be, maybe a superstar but then again maybe not. I know how good Carlise is and can be, he has shown it at the highest level.

 

[pinot]

Yes he had a poor year but Jake had 15 poor games of 22 this year so what does that tell you?

 

[pinot]

Yarran has given the club 6 good years out of 7 and deserves his $450k pay packet in 2016 hope we keep him

 

[Keystone agony]

Carlton lose big time - whilst Richmond and Essendon profit - you must think the world that evolve around you is made up of dummies.

Yarrans gonna walk for nothing next year

Ive decided to start posting like you in here. Cool

 

[eth-dog]

Yes he had a poor year but Jake had 15 poor games of 22 this year so what does that tell you?

Carlisle is better than Yarran and pick 21. The fact you think otherwise is laughable.

 

[pinot]

Carlisle is better than Yarran and pick 21. The fact you think otherwise is laughable.

Yarran kicks goals and breaks the lines - Carlisle can not do either. If we get him he won't move from FB

Yarran can play any flank and midfield position on the ground.

 

[pinot]

Yarrans gonna walk for nothing next year

Ive decided to start posting like you in here. Cool

he can't he's a restricted free agent.

 

[eth-dog]

Yarran kicks goals and breaks the lines - Carlisle can not do either. If we get him he won't move from FB

Yarran can play any flank and midfield position on the ground.

Yarran is a front running, soft, outside player that chokes under pressure.

Carlisle is a gun KPP and has shown the ability to dominate at both ends of the ground

 

[Keystone agony]

he can't he's a restricted free agent.

Hes OOC

 

[pinot]

Hes OOC

Yes he is, but will be at the club for eight years which makes him a RESTRICTED free agent.

 

[BRWB]

Carlisle is better than Yarran and pick 21. The fact you think otherwise is laughable.

The fact you think Ess somehow hold the whip hand in these negotiations continues to amuse me.

I've said it before, I'll say it again, Yarran for Carlisle straight swap or Carlton's 2nd rd pick for Carlisle loom as possible scenarios.

 

[Keystone agony]

Yes he is, but will be at the club for eight years which makes him a RESTRICTED free agent.

Yeh but he can just walk to the PSD for his sake he will be hoping like hell your not last again

 

[pinot]

Yarran is a front running, soft, outside player that chokes under pressure.

Carlisle is a gun KPP and has shown the ability to dominate at both ends of the ground

Yarran is far from soft.

 

[pinot]

Yeh but he can just walk to the PSD for his sake he will be hoping like hell your not last again

Yes he can walk into the PSD but not this year. Contracted players cant walk into PSD unless the club release them there.

 

[MightyDons4]

Yarran kicks goals and breaks the lines - Carlisle can not do either. If we get him he won't move from FB

Yarran can play any flank and midfield position on the ground.

What KPD breaks the lines and kicks goals?

Also Carlisle has kicked and averaged more goals than Yarran this season.

 

[pinot]

What KPD breaks the lines and kicks goals?

Also Carlisle has kicked and averaged more goals than Yarran this season.

OK so they're different players - go and speak with your numbskull bretheren not me,

 

[Keystone agony]

Yarran for Carlisle straight swap or Carlton's

Lol

 

[marky53]

Yarran is far from soft.

ROFL

 

[MightyDons4]

OK so they're different players - go and speak with your numbskull bretheren not me,

Then why make the comment that Yarran can break lines and Carlisle cannot when you know they're completely different players? It's like me saying Carlisle is an excellent contested mark and Yarran is not, it's not a knock on Yarran as he's not expected to be a good mark at his size. Try and think before you post .

 

[DapperDon]

Yarran is far from soft.

pinot pls

 

[HereComesJuddy]

Yes he is, but will be at the club for eight years which makes him a RESTRICTED free agent.

Don't think he is paid enough to be a restricted free agent.

 

[SherbertLemon]

Yarran kicks goals and breaks the lines - Carlisle can not do either. If we get him he won't move from FB

Yarran can play any flank and midfield position on the ground.

Okay, I get that you must be accustomed to Essendon KPP's crumming goals and breaking the lines, we had years of faithful service for imo the most underated KPP player for Essendon... Mr Alwyn "Froggy" Davey.

What you'll get from Carlisle, should you get him, is what a KPD is actually supposed to do... you know... play on a KPF....

heck i miss froggy. I mean, crummed goals and played tall. What a champion.