Jason Johnson or Adem Yze?

[raskolnikov]

which one

 

[DaveMorro]

No comparison
JJ by an absolute mile.

 

[Palace03]

Jason Jonhson for sure

 

[Cuneyt]

j.johnson

j.johnson=hard nut
Yze=pussy

 

[Darealrath]

Jason Johnson.

 

[Ten Ton Hammer]

I rather have jason johnson cause he's a lot harder at the ball!

 

[Destructive]

Jason Johnson.

 

[X_box_X]

This time last year, these two guys were my tip for the Brownlow Medal. I rate them highly, but I'd probably rate Johnson just above Yze at the moment.

Johnson, a hard nut, I agree.

 

[SonOfScray]

JJ by a fair way, he is the player I'd most like to have at Footscray for the upcoming season.

 

[mellowyellow]

All aboard the JJ train.

 

[Lockyer24]

Johnson has the ability to turn a game. Yze doesn't.

 

[marcuz]

Yze is a very skilled footballer. And one that i would love at bomberland. But JJ is so tough and is the heart and soul in a midfield and i wouldnt swap him for anything...well maybe Voss...and Pavlich. I wouldnt mind McLeod also.

 

[bLuEMoOsE]

and if they would be so king as to through in Lappin Black Goodes Couglan Cousins Kerr Judd Fletcher Haselby and Bell then yeah we have a deal

JJ although i do love the way Yze hasnt learned how to handball yet

 

[lufc618]

Jason johnson..

 

[Ataata39]

Jason Johnson- more consistent. Yze has more skill but would take JJ over him at Collingwood.

 

[Bombers_Forever]

JJ by a country mile

 

[Gopies 2002]

Johnson comfortably.

Pity Johnson can't kick like Yze though. What a player he would be then.

 

[MarkT]

Both good players. Seems a heavy loading to Johnson though and I don't see why. At Collingwood I'd take Yze right now for his finishing.

 

[pazza]

Originally posted by MarkT
Both good players. Seems a heavy loading to Johnson though and I don't see why. At Collingwood I'd take Yze right now for his finishing.

Probably JJ's hardness has impressed a lot of people Mark.

As Rex would say though: IT'S OOOOOOVVVVVEEEEEERRRRRR

 

[Feel the Heater]

Originally posted by pazza
Probably JJ's hardness has impressed a lot of people Mark.

As Rex would say though: IT'S OOOOOOVVVVVEEEEEERRRRRR

How many of these people on this post actually support the bombers? I have noticed a lot of the issues concerning player Vs player tend to involve bomber players, and mysteriously the bomber player comes out on top! Seriously, Yze has just come off an average year and if the same question was asked this time last year Yze would be head and shoulders above Johnson. 'Which one' was the question, well what do you want? A hard in and under player or a fast running skillful midfielder? Different players, different strengths. But it ain't oooooovvvvvveeerrrrrr, that's for sure.

 

[pazza]

Haven't been too many Dons fans posting in this topic reading through it.

Counted only 7 Essendon posters.

Seems to be a lot of support across the majority of teams.

 

[Gopies 2002]

Originally posted by pazza
Probably JJ's hardness has impressed a lot of people Mark.

As Rex would say though: IT'S OOOOOOVVVVVEEEEEERRRRRR

Its not just the hardness, but also his ability to win his own ball that I think puts Johnson ahead.

In a good team that is travelling well, Yze is a fine player. However I am yet to see him stand up in games that count, or when the Dees are struggling.

 

[Feel the Heater]

Originally posted by Gopies 2002
Its not just the hardness, but also his ability to win his own ball that I think puts Johnson ahead.

In a good team that is travelling well, Yze is a fine player. However I am yet to see him stand up in games that count, or when the Dees are struggling.

Ability to win his own ball, but then can he do what Yze does with it? Yze ain't bad at getting the ball either, not so much the hard ball gets like Johnson but they're not all receiving possessions either. Stand up in games that count? Are you serious? 2002 had some fairly important games for us, all the way to the semi finals. What did Yze finish in the Brownlow that year? 2000 also had some important games to. Do you suffer from short term memory loss?

 

[Gopies 2002]

Originally posted by Feel the Heater
Ability to win his own ball, but then can he do what Yze does with it? Yze ain't bad at getting the ball either, not so much the hard ball gets like Johnson but they're not all receiving possessions either. Stand up in games that count? Are you serious? 2002 had some fairly important games for us, all the way to the semi finals. What did Yze finish in the Brownlow that year? 2000 also had some important games to. Do you suffer from short term memory loss?

Take a deep breath there and try and be calm.

Read what I wrote again. IMO, and remember its just that, I think he does well when the team is doing well, but struggles to have an influence otherwise.

You disagree and thats fine.

 

[Ibeeza]

There seem to be a lot of Demon and Bummer supporters debating this, time for a non-biased opinion from an opposition supporter:

Yze, IMO, is the better player. Given a choice of the two Yze would be my choice as he has the better skills and match winning ability. I find Johnson to be a bit rough around the edges, a no frills type who goes in hard but will never be a star, just a good ordinary player. Handy to have, every side needs one, but Yze has star capabilites and will influence a match more.