- Sep 27, 2015
- 3,465
- 3,829
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
44. Hawthorn – Kurt Heatherley (rookie upgrade)
Surely hawks use this pick
Surely hawks use this pick
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Jourdan Canil's 2015 Phantom Draft
- Thread starter Dukes Of Hurley
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Crows need a backup for Walker and Jenkins. If H McKay already gone, Burton is best option. They did take a great punt on Lever last year. Would also be happy with one of Oliver, Mathieson or Gresham. Not as enthused about Balic.
Excellent read DoH.
Well done and well thought out.
Well done and well thought out.
monty1104
Brownlow Medallist
Hope you're wrong on Morgan. We are stacked with half backs, we have way more pressing needs. Other than that it's probably fine. Would rather Francis than Weideman, but see the logic in Weideman.
Dukes Of Hurley just to be 100 % clear, Melbourne deliberately traded up ahead of Essendon for one reason, grab the player they most want...
Rest assured Parish will be a Dee.
Rest assured Parish will be a Dee.
dustydusty_4
Draftee
- Oct 19, 2015
- 15
- 12
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Do u think burton is worth richmond taking a punt on?
- Banned
- #36
A plate and seven screws in his knee after trading Menzel who has had knee troubles. Isn't a safe option for SOS who needs to nail 19 after offloading Yarran and Menzel. A vanilla mid or flanker might be unfashionable, but we need more than upside to build a top side. Even Rendell felt Sloane had questionable disposal. He played on Yarran before becoming a mid.
Last edited:
- Feb 2, 2009
- 2,174
- 5,733
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Thank you.
Carlton simply must play it safe with their early picks for the next couple of years. Build up a solid core of players. There's no point getting rid of Yarran and Menzel if you replace them with similar players. You need the cake before you can add the cream.
I don't get why would reach to draft an undersized KPF at P3... Particularly when we have P7 up our sleeves and he's every chance to be there anyway.
We need midfielders, lots of them. The more the merrier. Besides we already have the best young forward in the game, a second would be great, but we need to get him the ball.
If we go tall, which we may well at 7, we'd be looking to draft someone capable of rucking as a back up to Gawn. My bet however is Oliver at 7, as Weid will go to the Bombers and Harry McKay is just to much of a reach when considering the talent availible.
Roos loves his midfielders.
I'm firming in my belief that Melbourne go
3. Parish
7. H.McKay
Parish best available mid and McKay the perfect partner for young dominant KPF Hogan and young Ruckman Gawn. I don't think McKay is a reach. Potential is huge given his size, ability, birthdate and sound body.
- Sep 14, 2015
- 5,396
- 16,113
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
Nice draft. One player most Phantom Drafters have left out but is reputedly on many clubs' radar is Marcus Adams. I appreciate mature agers are hard to line up. Did you consider him?
Agree totally with everything you have said here. What most have forgotten as well is that Petracca can play forward as well in a Stringer/Brad Johnson type role. McKay would be a good get or possibly Weideman but also in today's football system a forward line is the sum of all parts not the 80's type of kick it just to the FF.
VanDemonxx
Club Legend
- Jul 24, 2015
- 1,057
- 924
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
I think it is hard to see Melbourne passing on Parish. Hence why they wanted pick 3. Parish had no chance of being there at 6 while Curnow was a chance. If we do decide to grab Curnow, which would make sense considering aside from Garlett and Hoges, our forwardline is very weak. Petracca coming back will help a bit. Grabbing Curnow i think would have us taking Clayton Oliver at 7. My mail is that we have some intrest. If we take Paris which I expect, I think Sam Weideman will be available for us at 7, as the Dons won't take both him and Curnow, and the Suns are stacked with KPF with Day, Lynch and Wright
Dukes Of Hurley
Team Captain
- Thread starter
- #44
Nah won't be any kpp's left by then. Ben McKay will be well and truly gone. Himmelberg is an inbetween type and GWS will probably match it. Don't think guys like Moore, Glass-McCasker etc are what the Bombers need, and certainly not at that pick. David Cuningham, Alex Morgan or Brayden Fiorini make a bit more sense.
Dukes Of Hurley
Team Captain
- Thread starter
- #45
They might, but depends if they're keen to have more than 38 senior listed players. It's looking likely only 60 players will be taken in the National this year, don't be surprised if Rookie Upgrades come a fair bit earlier.
I considered Burton, and I think the Crows will too. I don't really see a shrewd drafter bringing in Burton as a back up, particularly at that high a pick. I think Ogilvy would take Burton if he can see him cementing a place in the side. Don't think Burton is the type of guy who would be happy to be a 'back-up'
The reason it makes sense is based on the fit / how the game is changing. I'm not of the belief that Curnow is a better player, and again, I stress that if it was me, I'd take Parish. But again, my mail is pretty strong on this.
Heard a bit about him, but with mature agers, I tend to leave them out unless I've got some knowledge on if a club is particularly keen. I think he is a decent chance to get taken, but didn't want to put him in unless I was fairly sure.
Dukes Of Hurley
Team Captain
- Thread starter
- #46
Just think both are best available. I think Ah Chee might be a chance, as may Burton (although I don't think he may necessarily be a good fit). Crows are a bit of a mystery to me at the moment, haven't got a whole lot of mail on them.
Great effort.
The Filth Wizard
Just here for the zipline
- Jul 26, 2007
- 95,078
- 169,515
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Arsenal, Coney Island Warriors
- Moderator
- #49
I would actually be really happy if that ended up as North's draft (even Mitch Brown).
Nice work OP.
Very well thought out across the board actually.
Nice work OP.
Very well thought out across the board actually.
Dukes Of Hurley
Team Captain
- Thread starter
- #50
They may well do. Could also look to re-rookie Hams or NOB.
Thanks mate. It's a possibility. I liked a couple of things he did against Tasmania, but aside from that, I haven't really seen too many encouraging signs in terms of actual in-game play. Love the athleticism though.
Think David Cuningham is also going to be a strong consideration at one of those picks. He's got great speed and I particularly like his ability to weave through traffic. Think he could be a really special player around the stoppages. A few clubs will consider him in the early 20's.
Similar threads
