Judd's been cited

[lazy]

Re: judd offered a week

just reported on 9 perth. i hope we appeal this rubbish.

You snorting again and missed the other huge thread on this?

 

[Alphanumeric]

Re: judd offered a week

You're lucky he got only 1, 3 matches at least he should have got but he is a protected species.

As is Barry Hall and Brett Kirk.

 

[j_mac]

Re: judd offered a week

You're lucky he got only 1, 3 matches at least he should have got but he is a protected species.

awww footy lover just like goodes eh

 

[94_Eagles]

Re: judd offered a week

You're lucky he got only 1, 3 matches at least he should have got but he is a protected species.

Hall.

 

[Stakerz]

Re: judd offered a week

Come on Judd, get off!

 

[fogelhoon]

Re: judd offered a week

awww footy lover just like goodes eh

Yeah thats right Goodes actually ran up behind somewones back and purposefully punched them in the back when they weren't looking. Hmm how many did he get i forget

 

[davey_magik]

Re: judd offered a week

Should have been at least 3.
Unlike some WCE players, the Hawks players haven't dobbed him in, but he still should go.

 

[Embley]

****ing joke

 

[lazy]

Re: judd offered a week

Yeah thats right Goodes actually ran up behind somewones back and purposefully punched them in the back when they weren't looking. Hmm how many did he get i forget

Goodes should have got a week - Judd should have got probably more than a week - But they are AFL love childs.

 

[Ripper]

****ing joke

About 2 weeks short I reckon.

They are an undisciplined lot at WC.

 

[j_mac]

Re: judd offered a week

Yeah thats right Goodes actually ran up behind somewones back and purposefully punched them in the back when they weren't looking. Hmm how many did he get i forget

yep but that doesn't matter does it.
because a west coast player did it they must be guilty

 

[lazy]

****ing joke

Yet the "victim" said he didnt do it.. Can you believe it Embers???

 

[j_mac]

Re: judd offered a week

Should have been at least 3.
Unlike some WCE players, the Hawks players haven't dobbed him in, but he still should go.

three !!!!! you have been hanging around benny tooooo long champ

 

[Angry Dragon]

Are you suggesting that the Tribunal will not treat this case like other ones?

Are you suggesting that the Tribunal is corrupt?

The umps have already admitted that certain players are looked after. Corruption at all levels.

 

[bbco49]

About 2 weeks short I reckon.

They are an undisciplined lot at WC.

yeh and freo aint?

eagles should appeal and use ben hollands reprimand as an example - his eye gouge on BJ was much worse

 

[Wizard]

Yet the "victim" said he didnt do it.. Can you believe it Embers???

LOL, the victim that wasnt actually a victim in the end.

 

[fogelhoon]

Re: judd offered a week

Goodes should have got a week - Judd should have got probably more than a week - But they are AFL love childs.

how cna you compare the 2 Goodes was a purposefull premeditated punch from behind, some would say this is a dog act. Judd had 2 players on top of him, one with an elbow in his throat, and he has accidently put his hand on someones face (whether it was eye or noe vistim says no) in an attempt to get him off so he can breathe

 

[Wizard]

yeh and freo aint?

eagles should appeal and use ben hollands reprimand as an example - his eye gouge on BJ was much worse

Thanks captain obvious. We all know he will get off with an appeal. Thats how the AFL/MRP has made it.

 

[juddanort]

you have got to be kidding!! they are sure as hell making sure no wce boys are in the running for the brownlow.

 

[hawker5]

Umpire should be suspended for a week - I thought the rule was if it is above the shoulder then it was a free kick - umpire was right in the front of the incident and didnt pay any frees and now we have all supporters totally confused.

If Judd is to sent to the tribunal he should be reprimanded as it was a wrong thing to do (touch another players eye) but it was accidental.

 

[lazy]

Re: judd offered a week

how cna you compare the 2 Goodes was a purposefull premeditated punch from behind, some would say this is a dog act. Judd had 2 players on top of him, one with an elbow in his throat, and he has accidently put his hand on someones face (whether it was eye or noe vistim says no) in an attempt to get him off so he can breathe

dunno stupid - ask someone if they would prefer a push in the back or a finger nail in their eye

 

[scottywiper]

The victim said he didnt do it. How the heck can ya still be charged. Its stupid.

Mate, you can't honestly believe that. The footage is what he was charged on.
It's the old players code, if the AFL accepted the word of players no one would ever be charged with anything.

 

[milo]

Mate, you can't honestly believe that. The footage is what he was charged on.
It's the old players code, if the AFL accepted the word of players no one would ever be charged with anything.

Except Josh Carr and Stephen Dodd.

 

[j_mac]

you have got to be kidding!! they are sure as hell making sure no wce boys are in the running for the brownlow.

sad isn't it no victorian has won anything of any note for a few years
booooo hooooooo so the VFL has decided to help out

 

[MF]

Mate, you can't honestly believe that. The footage is what he was charged on.
It's the old players code, if the AFL accepted the word of players no one would ever be charged with anything.

Unless the victim was Chick or Holland