Traded Luke Jackson [Traded with #44 and #67 to Fremantle for #13, F1 and F2]

Remove this Banner Ad

Totally different players but Rankine has shown a lot more than Jackson so far, Jackson is still riding on potential

We are paying up for potential but Rankine has ripped multiple games apart already, no way should he be worth half of Jackson

eh???????

Ruck duties were always skewed in Gawns favour, Jackson showing he will dominate with higher % ruck duties. Has won a premiership.

Rankine had a decent back end to 2022 and that's it.

There is a higher ceiling with Rankine, IMO, but also a higher bust potential.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Doesn't mean I have to back in his opinion. I'll believe he's a gun when I see it.
Strange, as I would be excited about Jackson joining my team...
 
Nothing exciting about losing 5 players AND two first round picks to get a guy who has played about 5 good games.
But you didn't need to lose 5 players to fit Jackson in your cap... but agree it's worrying how many players appear to be leaving. I'm told you have another couple of likely trade ns.
 
But you didn't need to lose 5 players to fit Jackson in your cap... but agree it's worrying how many players appear to be leaving. I'm told you have another couple of likely trade ns.
We don't need to lose any of them to fit him. But we're still going to lose them. I'm sure there would be a lot less debate about Jackson if we didn't have anyone leaving. Where out list is at atm we could afford to not hit the first round of the draft for a couple years and Jackson would be worth taking the risk for. Now we are losing a lot of important depth and b22 and so paying so much trade capital for Jackson doesn't seem worth it.
 
Jackson will be a good player for us but shouldn't cost more than 13 and our F1st.

It’s interesting isn’t it…Taranto looks like going for 12 and 19 with something going back to Richmond…

So as players Jackson has…being tall as a superiority to Taranto…and a couple of years in age…that’s it.

13 and a future second is all it should cost at worst
 
Nothing exciting about losing 5 players AND two first round picks to get a guy who has played about 5 good games.
Yeah but if one of those 5 games helps your team win a flag and end its premiership drought, then that is the game you will remember for a long long time....thus why the Melbourne fans rate Jackson...and fair enough....think the Freo fans will feel the same if Jackson does the same for Freo in the future.
 
That's been done to death mate.

You wanted 3 first rounders for him.
He finished 14th in this years F&B.
Just saying.
lol so you expect a 3rd year 2nd ruck, playing out of position to be ahead of Oliver, Gawn, Petracca, May, Viney, Lever, Brayshaw and Fritsch in the BnF? LOL just a lazy 4 all-australians, 1 former AA, 1 AA-squad member and Jack Viney. :)
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Wanted(being the key word) 3 first rounders at the start of the season coming off a flag and Rising star....of course that is not going to happen especially after his 2022 season....but pretty sure Melbourne fans have stated many a time his current currency has devalued....
spot on. I called for 3 first rounders and now his form has resulted in 2 firsts. That's for an out of contract too. in contract, its 3.
 
Lol, surely Jackson, a proven performer & premiership player is worth significantly more than Rankine.
I don't care if he played in a flag. So did Aaron Keating.

His performance is what I am questioning. I think he will be a good ruck, not sure about a mid.

Rankine already is a very good player
 
lol so you expect a 3rd year 2nd ruck, playing out of position to be ahead of Oliver, Gawn, Petracca, May, Viney, Lever, Brayshaw and Fritsch in the BnF? LOL just a lazy 4 all-australians, 1 former AA, 1 AA-squad member and Jack Viney. :)
I didn't say that.
Doesn't matter who was in front of him.
I said he finished 14th.

Lever was 19th by the way.
Just saying.
 
Assuming JHF ends up at Port:

13 + Logue to North for 8,

8 + Future 1st for Jackson for Melbourne's Pick 32 and Future 2nd or 3rd.
We will see. I don't reckon we need to split picks to give you 8. (especially if it means the trade value is losing a 24 year old swingman who finished in our top 5 best and fairest)
 
Dockers Get- Jackson Georgiades
Dockers give up- Logue 1st rd pick Lobbe

Port Adelaide- JHF
Port Adelaide- 1st rd pick Georgiades

North Melbourne - Logue 1st rd pick (port)
North Melbourne- JHF

Melbourne - Lobbe 1st rd pick dockers
Melbourne- Jackson

Melbourne then trade with bulldogs
Lobb for first rd pick and Ed richards
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Traded Luke Jackson [Traded with #44 and #67 to Fremantle for #13, F1 and F2]

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top