News Matt Clarke heads West. Replaced by Chris Toce

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

Massive risk for us as he would know our list in terms of contracts and caps inside out.
Wouldnt be surprised if a few wa boys go home. Oh wells need to replaced with someone good.

Bit worrying as geelong, pies all had pretty much the same recruiter for decades. Not sure how we didnt keep him - seems like $$ made him leave but why didnt west coast get pies/cats as they have a bit of loyalty?
 
  • Thread starter
  • Moderator
  • #36
Massive risk for us as he would know our list in terms of contracts and caps inside out.
Wouldnt be surprised if a few wa boys go home. Oh wells need to replaced with someone good.

Bit worrying as geelong, pies all had pretty much the same recruiter for decades. Not sure how we didnt keep him - seems like $$ made him leave but why didnt west coast get pies/cats as they have a bit of loyalty?
The player managers know all that info anyway it’s not that big of a deal
 
Would love a replacement coming from Sydney… they barely miss
When you have unlimited access to your academy kids it's pretty bloody easy to 'nail' their picks
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

That re-development of PRO is going to bleed this Club dry...talk about sucking in all our resources...
Bet M.Clarke's replacement is internal!
get rid of the redevlopment

we dont need it

what we have is fine

just move the girls out
 
I didn't rate him & i'll tell you why, he got more wrong than he got right. he has been here since 2013 just look at our drafting since than.
Francis Jackson recruited all our legends of the dynasty era Cotch, Riewoldt, Dusty, Edwards. etc
Blair Hartley had biggest impact of luring players from other clubs Grigg, Caddy, Houli, Prestia, Lynch you also hear players thanking him in retirement speeches for them getting him over to Richmond.

You might bring up the the odd gems like Baker & Short but they were rookies & more luck than anything if you give him credit for those you also have to give him criticism for guys like RCD, Corey Ellis, Ben Lennon.

I like some of our kids atm but also not sold on some of the players either.

I just hope we recruit someone highly rated & not promote within this is a serious job if you get wrong, can set your club back years.
 
Which one of you nerds is coming up with the where are they now with the players he brought in


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Joined in 2009 as a recruiter

Promoted to lead national recruiter in 2016

2016
Pick 29- Shai Bolton
Pick 53- Jack Graham
Pick 72- Ryan Garthwaite | Delisted

Rookie draft- Tyson Stengle | Geelong

2017
Pick 17- Jack Higgins | St Kilda
Pick 20- Callum Coleman-Jones | North Melbourne
Pick 25- Noah Balta
Pick 34- Patrick Naish | Delsited
Pick 63- Ben Miller

Rookie draft- Liam Baker

2018
Pick 20- Riley Collier-Dawkins | Delisted
Pick 43- Jack Ross
Pick 58- Fraser Turner | Delisted
Pick 62- Luke English | Delisted

Rookie draft- Jake Aarts | Delisted

PSS- Sydney Stack | Delisted
PSS- Maverick Weller |Delisted

MSD- Marlion Pickett


2019
Pick 21- Thomson Dow
Pick 43- Noah Cumberland
Pick 44- Will Martyn | Delisted
Pick 46- Hugo Ralphsmith
Pick 54- Bigoa Nyuon | North Melbourne

2020
Pick 40- Samson Ryan
Pick 51- Maurice Rioli Jnr

PSSP- Rhyan Mansell

MSD- Mathew Parker | Delisted


2021
Pick 9- Josh Gibcus
Pick 17- Tom Brown
Pick 28- Tyler Sonsie
Pick 29- Sam Banks
Pick 30- Judson Clarke

MSD- Jacob Bauer


2022
Pick 49- Kaleb Smith
Pick 55- Steely Green

Rookie draft- Seth Campbell
Rookie draft- Tylar Young

MSD- Mathew Coulthard
MSD- James Tresize

2023
Pick 40- Kane McAuliffe
Pick 43- Liam Fawcett
 
Joined in 2009 as a recruiter

Promoted to lead national recruiter in 2016

2016
Pick 29- Shai Bolton
Pick 53- Jack Graham
Pick 72- Ryan Garthwaite | Delisted

Rookie draft- Tyson Stengle | Geelong

2017
Pick 17- Jack Higgins | St Kilda
Pick 20- Callum Coleman-Jones | North Melbourne
Pick 25- Noah Balta
Pick 34- Patrick Naish | Delsited
Pick 63- Ben Miller

Rookie draft- Liam Baker

2018
Pick 20- Riley Collier-Dawkins | Delisted
Pick 43- Jack Ross
Pick 58- Fraser Turner | Delisted
Pick 62- Luke English | Delisted

Rookie draft- Jake Aarts | Delisted

PSS- Sydney Stack | Delisted
PSS- Maverick Weller |Delisted

MSD- Marlion Pickett


2019
Pick 21- Thomson Dow
Pick 43- Noah Cumberland
Pick 44- Will Martyn | Delisted
Pick 46- Hugo Ralphsmith
Pick 54- Bigoa Nyuon | North Melbourne

2020
Pick 40- Samson Ryan
Pick 51- Maurice Rioli Jnr

PSSP- Rhyan Mansell

MSD- Mathew Parker | Delisted


2021
Pick 9- Josh Gibcus
Pick 17- Tom Brown
Pick 28- Tyler Sonsie
Pick 29- Sam Banks
Pick 30- Judson Clarke

MSD- Jacob Bauer


2022
Pick 49- Kaleb Smith
Pick 55- Steely Green

Rookie draft- Seth Campbell
Rookie draft- Tylar Young

MSD- Mathew Coulthard
MSD- James Tresize

2023
Pick 40- Kane McAuliffe
Pick 43- Liam Fawcett
1709114174018.gif
 
Would be nice to get someone who doesn't repeatedly squander 1st rounders and can identify quality KP players as we urgently need restocking. Hopefully the club poaches someone considered top tier from another club. Need to nail the next few drafts before Tassie compromises it. No more el cheapo internal promotions. Actually glad he's gone. WCE did us a favour.
 
At this juncture change is healthy , livo and Blair will get someone that will be a great asset to the team , plenty going around in this dept , narrow it to the current leading clubs ,,,fk swans anyway , beyond their academies , who they got , did ly squat , try building a premiership side from rookie pics that’s impressive
 
reckon we've got the best recruiter lined up but the afl is gonna come in over the top and poach him to tassie on crazy afl $$$ like they did to us with plugger to sydney
 

Remove this Banner Ad

News Matt Clarke heads West. Replaced by Chris Toce

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top