- Banned
- #126
Sooooooooo how does that humble pie taste? bitter??
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Nick Maxwell guaranteed AA
- Thread starter Football God
- Start date
- Tagged users None
obviously you dont watch him play football. this guy breaks packs, outmarks nearly everybody, thats what true defenders are meant to do. not like scarlett who receives a cheap handball out of defense all the time.
you being a brisbane supporter wouldn't understand since you dont watch a real team.
I'm sure they watched both Brisbane and Collingwood in the GFs in 2002 and 2003
- Thread starter
- #128
2002 is also the year peter garrett left midnight oil.I'm sure they watched both Brisbane and Collingwood in the GFs in 2002 and 2003
mate stick with the program...
Great early call, we all knew Maxwell deserved AA, i just wasn't sure whether the selectors would give it to him.nick maxwell is dead certain to make the AA team.
he has dominated all of his opponents all season and helped the defense to get back there and clear the ball out.
whoever thought at the start of the season that maxwell will choke as being collingwood's new captain, think again.
being a leader of such a young side, he has been sensational and has improved heaps of his skills.
he deserves that 'C' more than the likes of harley (lol), mitchell, harvey etc..
AA HBF: maxwell.
now lets see all those collingwood haters out there disagree
Hmm let's do a comparison with Fletcher (who was also in the AA squad) and Maxwell.
Note I don't think Dustin deserevd an AA gig.
1) Could say line ball
2) Fletch wins hands down
3) See point 2
4) See point 2
5) See point 2
Well if they were the criteria the AA selectors surley stuffed that one up.
- Oct 7, 2002
- 16,174
- 16,876
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
The only thing that is stuffed up is the eye that you didn't have open when you wrote that, you biased clown.
Good call.
The Falcon Strike
Hall of Famer
Not sure he deserved it - but if Joel Bowden can make AA on a back flank by playing loose and not having an opponent - then at least Maxwell's pick shows consistency.
And at least Maxwell actually put his body on the line occasionally.
As i mentioned in another post - it's a lot easier to look good when you don't have an opponent.
Bowden, H Shaw (of yesteryear), Hodge, Maxwell, Harley, Johnstone etc etc all have looked like worldbeaters when they don't have an opponent.
Childish retorts - ahh the intelligence of a pies fan.
Ask non-pies and dons supporters then - see who they would want.
The Falcon Strike
Hall of Famer
For a career or for 2009?
Obvioulsy 2009 as there is no contest for career.
The one hting I will admit is Fletch missed a few games during the middle of the year.
And I will repeat - No I don't think fletch should have got an AA gig, but considering the guys who did, he could consider himself stiff because the bar was lowered.
The Falcon Strike
Hall of Famer
then if you look at output - i'd take Maxwell for this year
- Sep 14, 2005
- 18,419
- 18,679
Hes been bloody named as an AA HBFer!! Whos opinion is more important and respected? Yours, a guy on some net forum? Or the AA selection committee? Geez, get a clue!
Nick Maxwell is now an All-Australian, suck it up.
Nick Maxwell is now an All-Australian, suck it up.
scruffydog
Club Legend
Well... to be honest... it's about par.
Swan in the forward line, no Le Cras, Judd in the team at all... no second ruckman...
billanderson64
Rookie
great player, wish fletch played for us
although i'm a pie supporter that is very funny.
Wouldn't matter who you supported I don't think, cracked me up.
- Thread starter
- #146
so did no st.kilda player making the backline in the AA team, now that cracked me up.
me too.
- Thread starter
- #148
i am glad
Dont cry 4 me Riewoldt
Debutant
hey footy god do you think st kilda is overated or is it just me
- Thread starter
- #150
i think they love themselves and watch all the bandwagoners come out.
in the name of your name.... this will be the expressions on their faces adter the match on the weekend
