Status in Question No more BBQ ribs on the field

[The Mares Leg]

Ports actions with Butters has foretold the future in how rib injuries are to be handled.

There will be legal shenanigans at Melbourne over Duty of Care and Club liability.

Butters had a rib, the club had a responsibility and a LEGAL obligation to pull him off the ground after the Petracca scenario.

Get used to it - rib injuries will be benched from here on. This potato hasn’t been roasted yet.

 

[Buzz Hawk]

lol what.

 

[frggr]

Ports actions with Butters has foretold the future in how rib injuries are to be handled.

There will be legal shenanigans at Melbourne over Duty of Care and Club liability.

Butters had a rib, the club had a responsibility and a LEGAL obligation to pull him off the ground after the Petracca scenario.

Get used to it - rib injuries will be benched from here on. This potato hasn’t been roasted yet.

What about the DeKoning incident?

 

[HairyO]

lol what.

Port's medical team doing what Port's medical team does best - mis-management.

 

[mightypowerrrr]

Ports actions with Butters has foretold the future in how rib injuries are to be handled.

There will be legal shenanigans at Melbourne over Duty of Care and Club liability.

Butters had a rib, the club had a responsibility and a LEGAL obligation to pull him off the ground after the Petracca scenario.

Get used to it - rib injuries will be benched from here on. This potato hasn’t been roasted yet.

Port also put Allir back on after he was concussed..

Butters was driving the decision to be subbed off

He'd want a big game this week because he was as SOFT AS BUTTER last Thursday

 

[The Mares Leg]

You’re entitled to disagree - except Buz Hawk who’s struggling with the concept.

I believe Butters was dragged because of the fear surrounding the Petracca injury.

You can think differently….but I’m not sure why you would…?

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

Butters doesn’t have a rib injury. He should never have played last week.

 

[The Mares Leg]

Butters doesn’t have a rib injury. He should never have played last week.

Umm….he was dragged due to a suspected rib injury….or are you being facetious?

 

[yirra_kurl]

Butters doesn’t have a rib injury. He should never have played last week.

hearing whispers around this.
Something about Kraft Singles i think is what i heard

 

[The Mares Leg]

hearing whispers around this.
Something about Kraft Singles i think is what i heard

Well, regardless of the reality - it’s clear Port was exercising a risk averse position in dragging him - and anyone not understanding this was directly due to the Trac scenario is pretty slow.

 

[yirra_kurl]

Well, regardless of the reality - it’s clear Port was exercising a risk averse position in dragging him - and anyone not understanding this was directly due to the Trac scenario is pretty slow.

well the rumour I'm hearing is it's actually not Rib related.
I understand that it's an easy comparison to draw to the Trac situation but i dn't believe it's as black and white as it seems.

Do you have the footage of the 'heavy knock in the first half'?

 

[The Mares Leg]

well the rumour I'm hearing is it's actually not Rib related.
I understand that it's an easy comparison to draw to the Trac situation but i dn't believe it's as black and white as it seems.

Do you have the footage of the 'heavy knock in the first half'?

No, I just have the official match report signed off by the AFL.

 

[GudOnya]

No, I just have the official match report signed off by the AFL.

Next thing you know we'll have people questioning late withdrawals due to hamstring injuries. Bloody conspiracy theorists.

 

[The Mares Leg]

Next thing you know we'll have people questioning late withdrawals due to hamstring injuries. Bloody conspiracy theorists.

As I said, you’re welcome to believe anything you want - but nobody has given me a reason to think or believe it eas anything but what the match report says it was.

Are you saying it was Men from Mars and a tractor beam? Or are you saying it was a drug overdose? Or ?

 

[PenfoldsFan]

Lol, Cats threw everything at us early and managed a 20pt lead which we clawed back to lead by 2pts when the cue went in the rack.
Butters wasnt injured, along with JHF starting on the bench snd DBJ moved back, it was all part of the plan.
Watch the replay, we jogged to contests and applied zero pressure.
If the cats were any good they should have given 119 a nudge.

Our finals campaign starts this week off the back of an extended bye.

 

[GWT6]

While I agree with the general thinking behind the OP, I would also like to say that posting while high isn't always a great idea.

 

[Happy_Neale]

well the rumour I'm hearing is it's actually not Rib related.
I understand that it's an easy comparison to draw to the Trac situation but i dn't believe it's as black and white as it seems.

Do you have the footage of the 'heavy knock in the first half'?

I’ve seen it shown multiple times, he also spent the night in hospital. There is no conspiracy here

 

[The Mares Leg]

While I agree with the general thinking behind the OP, I would also like to say that posting while high isn't always a great idea.

I wish!

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

I’ve seen it shown multiple times, he also spent the night in hospital. There is no conspiracy here

Did he?

Also missed a session with an eye infection last week.

Subbed from the game. Some say he was having anxiety. Some say ribs. Contact minimal, but it floored him.

Lots of talk going around that he in fact has shingles and took to the field against Geelong with it.

 

[Happy_Neale]

Did he?

Also missed a session with an eye infection last week.

Subbed from the game. Some say he was having anxiety. Some say ribs. Contact minimal, but it floored him.

Lots of talk going around that he in fact has shingles and took to the field against Geelong with it.

Well in that case the people suggesting it must have thoroughly inspected his body for a rash

 

[The Mares Leg]

Well in that case the people suggesting it must have thoroughly inspected his body for a rash

Not to mention it generally targets 40-70 year old males who have had Chicken Pox.

 

[Thuggee_Cult]

IIRC didn’t he get a heavy collision late in the Freo game in Round 24?

Could that be the issue?

 

[tenderwarrior]

Port also put Allir back on after he was concussed..

Butters was driving the decision to be subbed off

He'd want a big game this week because he was as SOFT AS BUTTER last Thursday

Can't believe he is not margarine!

 

[Cyclops]

So, Butters has shingles, presumably from eating BBQ ribs, and anxiety because of Petracca?

Coherent, sensible analysis. Good to see posters putting their brains to work.

 

[GudOnya]

As I said, you’re welcome to believe anything you want - but nobody has given me a reason to think or believe it eas anything but what the match report says it was.

Are you saying it was Men from Mars and a tractor beam? Or are you saying it was a drug overdose? Or ?

That was my first post in this thread so the only thing I was saying is that the AFL would sign off on anything they thought they could get away with. Believing what they say is naïve at best.