List Mgmt. Our List 2014 - Trade, De-list and Draft - (keep it all in here)

[happydude]

always... too many people take this bullshit seriously... as if the Carlton recruiters are going to read this piece of humourous rubbish of a thread, spot pinot's constant posts about trading our stars for bullshit and think hmmm... this guy is on to something here.

We'd be lucky if they did read them and didnt burst out laughing at the thought.

dont worry i got it

 

[ferrisb]

Do you mean Matt Crouch? Would be awesome if we got him !

Yes, I did mean Matt. Not as 'skilled' as his brother Brad, but have read good things (mostly on BF, admittedly) about inside ball ability. Sounds like he might go 'high single digits' in the draft...

 

[Bradschi]

I wouldn't do a straight trade Yarran for Gumbleton.

No sane human being will do it, Lloyd has just lost his marbles.

Yes, I did mean Matt. Not as 'skilled' as his brother Brad, but have read good things (mostly on BF, admittedly) about inside ball ability. Sounds like he might go 'high single digits' in the draft...

definitely in the top 15 players at the draft this year.

 

[smashbox gill]

Im more excited about nathan Freeman that Matt Crouch. But Matt does seem like a great prospect, was touted as one of the potential mini draft selections

 

[Faz 2000]

Im more excited about nathan Freeman that Matt Crouch. But Matt does seem like a great prospect, was touted as one of the potential mini draft selections

Need to do some aggressive trading and double-dip in the first round.

 

[Pratt = Premiers]

Appoligise if already raised, but what are thoughts on three way trade between carlton, Melbourne and west coast. Yarran to west coast, Mitch brown and 2nd round pick to demons and frawley to carlton.

I feel carlton and west coast would be happy, not sure about Melbourne; can't justify a first round pick and brown, but pick in mid 20's plus brown seems just under the requirement.

 

[pinot]

Im more excited about nathan Freeman that Matt Crouch. But Matt does seem like a great prospect, was touted as one of the potential mini draft selections

The draft is four rounds deep so this year a pick 50 will get you a Graham. is what I have been told.

 

[slashin_velvet]

Appoligise if already raised, but what are thoughts on three way trade between carlton, Melbourne and west coast. Yarran to west coast, Mitch brown and 2nd round pick to demons and frawley to carlton.

I feel carlton and west coast would be happy, not sure about Melbourne; can't justify a first round pick and brown, but pick in mid 20's plus brown seems just under the requirement.

I like it.....but dont want to lose yarran.

I'd add a couple more limbs to the deal so it was:
Yarran to West Coast
Mitch Brown, 2nd Round (WC) and 3rd Round (Carl) to Melbourne
Frawley and Magner to Carlton

 

[Cringle]

I like it.....but dont want to lose yarran.

I'd add a couple more limbs to the deal so it was:
Yarran to West Coast
Mitch Brown, 2nd Round (WC) and 3rd Round (Carl) to Melbourne
Frawley and Magner to Carlton

Whose he?

 

[King of Ruin]

Whose he?

James Magner.

 

[Cringle]

James Magner.

Had a bit of a google. Remember his face, but personally dont watch much of Melbourne's games... atm are a joke of a team and shouldn't be televised in any state. Harsh yes. But no one enjoys watching 30-70 point whompings unless its your team. Even if the game is close, it'll end up being a low class bottom 4 clash.

Anyway, to the trade. Wouldnt mind a try at Tapscott. If we must chuck a second rounder in, we should, but then grab another second rounder from Warnock trade... if we can.

 

[Quazza]

Appoligise if already raised, but what are thoughts on three way trade between carlton, Melbourne and west coast. Yarran to west coast, Mitch brown and 2nd round pick to demons and frawley to carlton.

I feel carlton and west coast would be happy, not sure about Melbourne; can't justify a first round pick and brown, but pick in mid 20's plus brown seems just under the requirement.

where do I sign?

 

[I bleed Blue]

Appoligise if already raised, but what are thoughts on three way trade between carlton, Melbourne and west coast. Yarran to west coast, Mitch brown and 2nd round pick to demons and frawley to carlton.

I feel carlton and west coast would be happy, not sure about Melbourne; can't justify a first round pick and brown, but pick in mid 20's plus brown seems just under the requirement.

No way Melbourne would do that

 

[Big_Luch]

Appoligise if already raised, but what are thoughts on three way trade between carlton, Melbourne and west coast. Yarran to west coast, Mitch brown and 2nd round pick to demons and frawley to carlton.

I feel carlton and west coast would be happy, not sure about Melbourne; can't justify a first round pick and brown, but pick in mid 20's plus brown seems just under the requirement.

id take that trade in an instant.

with glass' retirement imminent i think Brown will want to stay, plus he is getting games this year.

 

[Silvagnis]

where do I sign?

We sign after Melbourne let Carlton and WC hold their trillion dollar bill.

 

[LanceRomance]

Dale Thomas will re-sign soon: Walsh


what's all this about?

I thought he was already in navy blue

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

sheedy lured our delisted players for nothing?

Camporeale and Matty Allan.

 

[Dramoth]

Dale Thomas will re-sign soon: Walsh


what's all this about?

I thought he was already in navy blue

I think that it is Walsh putting out some bullshit to try and placate the filth supporters. Until Thomas puts pen to paper, he is still a blue.

 

[LanceRomance]

I think that it is Walsh putting out some bullshit to try and placate the filth supporters. Until Thomas puts pen to paper, he is still a blue.

 

[slashin_velvet]

Whose he?

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/player-profile/james-magner

Only played 2 games this year due to being on the rookie list, but is a great player and would be good steak knives in that deal. I'd see if we can lure him accross regardless.

 

[Kramer1]

Magner is just another plodder to add to out plod pile. No thanks.

 

[Bradschi]

I feel carlton and west coast would be happy, not sure about Melbourne; can't justify a first round pick and brown, but pick in mid 20's plus brown seems just under the requirement.

Melbourne isnt exactly a club that is in a position to bargain.

 

[pjhad1]

Problem is ... Tom Bellchambers is having a cracking past few weeks ... they'll go for him instead.

He won't be playing next year... ASADA investigation results are apparently expected before finals and trade period

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

He won't be playing next year... ASADA investigation results are apparently expected before finals and trade period

The players won't be affected personally - there will be no bans.

The club will be affected, as they have will have been found to have breached their duty of care to their players.

 

[Aphrodite]

The players won't be affected personally - there will be no bans.

The club will be affected, as they have will have been found to have breached their duty of care to their players.

Source