List Mgmt. Our Trade/FA, Suburban & Country Town Thread

[Fat Jesus]

Allan straight swap for Petracca

No way. Not interested. I know you're trying to poke the bear mate.

 

[Apex36]

Sorry, I can’t type any slower to assist you with your understanding.

I want him to keep going, watching him dig in despite being told in plain English specifically what your post was in relation to is a sight to behold.

And that’s the god damn truth!

 

[Pleasedontfail11]

You're being silly now.

And trolling Fat Jesus

I'm a bad little boy.....

 

[Scodog10]

Might be later in the week..next week.

Not all signings need to be done or announced in the one day.

They don’t need to with Richards being the obvious one, but unlike the others still OOC he has a contract decision to make. A rookie OOC post exit interviews with so many options ahead of him brought in as a mature ager sits comfortably in the unlikely basket until post trade week.

 

[MooreDaicos]

Based on the tweet, we have or could have made the space for Lukosius $1M. We were interested if it was a salary dump situation. Would make sense, trying to get back into the first round of the draft.

Maybe we'll try to get a first round pick by taking Lynchballs contract, maybe our future 1st for their mid 1st + F2nd as a last resort if tigs don't play ball with just giving us one with Lynch. Then keep pick 20 for the draft that we get for JFN and use ports pick for Richards to get Davies. Maybe extra picks swapped between us and GC.
If anyone else goes (Johnson ) then that's bonus picks

 

[Doc1763]

Best thing they could do. Add their CEO & President...& Petracca stays.

I'd rather Goodwin, Pert and their clueless president all stay and Petracca come to us.

 

[JuniorB]

I don’t know what condition he is in. Neither do you. But he’s turning 29 and there are question marks. He still hasn’t been allowed to work out at a heart rate exceeding 100bpm, what, two months after the injury? That’s brisk walk level of exercise.

And after such a long break, will he still have the hunger? The willingness to run himself into the ground and fearlessly out his body on the line?

Given the uncertainties and age, we shouldn’t be mortgaging the farm to get him. It needs to be at bargain trade price to reflect the risk.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

The heart rate limitation is until his spleen is fully healed, then he'll be fine physically.
Mentally might be a different story.

 

[Fat Jesus]

I'd rather Goodwin, Pert and their clueless president all stay and Petracca come to us.

Agree. It's like the hope for Voss getting a coaching extension.

 

[Scodog10]

Maybe we'll try to get a first round pick by taking Lynchballs contract, maybe our future 1st for their mid 1st + F2nd as a last resort if tigs don't play ball with just giving us one with Lynch. Then keep pick 20 for the draft that we get for JFN and use ports pick for Richards to get Davies. Maybe extra picks swapped between us and GC.
If anyone else goes (Johnson ) then that's bonus picks

Lot of maybe’s there. When was the last time we orchestrated one trade lopsided toward us let alone 3?

 

[MooreDaicos]

Lot of maybe’s there. When was the last time we orchestrated one trade lopsided toward us let alone 3?

It costs nothing to dream

 

[sr36]

Exactly, he’s 28 now and wants to make a call, I also don’t get all the crap about Brand Petracca, he’s looking after his future and current arrangements, he more than entitled to maximise his brand and opportunities moving forward.

Maybe it's all a crock of shit and he's just getting free exposure for Brand Petracca.

 

[No SPIN]

Then why wasn’t he re-contracted alongside Steene today? He’s behind Moore, Frampton, Dean and probably Keane in 2025 and it probably comes down to him or Krueger up forward unless we bring someone in which puts heat on both of them.

I don’t think all the remaining uncontracted players are automatic delists. In that group of defenders, at 200cm he’s the only one who could challenge Framptons in the role on monster talls ( I’m not including Moore).
And to be honest I wouldn’t mind Frampton coping some selection pressure,

 

[JuniorB]

Allan straight swap for Petracca

No

 

[Go Woods]

If we cant afford Luko, then we def can't afford CP unless dees pay some of his salary in a dump

More like we can't afford both, so I'm sure the preference is get Trac.

 

[Apex36]

Lot of maybe’s there. When was the last time we orchestrated one trade lopsided toward us let alone 3?

Bobby Hill for future pick 36

 

[TakingThePies]

If we cant afford Luko, then we def can't afford CP unless dees pay some of his salary in a dump

They can afford Luko, but we wanted a first with him like e.g Bowes.

 

[nahnah]

I doubt Allan's parents would approve a move to Melbourne. Wouldn't want to have their son hooked on Goodwin little bag of goodies

 

[Jasper84]

Probably same people whining that Pendles and Sidey are too old.
These two geezers would still make best 23 in any side.

I'm over the moon that we have Edward to help out Nick.

Whilst I agree, what would really help Nick right now is the opposition having to choose whether to go to him or Petracca. It also lets JDG be our most damaging forward.

 

[Bianconeri]

Lipinski went for pick 43. Anything to suggest Noble or Richards will get a pick in the low 20s???

Noble is best 22, Lipinski’s was
not at the time of the trade. Richards is being offered a 3 year deal.

 

[Scodog10]

Bobby Hill for future pick 36

Next two?

 

[sr36]

They don’t need to with Richards being the obvious one, but unlike the others still OOC he has a contract decision to make. A rookie OOC post exit interviews with so many options ahead of him brought in as a mature ager sits comfortably in the unlikely basket until post trade week.

That's what I think too. Richards has a decision to make. The others are hoping for an offer from any club and we'll make final decisions on them after we see where we're at post trade week.

 

[watt price tully]

We should be offering Richards 3 years too unless he’s part of a deal that benefits Collingwood. I’d much prefer he remains with “us”.

 

[Silky23]

I find it laughable that people don’t think Trac won’t make it back to an elite level. He’s an ULTRA pro. He takes care of his body like he’s a messiah.

Take out his rookie year due to the ACL, plus the first 4 years forward, he hasn’t even played 100 afl games combined as an elite mid, so the mileage is also not there as a crash and bash contested beast.

Hes 29, but I dare say he still has at a minimum 5 years worth of his best footy ahead of him.

To think he would not be a huge get at whatever the cost, is blasphemous.

 

[NMBB]

Players aside, a Dees mate reckons Goodwin may be sacked in the next week.
I call BS but he’s adamant he’s heard it from a senior Melbourne official.

Melbourne Football Club - fantastic!

 

[Fat Jesus]

I find it laughable that people don’t think Trac won’t make it back to an elite level. He’s an ULTRA pro. He takes care of his body like he’s a messiah.

Take out his rookie year due to the ACL, plus the first 4 years forward, he hasn’t even played 100 afl games combined as an elite mid, so the mileage is also not there as a crash and bash contested beast.

Hes 29, but I dare say he still has at a minimum 5 years worth of his best footy ahead of him.

To think he would not be a huge get at whatever the cost, is blasphemous.

Agree with everything. Except at "whatever the cost"