Pick 1 2023 Trade value - What would it take?

[bzparkes]

ok let's look at west coasts fwd options for the future:

Oscar Allen- great
Jake Waterman- decent role player
Jack Williams- unproven
Ryan Maric - unproven
Callum Jamieson- Nope
Barnett- unproven, ruck?

So JVR would go immediately to your 2nd best forward.

Wce just need good players across the park. I think if wce are real with themselves about their list it will most likely mean that they will try to split their pick.

He's undersized. Could replace Darling in a couple of years, I guess.

 

[Cursedsword02]

ok let's look at west coasts fwd options for the future:

Oscar Allen- great
Jake Waterman- decent role player
Jack Williams- unproven
Ryan Maric - unproven
Callum Jamieson- Nope
Barnett- unproven, ruck?

So JVR would go immediately to your 2nd best forward.

Wce just need good players across the park. I think if wce are real with themselves about their list it will most likely mean that they will try to split their pick.

A fat load of good JVR would do if the ball can't get there well enough.

It's clear you've never watched us or seen our stats, we were easily the worst side for clearances and scoring from clearances this year. Why would we give away Pick 1 (to a flag contender no less) when the player at that position is exactly what our side has been crying out for for years?

 

[boncer34]

You'd imagine Maric's superior ability to get his hands on the pill would only increase if he and JVR switched teams.

 

[Big_Birdy]

ok let's look at west coasts fwd options for the future:

Oscar Allen- great
Jake Waterman- decent role player
Jack Williams- unproven
Ryan Maric - unproven
Callum Jamieson- Nope
Barnett- unproven, ruck?

So JVR would go immediately to your 2nd best forward.

Wce just need good players across the park. I think if wce are real with themselves about their list it will most likely mean that they will try to split their pick.

Are you only naming talls? Long looks OK.

There is also AA player Liam Ryan.

 

[Mich0]

To be fair Rivers makes a hell of a lot more sense than JvR.

Could inject him right into the midfield to help protect the youngsters. Bloke is a unit.

 

[bh90210fan]

To be fair Rivers makes a hell of a lot more sense than JvR.

Could inject him right into the midfield to help protect the youngsters.

Or we could just get Robertson to do that for cheap while still securing Reid, win/win

 

[Cursedsword02]

To be fair Rivers makes a hell of a lot more sense than JvR.

Could inject him right into the midfield to help protect the youngsters.

His contract lasting 'til 2027 makes that a harder play than JVR though. As much sense as it makes team-wise.

 

[Mich0]

Or we could just get Robertson to do that for cheap while still securing Reid, win/win

Would have thought one of the arguably worse teams of all time would be keen to turn over as many players as possible.

 

[GoEaglesGoSGIO]

Would have thought one of the arguably worse teams of all time would be keen to turn over as many players as possible.

Need to space it out over 3 years and not do it all in 1. Likely to turn over 7 players this year but 3 of those will be current listed but young players in Brockman/Robertson and then one of Sweet/Nick Bryan

Next year we will have a few to easily move on still but no point rushing it and paying them out to use pick 80 is all

 

[bh90210fan]

Would have thought one of the arguably worse teams of all time would be keen to turn over as many players as possible.

Don’t think we’d get too far by giving up generational talent for half back flankers though

 

[GoEaglesGoSGIO]

Don’t think we’d get too far by giving up generational talent for half back flankers though

Something to think about with regards to giving up 1 thing for a ton of picks

For Tim Kelly, Eagles gave up

Pick 16 - Cooper Stephens (traded already, cant get a game)
Pick 27 - Jeremy Sharp (to be traded)
Pick 36 - Nick Bryan (2nd choice ruck. Likely to leave)
Pick 18 - Ryan Angwin (battler not in the regular team)

Just proof that alot of nothing isnt necessarily as good as the actual thing

 

[bzparkes]

Would have thought one of the arguably worse teams of all time would be keen to turn over as many players as possible.

And do what to replace them?

 

[GoEaglesGoSGIO]

And do what to replace them?

Use Pick 120 in the draft of course.

 

[Big_Birdy]

Something to think about with regards to giving up 1 thing for a ton of picks

For Tim Kelly, Eagles gave up

Pick 16 - Cooper Whyte (delisted)
Pick 27 - Jeremy Sharp (to be traded)
Pick 36 - Nick Bryan (2nd choice ruck. Likely to leave)
Pick 18 - Ryan Angwin (battler not in the regular team)

Just proof that alot of nothing isnt necessarily as good as the actual thing

That's not correct. It was Cooper Stephens, who was traded to Hawks (and hasn't gotten a game with them either).

 

[bzparkes]

Use Pick 120 in the draft of course.

Unlikely to get another Brett Heady in that range, unfortunately

 

[GoEaglesGoSGIO]

That's not correct. It was Cooper Stephens, who was traded to Hawks (and hasn't gotten a game with them either).

Ah read that wrong. Not much difference I suppose

 

[danster168]

A fat load of good JVR would do if the ball can't get there well enough.

It's clear you've never watched us or seen our stats, we were easily the worst side for clearances and scoring from clearances this year. Why would we give away Pick 1 (to a flag contender no less) when the player at that position is exactly what our side has been crying out for for years?

you just picked up Ginbey and Hewett. 2 elite mids (well they were at least early picks). it's not that dire.

 

[Get_The_Gaff]

The WC fans who think Reid is worth any more then the current cream of the crop AFL players is laughable.

Why can't everyone just shut up and let us take Reid then ?

Its a national competition.

All I hear is a Victorian narrative that west coast should take a shit deal so a once in a generation Victorian can stay home

 

[Get_The_Gaff]

ok let's look at west coasts fwd options for the future:

Oscar Allen- great
Jake Waterman- decent role player
Jack Williams- unproven
Ryan Maric - unproven
Callum Jamieson- Nope
Barnett- unproven, ruck?

So JVR would go immediately to your 2nd best forward.

Wce just need good players across the park. I think if wce are real with themselves about their list it will most likely mean that they will try to split their pick.

Nah we should just take Reid our recruitment staff have no problem picking KPPs .

 

[bzparkes]

you just picked up Ginbey and Hewett. 2 elite mids (well they were at least early picks). it's not that dire.

Sweet, so we pick up one more so that can be our centre square/onballer brigade for the next 10+ years.

 

[Big_Birdy]

Ah read that wrong. Not much difference I suppose

The way it’s going there will be zero difference by the end of 2024

 

[GoEaglesGoSGIO]

you just picked up Ginbey and Hewett. 2 elite mids (well they were at least early picks). it's not that dire.

And Ryan Maric who would clearly go top 20 if he was available. It’s not that dire

 

[Mich0]

Something to think about with regards to giving up 1 thing for a ton of picks

For Tim Kelly, Eagles gave up

Pick 16 - Cooper Stephens (traded already, cant get a game)
Pick 27 - Jeremy Sharp (to be traded)
Pick 36 - Nick Bryan (2nd choice ruck. Likely to leave)
Pick 18 - Ryan Angwin (battler not in the regular team)

Just proof that alot of nothing isnt necessarily as good as the actual thing

This goes both ways of you bring up Adelaide Dawson, Rankin and Rachelle /JHF scenario

 

[bzparkes]

Looks like even Ralph is finally cooling on a trade happening. Guess the 'jungle drums' have stopped beating.

 

[Jupes]

ok let's look at west coasts fwd options for the future:

Oscar Allen- great
Jake Waterman- decent role player
Jack Williams- unproven
Ryan Maric - unproven
Callum Jamieson- Nope
Barnett- unproven, ruck?

So JVR would go immediately to your 2nd best forward.

Wce just need good players across the park. I think if wce are real with themselves about their list it will most likely mean that they will try to split their pick.

so would reid lol