Prediction Pick 6

Who do we get at pick 6

  • Cam Rayner

    Votes: 6 2.2%
  • Paddy Dow

    Votes: 1 0.4%
  • Luke Davies-Uniacke

    Votes: 1 0.4%
  • Adam Cerra

    Votes: 15 5.4%
  • Jaidyn Stephenson

    Votes: 27 9.8%
  • Andrew Brayshaw

    Votes: 13 4.7%
  • Darcy Fogarty

    Votes: 113 40.9%
  • Nick Coffield

    Votes: 59 21.4%
  • Jarrod Brander

    Votes: 20 7.2%
  • Aaron Naughton

    Votes: 42 15.2%
  • Other

    Votes: 10 3.6%
  • Aiden Bonar

    Votes: 15 5.4%
  • Nathan Murphy

    Votes: 3 1.1%

  • Total voters
    276
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

And you don't think you're betting on both sides a little by claiming that he never gets on the park, yet you know for certain that he never had any ability as a player?

But hard to make a categorical assessment when he plays so rarely, no?

No it really isn’t. When I’m told that Freeman “doesn’t get it” by a player and then see what he’s done in his limited time on the park it makes a lot more sense than listening to BF experts talk about him...
 
Ultimately l voted for Naughton, and l will stay with that.
Also it would not surprise me if one of Fogarty, Stephenson and Murphy is picked.
If we want a better forward than the fog then Bonar is the kid. Comes with high risk no doubt, but high reward as well. Just don’t see the club pulling the trigger though.
Safe pick Naughton, is how l see the club rolling this year
 

Log in to remove this ad.

For the sake of ER departments around the country I hope the utility Hine was alluding to wasn't Murphy.

Hopes are now so high for The Fog Boy.

If the Fogger is not named at 6.. I'll get the meltdown hine thread up and running.
 
Ultimately l voted for Naughton, and l will stay with that.
Also it would not surprise me if one of Fogarty, Stephenson and Murphy is picked.
If we want a better forward than the fog then Bonar is the kid. Comes with high risk no doubt, but high reward as well. Just don’t see the club pulling the trigger though.
Safe pick Naughton, is how l see the club rolling this year

I'd be happy with that as well re when everything settles down.. but seriously.. the Fog man if they don't get him.. I'd be seriously pissed for a good week I reckon re
 
Don’t feel bad about it the same happened with Toumpas. When he was traded to the Power and even post 2016 Power fans still thought he had it. The problem is the system got the talent ID wrong on them.
Wow, that is a great comparison notwithstanding Aish has played about 1/2 as many more games...
Screen Shot 2017-11-24 at 9.02.27 am.png
 
Fogarty, Naughton or Stephenson all fill a need for us - be happy with any of them, but if the club is satisfied his apparent medical issue won't inhibit him, then I'm mainly hoping for Stephenson. We need more exciting players on the list.
 
Ultimately l voted for Naughton, and l will stay with that.
Also it would not surprise me if one of Fogarty, Stephenson and Murphy is picked.
If we want a better forward than the fog then Bonar is the kid. Comes with high risk no doubt, but high reward as well. Just don’t see the club pulling the trigger though.
Safe pick Naughton, is how l see the club rolling this year
On a needs basis you've really got to go for Naughton but I am convinced we will go for Fogarty now. Hine did seem to imply we would look at picking up a big guy with pick 38. I am looking forward to the draft tonight given the lack of certainty over the order and our selections.
 
Shifter on SEN saying Stephenson has absolutely no problems with his heart (or at least if not no problems, he has at least been cleared to be selected and play).

I only caught the back end of it but he's saying over the last 24 hours it sounds like this has been clarified? Did anyone hear the whole thing?

If we think he is healthy...have no problems taking him. Seems to be quite freaky
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

If we think he is healthy...have no problems taking him. Seems to be quite freaky
He's been the dream since day one, if heart problems didn't enter into it.

He's exactly the type we need, and exactly the type Dekka likes - goalkicking mid with a bit of versatility and the tendency to show up big in big games.
 
Shifter on SEN saying Stephenson has absolutely no problems with his heart (or at least if not no problems, he has at least been cleared to be selected and play).

I only caught the back end of it but he's saying over the last 24 hours it sounds like this has been clarified? Did anyone hear the whole thing?

Shifter would talk up a bloke that’s had an arm amputated he’s probably the last bloke I’d go to for this type of stuff. Think of him as a Walmart spruiker who’s job is literally to talk up any and every prospect!
 
Have we got the 'Welcome to Collingwood Darcy Fogarty' thread ready to go?

My predicted top 6

1. Rayner
2. LDU (Cerra)
3. Dow
4. Brayshaw
5. Cerra (LDU)
6. Fogarty

Freo want Cerra and LDU - and I think they will get both.
Whoever they select at 2, I think the other one will be there at 5, as Blues are set on Dow and Kangas very keen on Brayshaw.

That leaves us open for Fogarty - with Stephenson the only other name linked to us.
 
Have we got the 'Welcome to Collingwood Darcy Fogarty' thread ready to go?

My predicted top 6

1. Rayner
2. LDU (Cerra)
3. Dow
4. Brayshaw
5. Cerra (LDU)
6. Fogarty

Freo want Cerra and LDU - and I think they will get both.
Whoever they select at 2, I think the other one will be there at 5, as Blues are set on Dow and Kangas very keen on Brayshaw.

That leaves us open for Fogarty - with Stephenson the only other name linked to us.

Dave has been a lil slack this morning.. Daaaaave wake up reeee.. get it going reee.. stop procrastinating.
 
Have we got the 'Welcome to Collingwood Darcy Fogarty' thread ready to go?

My predicted top 6

1. Rayner
2. LDU (Cerra)
3. Dow
4. Brayshaw
5. Cerra (LDU)
6. Fogarty

Freo want Cerra and LDU - and I think they will get both.
Whoever they select at 2, I think the other one will be there at 5, as Blues are set on Dow and Kangas very keen on Brayshaw.

That leaves us open for Fogarty - with Stephenson the only other name linked to us.

and unfortunately Naughton. Even though Hine said mids/utility on the CFC video, I'm not buying what he's selling.
 
No it really isn’t. When I’m told that Freeman “doesn’t get it” by a player and then see what he’s done in his limited time on the park it makes a lot more sense than listening to BF experts talk about him...
Doesn’t get it as in what’s required to be a pro footy player, or doesn’t get it as in he’s clueless on the field?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Prediction Pick 6

Back
Top