-
AFLW 2024 - Round 4 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Pick the ins and outs this week v Collingwood and win a prize
- Thread starter Kildonan
- Start date
- Tagged users None
DanACTsaint
Debutant
In: Goddard, King, Stanley
Out: Pattison, Gardiner, Steven
Out: Pattison, Gardiner, Steven
in goddard out dorkson
dan0z
Club Legend
In: Goddard
Out: Mini
Out: Mini
Despite Stanley being in the bests for the VFL and the fact that I'd like to see him, I just don't see it. I simply can't see it happening.
OUT: Geary, Pattison
IN: Koschitzke, Goddard
Structure>Form is my thinking.
OUT: Geary, Pattison
IN: Koschitzke, Goddard
Structure>Form is my thinking.
Plugger35
Umpiring Expert
- Sep 27, 2008
- 140,070
- 162,180
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Other Teams
- Chelsea, Black Caps, Sea Eagles, Subiaco
Yes, you're probably right.
Except for Plugger35 who legitimately thinks Patto should be dropped for Rhys.
Well I have to get Stanley back into the team somehow.
To be honest I didn't watch the Brisbane game (only listened to the radio coverage) so I didn't see Pattison's game. By all reports he seemed to go OK so I wouldn't be against him staying in the side, just think Stanley has more to offer as a key forward.
Ideally Kosi will be fit anyway, in which case he'll probably replace Pattison.
Michael Scarn
Club Legend
no change.
Papa Juggs
Hall of Famer
- Banned
- #33
I think mine was already taken so I have to pick again.
I'll go for Patto to get the chop. Might not be the best to play him in a real top4 clash.
Out Patto, Steven, Dempster
In Goddard, Kosi, Clarke
I'll go for Patto to get the chop. Might not be the best to play him in a real top4 clash.
Out Patto, Steven, Dempster
In Goddard, Kosi, Clarke
sammm
Premium Platinum
according to the official injury list clarke is out for 1 more week. and then i assume he would to go back into the vfl to gain touch.
Look2Me4Guidance
Destination Club Supporter
Logic hat on.
BJ is an automatic in.
No way Dempster gets dropped with Collingwood's multiple mid/small forwards.
Kosi sounds doubtful, but I wouldn't be surprised someone has pulled up far too sore from the Gabba, so we'll roll the dice and go with.
In: Goddard
Out: Gardiner
BJ is an automatic in.
No way Dempster gets dropped with Collingwood's multiple mid/small forwards.
Kosi sounds doubtful, but I wouldn't be surprised someone has pulled up far too sore from the Gabba, so we'll roll the dice and go with.
In: Goddard
Out: Gardiner
Schneider looked really sore towards the end. And seeing as probably everything else has been taken:
IN: Goddard
OUT: Schneider
IN: Goddard
OUT: Schneider
Look2Me4Guidance
Destination Club Supporter
This was my thinking as well, but he did jam home a goal after his painful episode.
stkildathunda
DEMPSTERED
10k Posts
St Kilda Saints - Tom Ledger 2012 Player Sponsor
St Kilda Saints - Nicholas Heyne 2011 Player Sponsor
St Kilda Saints - Nicholas Heyne 2010 Player Sponsor
Just had a quick look and not one person thought Ben McEvoy would be ommitted. Shows how suprising tonights selections are.
Plugger35
Umpiring Expert
- Sep 27, 2008
- 140,070
- 162,180
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Other Teams
- Chelsea, Black Caps, Sea Eagles, Subiaco
Yeah McEvoy out was a big surprise, bit of a surprise to see Dempster out as well.
I think most people picked Goddard and Kosi as the ins.
I think most people picked Goddard and Kosi as the ins.
StFly
Space to Rent
- Moderator
- #41
Not as big for mine, one of McEvoy or Patto were going to be dropped simply because bringing 3 rucks only works rarely.
I went more on where the deficiencies are as opposed to what teh changes were most likely to be, we've lost the clearances and contested ball for the last couple games so figured it'd be easier to sacrifice a couple outside mids for some inside out ones, which ultimately mandated a like for like swap.
I'm hoping not to win anyway. But yeah, a ruckman was definitely getting dropped this week, especially on the back of Kosi coming in (in all liklihood at the time), simply a question of who it was.
I went more on where the deficiencies are as opposed to what teh changes were most likely to be, we've lost the clearances and contested ball for the last couple games so figured it'd be easier to sacrifice a couple outside mids for some inside out ones, which ultimately mandated a like for like swap.
I'm hoping not to win anyway.
But yeah, a ruckman was definitely getting dropped this week, especially on the back of Kosi coming in (in all liklihood at the time), simply a question of who it was.
- Banned
- #42
I heard Kosi is a 50/50 to play this week.
and if he does pull up sore, and McEvoy takes his place...
I WIN!!!
cue the cheesy inspirational music!!!
[YOUTUBE]54_NJVoBHmA[/YOUTUBE]
and if he does pull up sore, and McEvoy takes his place...
I WIN!!!
cue the cheesy inspirational music!!!
[YOUTUBE]54_NJVoBHmA[/YOUTUBE]
It's funny that more people didn't expect it really. My 20:20 hindight tells me Pattison is probably at least as good as McEvoy at the moment ( though I expect Macca to gain a bit of ground in the future ).
karmafree
Club Legend
I am also not surprised, I thought it would be Gardy, with Kosi back it had to be one of the big three rucks.
I say change it around.
Like tip who gets most touches and how many. Most goals, etc.
Personally I like 'guess how many behinds Collingwood scores' for this week
Like tip who gets most touches and how many. Most goals, etc.
Personally I like 'guess how many behinds Collingwood scores' for this week
stkildathunda
DEMPSTERED
10k Posts
St Kilda Saints - Tom Ledger 2012 Player Sponsor
St Kilda Saints - Nicholas Heyne 2011 Player Sponsor
St Kilda Saints - Nicholas Heyne 2010 Player Sponsor
22 :d
Similar threads
- Locked
