List Mgmt. Player Ages Thread

[HirdyLannister]

So please hear me out

I don't know if we can but can we make a play for Daisy Thomas?

- His value right now is low due to his injury.

- Collingwood need a ruckman as Jolly is no spring chicken.

- Collingwood need another tall forward to play with Cloke as lynch was a quick bandaid because they thought the could push for a flag this year plus lynch is old as well.

- The only thing that I can think of that might stop us is our salary cap.

Bellchambers + first round = Daisy?

Bellchambers + Gumby = Daisy?

Gumby + first round = Daisy?

Bellchambers + Gumby + second round = Daisy?

Thoughts??????
Or am I dreaming

 

[sneakyjetta]

Harley Bennell, Lewis Jetta, David Zaharakis immediately spring to mind. Chris Yarran is no where near any of these guys

hahaha

and people call me a troll

 

[Old Campaigner]

I don't know if we would bother unless a player wanted out and we wanted to be adequately compensated. The club has made no secret of it's desire for internal development of it's players rather than bringing in outsiders (Goddard was a lucky windfall in that it cost us nothing in terms of picks/trades), and I think they'll want to continue that way. We've shown we can identify and develop young talent, I'm not sure why we need a Yarran or a Thomas. It's not like there are gaping holes in the team structure that need to be filled ASAP for us to move forward.

 

[eth-dog]

hahaha

and people call me a troll

They are so far ahead of Yarran it's not funny. Zaka averages more kicks than Yarran does possessions, and more effective possessions than Yarran does possessions. So tell me how Yarran is an "elite outside mid". The same with Harley Bennell. Seriously, **** off, you've obviously got no clue

 

[Old Campaigner]

They are so far ahead of Yarran it's not funny. Zaka averages more kicks than Yarran does possessions, and more effective possessions than Yarran does possessions. So tell me how Yarran is an "elite outside mid". The same with Harley Bennell. Seriously, **** off, you've obviously got no clue

b-bbut yarran is fast and elite

 

[Zach Package]

So please hear me out

I don't know if we can but can we make a play for Daisy Thomas?

- His value right now is low due to his injury.

- Collingwood need a ruckman as Jolly is no spring chicken.

- Collingwood need another tall forward to play with Cloke as lynch was a quick bandaid because they thought the could push for a flag this year plus lynch is old as well.

- The only thing that I can think of that might stop us is our salary cap.

Bellchambers + first round = Daisy?

Bellchambers + Gumby = Daisy?

Gumby + first round = Daisy?

Bellchambers + Gumby + second round = Daisy?

Thoughts??????
Or am I dreaming

He's a FA in any event but that last one would make me absolutely murderous with rage

 

[JETTA7]

They are so far ahead of Yarran it's not funny. Zaka averages more kicks than Yarran does possessions, and more effective possessions than Yarran does possessions. So tell me how Yarran is an "elite outside mid". The same with Harley Bennell. Seriously, **** off, you've obviously got no clue

This x1000

 

[eth-dog]

Oh, I forgot Daisy Thomas too

 

[JETTA7]

you could argue Steele sidebottom

 

[JETTA7]

ohh and garry ablett jnr

 

[eth-dog]

you could argue Steele sidebottom

Not yet

ohh and garry ablett jnr

He's inside/outside, so didn't include him.

And a lot of flak has come on Melksham's DE right? His is better than Yarran

 

[JETTA7]

Not yet


He's inside/outside, so didn't include him.

And a lot of flak has come on Melksham's DE right? His is better than Yarran

Still better then Yarren though.

 

[eth-dog]

Still better then Yarren though.

So's Jarryd Lyons.

 

[JETTA7]

So's Jarryd Lyons.

you wouldent happen to be a de la boy aswell then?

 

[DaSawx]

Would certainly have a crack at Daisy, sorry T-Bell, you'd be involved.

 

[eth-dog]

you wouldent happen to be a de la boy aswell then?

...mebe

 

[Zach Package]

Would certainly have a crack at Daisy, sorry T-Bell, you'd be involved.

Don't think we need daisy to be perfectly honest

 

[grugsticles]

Would certainly have a crack at Daisy, sorry T-Bell, you'd be involved.

While Id admit he would be a handy addition, the principal of having him in red and black... just doesnt gel with me. I loath him as a player.

 

[DaSawx]

Never really hated him as much as some others, just think he can be a gun player again, and would make Pies fans squirm.

 

[lil big man]

what about...

Hooker/Pears - West Coast
Brown (WC) - St Kilda
Dal Santo (StK) - Essendon

 

[eth-dog]

If we trade Bellchambers to the filth I would be ropable. We'd need to get another ruckman (Longer?) via trade and draft another ruck, probably Sikora.

 

[eth-dog]

what about...

Hooker/Pears - West Coast
Brown (WC) - St Kilda
Dal Santo (StK) - Essendon

Ridiculously favours us. No way that'll happen

 

[Phone]

i don't know why you guys keep on talking about 'us' trading TBC. If TBC is traded, he has walked in and said he's accepted a contract from (club x), you can get a trade done or I can just go in the PSD. We won't have much say in the matter...

 

[eth-dog]

Pears and Jetta to WC
LeCras to Essendon



















One can dream

 

[Vander18]

Ridiculously favours us. No way that'll happen

No interest in Dal personally but right now Hooker is the most valuable commodity in that scenario...if Hooker involved suggest it's us who won't pull the trigger.