Prediction Possible pick swaps

[philthy05]

So say right now your draft hand is 19,38,39,41,75
After this deal it would be 27,38,39,41,47

That’s worse.

It’s worse on face value and even worse when you look deeper, like that the talent probably drops off in the 20’s, or that they already have 3 picks after 19 and before 47 to target players with.

 

[The Nostradamus]

That’s worse.

Downgrade 19 to 27 to upgrade 75 to 47
It’s about the same

 

[Senor M]

So say right now your draft hand is 19,38,39,41,75
After this deal it would be 27,38,39,41,47

If you plan on only using 4 picks then the deal would not make sense

Firstly-- you haven't even got Richmond's current draft hand correct

It's 19,38, 39, 41, 56, 75-- so another pick in there than what you're suggesting-- therefore making the slide from 19 to 27 even less valuable when it's upgrading our 5th draft pick by 9 spots-- so giving up 8 spots for our first pick to gain 9 spots for our 5th pick is a horrible, horrible deal.

Personally I don't expect Richmond to use more than 4 picks anyway as we will likely upgrade some of our rookies (all of Stack, Pickett, Baker & Chol are currently rookies)

 

[The Nostradamus]

Firstly-- you haven't even got Richmond's current draft hand correct

It's 19,38, 39, 41, 56, 75-- so another pick in there than what you're suggesting-- therefore making the slide from 19 to 27 even less valuable when it's upgrading our 5th draft pick by 9 spots-- so giving up 8 spots for our first pick to gain 9 spots for our 5th pick is a horrible, horrible deal.

Personally I don't expect Richmond to use more than 4 picks anyway as we will likely upgrade some of our rookies (all of Stack, Pickett, Baker & Chol are currently rookies)

didnt see 56, play on then

 

[philthy05]

Downgrade 19 to 27 to upgrade 75 to 47
It’s about the same

Upgrading 75 to 47 is so meaningless in the context of downgrading pick 19 to 27 it’s not funny


Would you have traded your pick 8 and 73 for pick 14 and 55? Lol

 

[The Nostradamus]

Upgrading 75 to 47 is so meaningless in the context of downgrading pick 19 to 27 it’s not funny


Would you have traded your pick 8 and 73 for pick 14 and 55? Lol

The draft evens out after 10 so I wouldn’t do 8 for 14

But I would do 19 for 27 if the upgrade on the other end was large enough

 

[Senor M]

The draft evens out after 10 so I wouldn’t do 8 for 14

But I would do 19 for 27 if the upgrade on the other end was large enough

But the upgrade has to be significantly better than a mid 3rd rounder (which would've become the clubs 5th pick).

I'd say the only situation as a Richmond supporter I'd accept 19 for 27 is if it was 27 & North's 2020 Second Rounder-- but they don't have one anymore.

 

[The Nostradamus]

But the upgrade has to be significantly better than a mid 3rd rounder (which would've become the clubs 5th pick).

I'd say the only situation as a Richmond supporter I'd accept 19 for 27 is if it was 27 & North's 2020 Second Rounder-- but they don't have one anymore.

Could do 19 for 27 and 30 but that would be overs for us imo and would need a future 3rd going back our way

 

[Senor M]

Could do 19 for 27 and 30 but that would be overs for us imo and would need a future 3rd going back our way

Richmond don't need another 2019 Pick though... Richmond already have 3 Picks @ 38, 39 & 41, why would they want to split 19 for 27 & 30-- plus give away a future pick.

If Richmond trade 19 it will be for an upgrade or a 2020 pick, it definitely won't be for a downgrade like you're suggesting.

 

[year of the cat]

If I had to guess - 14 and 24?

Guess it would make sense after reports today that we have just met with and are fans of Cooper Stephens.

14 and 24 for 9 and 43?

 

[THE_GUN]

If I had to guess - 14 and 24?

Guess it would make sense after reports today that we have just met with and are fans of Cooper Stephens.

So are we .................

Move on

 

[THE_GUN]

Tigers pick 19 for north with 27 and 47?
Move down 8 spots and gain 47 so they don’t have to use pick 75

Terrible deal for the Tigers , We already have 3 picks 38,39,41 and 56

How about 19+56 for 26 & 27

 

[The Nostradamus]

Terrible deal for the Tigers , We already have 3 picks 38,39,41 and 56

How about 19+56 for 26 & 27

We are trying to use less picks. Bundle 2 of ours for 1 higher

 

[THE_GUN]

We are trying to use less picks. Bundle 2 of ours for 1 higher

Ok 19 for 26&27 then

 

[The Nostradamus]

Ok 19 for 26&27 then

Lol no chance unless you throw in a future second rounder to us

 

[THE_GUN]

Lol no chance unless you throw in a future second rounder to us

No chance , Happy with 19,38,39,41,56
will probably trade 2 for a pick that will get a better 2nd rounder 39+41 to freo for #22 would be what we would want

 

[The Nostradamus]

No chance , Happy with 19,38,39,41,56
will probably trade 2 for a pick that will get a better 2nd rounder 39+41 to freo for #22 would be what we would want

We’d just outbid with 30 and 47 for the same second rounder

 

[THE_GUN]

We’d just outbid with 30 and 47 for the same second rounder

LOL then we can just throw #56 at them to sweeten the deal , Richmond would be happy with just 3 selections and upgrade Stack & Baker
If we rate #22

 

[juss]

Downgrade 19 to 27 to upgrade 75 to 47
It’s about the same

You can't be serious. That's close to the dumbest thing I've read on this site.

 

[perplexed]

It's traditional to exchange future firsts for pick 19. Seem fair?

 

[Pure_Ownage]

Geelong coming for pick 9

We are coming for pick 8 9 or 10 it just depends who wants to deal and for what price.

 

[Pure_Ownage]

What combination of 14, 17, 24, cats future 1st and eagles future 1st do you reckon the deal will be.

14 and 24 for 9 i reckon or equivalent price to that.

 

[David C]

Tigers pick 19 for north with 27 and 47?
Move down 8 spots and gain 47 so they don’t have to use pick 75

Richmond won't be using 75 anyway. There are 4 rookie candidates for upgrading to the main list. Baker and Stack are almost certainties.

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

We are coming for pick 8 9 or 10 it just depends who wants to deal and for what price.

I think it may be something along the lines of 9 and 43 for/ 14 and 24.

 

[GatesOfHell]

We are coming for pick 8 9 or 10 it just depends who wants to deal and for what price.

Melbourne is considering three possibilities for its pick 8.

Geelong - 14 & 17
Freo - 10 & 22
Port - 12 & 18

Most likely is Freo, then Port then Geelong.

Very unlikely at this stage the Cats 14 & 24 gets them into the top 10.