-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
MVP POTY & BYB Votes Round 16 vs Melbourne @ Subi
- Thread starter silverscope
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Kickett Punches Read
Norm Smith Medallist
5- Hill- was fantastic, his line breaking and fantastic skills kept us in the game when melbourne were charging home.
4- Ballantyne- 4 goals, great chasing and harrassing. close to his best game i reckon
3- no one worthy
2- Morabito- would have been bog if he kicked straight, his field kicking was first rate, as well as his running through the lines
1- Paul Duffield- solid all day, skills werent at his best
BYP
Morabito- fantastic all day
Silvagni- really has been a consistently good player all year.
Fyfe- thought he was good early, has great skills
4- Ballantyne- 4 goals, great chasing and harrassing. close to his best game i reckon
3- no one worthy
2- Morabito- would have been bog if he kicked straight, his field kicking was first rate, as well as his running through the lines
1- Paul Duffield- solid all day, skills werent at his best
BYP
Morabito- fantastic all day
Silvagni- really has been a consistently good player all year.
Fyfe- thought he was good early, has great skills
POTY
5. Duffman
4. Ballas
3. Hill
2. Morabito
1. Sandi
BYB
3. Morabito
2. Roberton
1. Fyfe.
Great to see Luke, Broughts and Fyfe make a seamless transition back to AFL footy (although Luke & Broughts faded, to be expected I guess.)
5. Duffman
4. Ballas
3. Hill
2. Morabito
1. Sandi
BYB
3. Morabito
2. Roberton
1. Fyfe.
Great to see Luke, Broughts and Fyfe make a seamless transition back to AFL footy (although Luke & Broughts faded, to be expected I guess.)
5. Duff: Solid game and worked really hard when it counted.
4. Frodo: Most damaging forward and kicked the sealer.
3. Mundy: Dominant first half and worked extremely hard as well.
2. Hill: Brilliant flashes throughout the game but not a total 4 qtr effort.
1. McPharlin: Shored up the backline well.
BYB
3. Roberton: very good effort off half back and decision making was good.
2. Mora: Showed glimpses but kicking was poor especially when it counted.
1. Sos: Very solid down back.
4. Frodo: Most damaging forward and kicked the sealer.
3. Mundy: Dominant first half and worked extremely hard as well.
2. Hill: Brilliant flashes throughout the game but not a total 4 qtr effort.
1. McPharlin: Shored up the backline well.
BYB
3. Roberton: very good effort off half back and decision making was good.
2. Mora: Showed glimpses but kicking was poor especially when it counted.
1. Sos: Very solid down back.
5.Balla..another great game,proof that Blue Gunslinger is a great judge ??showed heaps of energy,great tackling and harrassing and iced the game.
4.Duffman..solid game ,exceptional in the last ..where he ran himself ragged,keeps getting better,even Brades is coming around
3.Hill....great all round game,excitement machine...will take mark of the century in the next couple of years
2.McPharlap...great to have him back,team looks much better with him at CHB
1.Mundy...usual solid game,consistantly one of our best.
3.Roberton....shows plenty
2.Morabito ..great clearance work ,just needs to finish off a bit better..this will come in time
1.Fyfe..love his work,really puts his body on the line and rarely gets caught with the pill
4.Duffman..solid game ,exceptional in the last ..where he ran himself ragged,keeps getting better,even Brades is coming around
3.Hill....great all round game,excitement machine...will take mark of the century in the next couple of years
2.McPharlap...great to have him back,team looks much better with him at CHB
1.Mundy...usual solid game,consistantly one of our best.
3.Roberton....shows plenty
2.Morabito ..great clearance work ,just needs to finish off a bit better..this will come in time
1.Fyfe..love his work,really puts his body on the line and rarely gets caught with the pill
- Jul 15, 2007
- 9,634
- 7,239
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Boston Celtics, Patriots
5. Duffield - solid throughout but critical in the last 1/4
4. Hill - I don't care what anybody esle says (eg. the West), he killed Scully when the whole game is taken into consideration
3. Frodo - the only player with the goal radar working, plus all the other things he does
2. Mundy - almost opposite to Duffield. Killed them in the first 1/2, faded out later but still did some good things
1. McPharlin - also faded prob due to lack of match fitness, but was all class on his return.
Unlucky: Broughton, McPhee and Ibbo all had good games too.
BYB:
3. Mora - 0-4 shooting at goal was a big disappointment, but otherwise great game
2. Roberton
1. Fyfe
4. Hill - I don't care what anybody esle says (eg. the West), he killed Scully when the whole game is taken into consideration
3. Frodo - the only player with the goal radar working, plus all the other things he does
2. Mundy - almost opposite to Duffield. Killed them in the first 1/2, faded out later but still did some good things
1. McPharlin - also faded prob due to lack of match fitness, but was all class on his return.
Unlucky: Broughton, McPhee and Ibbo all had good games too.
BYB:
3. Mora - 0-4 shooting at goal was a big disappointment, but otherwise great game
2. Roberton
1. Fyfe
Without looking at everyone else's votes...
5 votes: Dylan Roberton
4 votes: David Mundy
3 votes: Luke McPharlin
2 votes: Hayden Ballantyne
1 vote: Anthony Morabito
Sorry Duffman, Ibbo and Kepler.
5 votes: Dylan Roberton
4 votes: David Mundy
3 votes: Luke McPharlin
2 votes: Hayden Ballantyne
1 vote: Anthony Morabito
Sorry Duffman, Ibbo and Kepler.
Most have Duff in the top 3 yet he didn't get a single coaches vote. Pretty disappointing from Harvey considering Duff was just about the only Docker busting a gut to lead into space in the last quarter.
DockersMad
Cancelled
- Banned
- #38
POTY
5 Ballantyne
4 Hill
3 Ibbotson
2 Duffield
1 Sandilands
BYB
3 Fyfe
2 Morabito
1 Roberton
5 Ballantyne
4 Hill
3 Ibbotson
2 Duffield
1 Sandilands
BYB
3 Fyfe
2 Morabito
1 Roberton
- Thread starter
- #39
votes closed
