POTY Voting -R16 West Coast

[Corpuscles]

Helping out SS...For those who enjoy it (I do) vote away

Sorry had function and missed game and not yet seen the tape.. me later

 

[SouthSwans]

5 - ROK
4 - Captain Kirk
3 - Benny M
2 - Dumpster
1 - Eski
Hon. Mentions - Goodes Train, Little McVeigh.

Nobody else was above par.

 

[Footylover1]

My votes went to

5: Brett Kirk
4: Jarrad McVeigh
3: Ryan O'Keefe
2: Sean Dempster
1: Nick Malceski.

 

[natlovestheswans]

Um.. this is hard.

5. Kirk
4. ROK
3. McVeigh
2. Malceski
1. Fosdike

 

[liz]

5 ROK
4 Macca
3 The Captain
2 Fozzie
1 Dempster

Can't think of anyone who was 'unlucky' this week. Malceski did a few nice things and got enough of the ball. Plus can't fault his work rate - can we ever? But two absolute hospital passes to team mates plus a couple of other shoddy disposals counts against him this week. Goodes laid 10 tackles, which suggests he was working hard. But when we needed someone to really stand up and stem the tide, he wasn't able to break the Selwood tag.

 

[grimlock]

5 - ROK
4 - Kirk
3 - Mathews
2 - McVeigh
1 - Dempster

 

[lovetheswannies]

5 kirk
4 mcveigh
3 o'keefe
2 goodes
1 dempster

that was really tough and you're right liz, i don't think there were any "unlucky" ones
i'd love to give a few votes to malceski but his disposals definitely let him down... that one to mcveigh was more than cringe worthy

 

[Humph]

5. Kirk
4. O'Keefe
3. Malceski
2. McVeigh
1. Dempster

There was 29 tackles between Goodes, Kirk and Fossie. Did we ever have the ball in the midfield? Luv Humph.

 

[ninth_in_the_line]

5. O'Keefe
4. Kirk
3. Dempster
2. Malceski
1. McVeigh

 

[snappy]

5.. Okeefe
4.. Kirk
3.. Mcviegh
2.. Mal
1.. Dempster

 

[Anything Footy Related]

Shocking round for votes. okeefe was having a blinder up till half time then went quiet

5- Kirk
4- McVeigh
3- Okeefe
2- Malceski
1- Dempster

 

[swantastic]

5 -Captain
4 - ROK
3 - Mathews
2 - McVeigh
1 - Dempster

Both ROK and Goodes went missing when it really matterd,but ROK did enough in the first half to get 4 votes.

 

[Tuco]

5. Kirky
4. ROK
3. Mal
2. Macca
1. Dempster

Was away on Holiday this round...the only thing that made the result bareable. Another boring classic encounter.

 

[liz]

Shocking round for votes. okeefe was having a blinder up till half time then went quiet

I think that had a lot to do with him playing more as a stay at home forward than normal in a team which failed to get the ball close to its forward line for most of the third quarter.

He was instrumental in the last ditch fight back and was robbed of one very solid mark that he clearly controlled before Brett Jones knocked it out of his hands. The team scored from the next play so its hard to argue the team was affected, but it should have given him a chance to add another goal to his personal tally.

 

[SouthSwans]

Round of voting completed.

54 Kirk
50 O'Keefe
31 McVeigh
17 Malceski
15 Dempster
9 Mathews
3 Fosdike
2 Goodes