Kbroome
Club Legend
- May 10, 2024
- 1,488
- 1,522
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Okay fair i can see the logic behind what your saying and will delete my previous message because it was out of touch. I don't agree with your thoughts of holding back Paps or JMac because this is the finals and they were during the season top 10 players in the side especially both of them are crucial for team structure.I can't argue if you think you've won a debate that I've not really engaged in. I wouldn't debate Parker vs Wicks as a direct comparison really, they are different types of players (which I distinctly remember saying around the time Parker came back). There are reasons, as I've given, as to why a part time mid might have higher numbers, and why stats are not always the full picture. And I've not called for Wicks to come back in since he was dropped...
Agree with most of the changes you mention, but I'd keep Campbell in for the QF, wouldn't bring in both Paps and Jmac in the same final.