Rate my Super Coach Team III

[Unknown Identity]

Re: Rate My SuperCoach team IV

backline is almost identicle to mine. still not sure if goddard can maintain his scores from last year depending where he plays...ive got him too and i hope he does well.

i prefer teams that only have two midfield rookies which makes your team look a bit more solid with scoring potential at the start. also well done for not going with gazza...i thought i was the only one haha

as a collingwood supporter, i love jolly already...at sydney he was 'playing something like 90% gametime. i dont think he'll have that much at collingwood which may affect his scoring. that being said hes one of the best ruckmen in the comp...

slowly doubts have crept into my mind about franklin and the hawks injury concerns do little to change that. unpredictable at the best of times (which showed in the nab - big against tigers, destroyed by lake). im leaning towards higgins instead or by saving some cash, j. brown. hall has been brilliant...and yet ive taken him out of my side and im not sure why.

good side 8/10

Gary Ablett is a SC gun.
His average has gone up every season, last year he started with scores of 162, 139, 150, 197, 149

To start without him will put you 400-600 points down from the beginning..!
Not a wise move.

And Jolly's average will drop in my opinion UNLESS, he gets moved forward instead of resting on the bench.

He will only ruck 65-70 % of the game, less stoppages in collingwoods game style than sydneys.

I looked up Jolly's score's on the MCG for last season, he only played there 3 times, but surprisingly on the larger ground scored 128, 107 and 88

I don't know..? Personally i would go with McIntosh or Clark over Jolly.

Clark averaged 109 from rounds 8-22.

I think he is the one to go with if you can't afford sandilands, with Charman going down again, and Leuey is still very inexperienced, expect Clark to average close to a hundred until Charman comes back.

 

[Look2Me4Guidance]

Re: Rate My SuperCoach team IV

Just wanted to put a smile on ur face UI, and looks like ive done that
It was either Cooney or Ball and then your advice cam in to my head.

Do you think I should trade off
Shaw, Trengrove and John Brown

for either Waite, NDS and M Motlop/T Walker
or Malceski, NDS, A Davey?
or leave as is?

Malceski would be good. I'd steer clear of M Motlop and T Walker.

 

[Unknown Identity]

Re: Rate My SuperCoach team IV

Just wanted to put a smile on ur face UI, and looks like ive done that
It was either Cooney or Ball and then your advice cam in to my head.

Do you think I should trade off
Shaw, Trengrove and John Brown

for either Waite, NDS and M Motlop/T Walker
or Malceski, NDS, A Davey?
or leave as is?

well your looking at the scoring potential of Shaw and and J.Brown Vs. NDS and Waite, then Trengove Vs M.Motlop/T Walker

Personally, no brainer, leave as is.

Heath Shaw will be rotated through the midfield this year with O'Brien stepping into Shaw's role while he is up the ground.

Brown is apparently in the best shape he has been in for 5 years, and wants to move up the ground, will kick less goals, but will have more possessions.

Trengove is a guaranteed start at Melbourne, is improving each week by all reports.

NDS is a SC gun, no doubt, but pairing him with Waite coming off his knee injury, Shaw and Brown will score more early on.

I'd look at bringing Waite in after he has settled and played 6-8 weeks.
I don't see his price going up by much early on, he may even drop and you could get him cheaper.

Marlon Motlop is a much bigger risk then Trengove and Walker could be a good pick this year with rumours he is moving up the ground, not sure if this will suit him. Too many unknowns.

Leave as is mate

 

[Ranga84]

Re: Rate My SuperCoach team IV

Everybody looks to have pretty good teams IMO reckon i've nearly got mine set in stone any thoughts appreciated or rating /10?
Backs: Goddard, Hodge, Gram, Kennely, Hunt, Ladson, Waters, (Macguire, Shoenmakers)

Mids: Ablett(C), Selwood(VC), Cooney, Trengrove, Martin, Barlow (Jetta, Scully)

Rucks: Sandi, Naitanui (Warnock, Lobbe)

Forwards: Goodes, Reiwoldt, Didak, Harvey, Dangerfield, Ziebell, Rohan (Rockliffe, Gumby)

$270K left

 

[September 27 2008]

Re: Rate My SuperCoach team IV

Just wanted to put a smile on ur face UI, and looks like ive done that
It was either Cooney or Ball and then your advice cam in to my head.

Do you think I should trade off
Shaw, Trengrove and John Brown

for either Waite, NDS and M Motlop/T Walker
or Malceski, NDS, A Davey?
or leave as is?

Hands down Cooney. Interrupted 2009 preseason. In 2008 he averaged 107. In 2009 his efficiency was the only reason he didn't average the same. He averaged more possessions in less time on ground compared with his Brownlow year.

IMO Luke Ball is more of a DT player due to his shite efficiency. He has moved to a team with just as many mid options as St.Kilda. More time on ground = more points, but maybe also = more clangers. Also he hasn't averaged 100 since 2005

Cooney will average alot more than Ball in 2010. And he's only 27K more. Alot safer selection IMO

Edit: And Cooney is a keeper, Ball is not

 

[Unknown Identity]

Re: Rate My SuperCoach team IV

Hands down Cooney. Interrupted 2009 preseason. In 2008 he averaged 107. In 2009 his efficiency was the only reason he didn't average the same. He averaged more possessions in less time on ground compared with his Brownlow year.

IMO Luke Ball is more of a DT player due to his shite efficiency. He has moved to a team with just as many mid options as St.Kilda. More time on ground = more points, but maybe also = more clangers. Also he hasn't averaged 100 since 2005

Cooney will average alot more than Ball in 2010. And he's only 27K more. Alot safer selection IMO

Luke Ball averages a point for every minute he is on the ground over his entire career. More game time means more points.

He has also been allowed to drift forward and kick goals with collingwood's game structure. Something he has not done at St Kilda in previous years.

Kicked 6 goals from his last 3 NAB challenge games i believe.
Only kicked 3 goals the entire season in 09.

I think Ball has more room for improvement than what Cooney does in SC scoring.

 

[PatrickBateman]

Re: Rate My SuperCoach team IV

Ok second crack at my team.

Backs: Goddard, Enright, Hodge, Gram, Malceski, Waters, Webberley, Nason.

Mids: Ablett, Gibbs, Cooney, Ball, Martin, McVeigh, Barlow, Banner.

Rucks: Sandilands, Nicnat, Warnock, Lobbe

Fwds: Riewoldt, Hall, O'Keefe, Medhurst, Rockliff, Ziebell, Dangerfield, Gumbleton, Hitchcock. (Pods in for Gumbleton if he's elevated).

Feedback and a rating would be much appreciated brothers.

I don't like Ball in SC, you're better off going for players who can score well from minimal possessions. Ball handballs a lot and is not a good kick... at all. He'd require 5+ tackles I'd say to really post a good score. Better value elsewhere.

 

[Ranga84]

Re: Rate My SuperCoach team IV

I agree ball not so great in SC.

 

[September 27 2008]

Re: Rate My SuperCoach team IV

Still hasn't swayed me. SC is all about efficiency. Ball's has been on a steady decline for a number of years. Cooney's numbers were also down last year compared to 2008 because both years he had 29 scoring shots, just that he kicked 14 goals 15 behinds compared with 23 goals 6 behinds in 2008. Cooney's efficiency last year was his worst in 5 years, but his possession count has increased each of the last 5 years. If he lifts his efficiency slightly, Cooney is a keeper at worst. If it jumps in a big way, coupled with more goals, Cooney is elite

 

[mitchell12345]

Re: Rate My SuperCoach team IV

thoughts!!!!


god enright shaw hodge mal hunt waters
maguire nason

abblett pendles mitchell cooon martin barlow
banner shuey

sandi hille
warnock lobbe/roughy

roo okeefe pav hall danger medders rockliff
hitchy pods

 

[N1k0s287]

Re: Rate My SuperCoach team IV

Backs: Goddard, Enirght, Shaw, Hodge, Kennely, Greenwood, Waters (Mcguire, Davis)
Mids: Gablett, Swan,NDL, Wells,Martin, Barlow (Shuey,Bastinac)
Rucks:Tippet,Hille (Warnock,Lobbe)
Forwards: Riewoldt,Brown,Harvey,Gray,Hall,Ziebell,Rohan (Rockliff,Hitchcock)

Thoughts please?

 

[T4P]

Re: Rate My SuperCoach team IV

thoughts!!!!


god enright shaw hodge mal hunt waters
maguire nason

abblett pendles mitchell cooon martin barlow
banner shuey

sandi hille
warnock lobbe/roughy

roo okeefe pav hall danger medders rockliff
hitchy pods

Backline missing the 300k mid-priced players - this year is a really tough one to pick them though.
Midfield is solid, although I'd downgrade Mitchell or Cooney or both and upgrade a rookie.
Ruck is good, Hille a risk though
Forwards: Medhurst is a no for my books, in his best season he averaged 82, he is not worth it. Once again I'd downgrade one of your three highest priced players and upgrade a rookie
Pretty good team though

Backs: Goddard, Enirght, Shaw, Hodge, Kennely, Greenwood, Waters (Mcguire, Davis)
Mids: Gablett, Swan,NDL, Wells,Martin, Barlow (Shuey,Bastinac)
Rucks:Tippet,Hille (Warnock,Lobbe)
Forwards: Riewoldt,Brown,Harvey,Gray,Hall,Ziebell,Rohan (Rockliff,Hitchcock)

Thoughts please?

Too many premiums in the backline imo
Wells is risky, pretty good midfield though, maybe downgrade one premium and upgrade one rookie
Rucks are pretty good, Tippett is unreliable though.
Forwards very good, Although I'd dump one of Roo/Brown and upgrade Rohan.



Now please rate mine

Backline: Brendon Goddard, Luke Hodge, Jarrod Harbrow, Joel McDonald, Tadgh Kennelly, Rick Ladson, Ryan Schoenmakers (Davis, Nason)

Midfield: Gary Ablett, Scott Pendlebury, Bernie Vince, Luke Ball, Chris Masten, Dustin Martin (Barlow, Banner)

Rucks: Mitch Clark, Nic Naitanui (Warnock, Lobbe)

Forwards: Matthew Pavlich, Brent Harvey, Shaun Higgins, Barry Hall, Patrick Dangerfield, Jack Ziebell, Chris Mayne (Gumbleton, Roberts)

Please offer opinions on bolded players - I'm unsure about them, and Italisized players means that their spot is dependant on whether they play Round 1 or not.

 

[Agetigers]

Re: Rate My SuperCoach team IV

Backline missing the 300k mid-priced players - this year is a really tough one to pick them though.
Midfield is solid, although I'd downgrade Mitchell or Cooney or both and upgrade a rookie.
Ruck is good, Hille a risk though
Forwards: Medhurst is a no for my books, in his best season he averaged 82, he is not worth it. Once again I'd downgrade one of your three highest priced players and upgrade a rookie
Pretty good team though

Too many premiums in the backline imo
Wells is risky, pretty good midfield though, maybe downgrade one premium and upgrade one rookie
Rucks are pretty good, Tippett is unreliable though.
Forwards very good, Although I'd dump one of Roo/Brown and upgrade Rohan.



Now please rate mine

Backline: Brendon Goddard, Luke Hodge, Jarrod Harbrow, Joel McDonald, Tadgh Kennelly, Rick Ladson, Ryan Schoenmakers (Davis, Nason)

Midfield: Gary Ablett, Scott Pendlebury, Bernie Vince, Luke Ball, Chris Masten, Dustin Martin (Barlow, Banner)

Rucks: Mitch Clark, Nic Naitanui (Warnock, Lobbe)

Forwards: Matthew Pavlich, Brent Harvey, Shaun Higgins, Barry Hall, Patrick Dangerfield, Jack Ziebell, Chris Mayne (Gumbleton, Roberts)

Please offer opinions on bolded players - I'm unsure about them, and Italisized players means that their spot is dependant on whether they play Round 1 or not.

Harbrow- i was considering picking him opted not to, had a breakout yr last yr and im not confident he can repeat.

Mcdonalld- had last yr was terrible.

Clark will be very handy for you
Danger- must have imo
Ziebell- doesnt score that heaavily
Mayne- No idea

 

[Couch Coach]

Re: Rate My SuperCoach team IV

Backs: Goddard, Enirght, Shaw, Hodge, Kennely, Greenwood, Waters (Mcguire, Davis)
Mids: Gablett, Swan,NDL, Wells,Martin, Barlow (Shuey,Bastinac)
Rucks:Tippet,Hille (Warnock,Lobbe)
Forwards: Riewoldt,Brown,Harvey,Gray,Hall,Ziebell,Rohan (Rockliff,Hitchcock)

Thoughts please?

Greenwood Inj. - Toe 2 - 3 weeks

 

[T4P]

Re: Rate My SuperCoach team IV

Harbrow- i was considering picking him opted not to, had a breakout yr last yr and im not confident he can repeat.

Mcdonalld- had last yr was terrible.

Clark will be very handy for you
Danger- must have imo
Ziebell- doesnt score that heaavily
Mayne- No idea

And Ziebell is a second year player.
Only real problem I have with Mayne is consistency
Dangerfield I've heard has been injured recently
McDonald - 2008 averaged over 90, but last year had players taken ahead of him, at Melbourne he will be starting 22 and will probably have a lot of the ball.

Thanks for that I feel a bit safer with Dangerfield and Clark, less safe with Ziebell and McDonald. Perhaps a bit more tweaking

 

[snaggletooth]

Re: Rate My SuperCoach team IV

Thanks for that I feel a bit safer with Dangerfield and Clark, less safe with Ziebell and McDonald. Perhaps a bit more tweaking

- Was thinking the same way

First Post, Any help would be gratefull

Backs
Enright, Hodge, Gram, Malceski, Hunt, Ladson, B Waters,
Maguire, Silvagni

Mids
Ablett, Goddard, Harvey, Cooney, Masten, Jetta
Barlow, Shuey

Ruck
Clark, Natinui,
Warnock, Trengrove

Forwards
Riewoldt, ROK, Pav, Tippert, Hall, Dangerfield, Medhurst
Hitchcock, Rokcliff

$40900 left

 

[Hrvat Hawks]

Re: Rate My SuperCoach team IV

Updated team;

BACKS;

Goodard
Enright
H.Shaw
Gilbee
Urqhart
Hunt
Waters

subs-Macguire,Roberton

MIDS;

Ablett
Vince
Cooney
Ball
Rich
Trengrove

subs-Morabito,L.Jetta

RUCKS;

Tippett
Naitanui

subs-Warnock,Prato

FWDS;

Riewoldt
Harvey
Buddy
Hall
Dangerfield
Walker
Wonaemirri

subs-Dennis-Lane,Tapscott


$21,700 left

 

[September 27 2008]

Re: Rate My SuperCoach team IV

Updated team;

BACKS;

Goodard
Enright
H.Shaw
Gilbee
Urqhart
Hunt
Waters

subs-Macguire,Roberton

MIDS;

Ablett
Vince
Cooney
Ball
Rich
Trengrove

subs-Morabito,L.Jetta

RUCKS;

Tippett
Naitanui

subs-Warnock,Prato

FWDS;

Riewoldt
Harvey
Buddy
Hall
Dangerfield
Walker
Wonaemirri

subs-Dennis-Lane,Tapscott

$21,700 left

Shaw may get the tag which makes him risky. Urqhart is a different selection, which is good, but he's not for mine. Robertson, don't know if he'll play.

Not sure how much improvement Rich has in him this year. Ball more of a DT but at 457K he has appeal

Nice rucks, would upgrade Prato

Buddy suspended round 1. Nice choice with Walker, gets a run in the middle from reports. Not sure on Wonna, will he play round 1. Dennis-Lane, also not sure round 1. Tapscott injured for half the year

 

[Powerade 08]

Re: Rate My SuperCoach team IV

Updated team;

Updated? lol.

I hear Dustin Martin of the Richmond football club has done well in the pre season. Also Barlow of Freo so I would look at both of them. Urqhart is coming along nicely, good pick up. Walker doesn't look at all terribly out of form so theres another good pick, and Tapscott will definitely play 22 games as will Wona.

 

[mclovin32]

Re: Rate My SuperCoach team IV

- Was thinking the same way

First Post, Any help would be gratefull

Backs
Enright, Hodge, Gram, Malceski, Hunt, Ladson, B Waters,
Maguire, Silvagni

Mids
Ablett, Goddard, Harvey, Cooney, Masten, Jetta
Barlow, Shuey

Ruck
Clark, Natinui,
Warnock, Trengrove

Forwards
Riewoldt, ROK, Pav, Tippert, Hall, Dangerfield, Medhurst
Hitchcock, Rokcliff

$40900 left

good team
Backs: first 3 are solid. waters and a must at that price IMO as is malceski going by his pre season. unsure on ladson and hunt as both are returning from big injuries its a bit risky having both, one sould do. i was forced to putting hunt in my team as greenwood is now injured.

Midfields: very solid, although id try offload goddard to the backline for maybe ladson and trade ladson for another rookie and upgrade harvey (i think hes had his day, but thats up to you)

Rucks: Class although id swap trengrove for lobbe so you can use tippett for the MPP

Forwards: very solid no need to change that

hope that helped, heres my team


Backs
Goddard, Enright, Hodge, Gram, Malceski, Hunt, B Waters,
Maguire, Davis

Mids
Dal Santo, Selwood, Bartel, Cooney, Masten, Martin
Barlow, Jetta

Ruck
Tippett, Hille
Warnock, Lobbe

Forwards
Riewoldt, Pav, Higgins, Franklin, Hall, Dangerfield, Rockliff
Hitchcock, Gumbleton

 

[johno_1989]

Re: Rate My SuperCoach team IV

Wouldnt change to much, Good selection of rookies although i would take Gumbleton over Hitchcock. Nicnat is to risky for my liking as there are better guys around the same price and Skipper is injured Maybe warnock instead?

Do you reckon Webberley will play many games? because i wanna pick him up.

Yeah nicnat is worrying me, but not to sure on the other rucks around him either. Gumbleton is looking good, but his injury proneness has me worried. I'll look more into him though. I didn't know skipper was injured? Thought only Taylor went down?

Webberly looks good, an has the body. A few of the tiger fans think he'll play, But come rd 1 an his not named I will drop him.

 

[couchgrinder]

Re: Rate My SuperCoach team IV

B: Enright, Goddard , Hodge, Suban,Ladson,Talia, Schoenmakers, Nason,Maguire

M:Ablett,Jones,Vince,Hill,Ziebell,Martin,Jetta Morabito

R:Sandilands,NicNat,Warnock,Lobbe

Fangerfield,Riewoldt,LeCras,Tippett,Hall,ROK,Gia,Gumbleton,Lynch

 

[mitchell12345]

Re: Rate My SuperCoach team IV

god enright shaw hodge kennely mal hunt
maguire nason

abblett pendles mitchell trengrove martin barlow
banner shuey

sandi hille
warnock roughy

roo okeefe pav franklin hall danger rock
hitchy pods

new tactic trying the 3 rookie mids as barlow and martin are pretty much premiums.

thoughts?????

 

[Dooky]

Re: Rate My SuperCoach team IV

Have hit a bit of a brick wall here, not sue what else I can do...would love the advice guys. Cheers

BACKS

1. Goddard, BPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$613,600
2. Hodge, LPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$485,600
3. Gilbee, LPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$453,500
4. Mackie, APts: 0 Avg: N/A
$421,400
5. Kennelly, TPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$320,700
6. Hunt, JPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$252,300
7. Waters, BPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$151,100
23. Maguire, MPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$114,000
24. Davis, PPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$100,200

MIDFIELD

8. Ablett, GPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$744,200
9. Mitchell, SPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$576,300
10. Watson, JPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$541,000
11. Cooney, APts: 0 Avg: N/A
$484,100
12. Martin, DPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$169,200
13. Barlow, MPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$111,400
25. Banner, MPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$100,200
26. Moles, BPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$89,400

RUCKS

14. Tippett, KPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$425,900
15. Naitanui, NPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$304,900
27. Warnock, RPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$132,200
28. Trengove, JPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$100,200

FORWARDS

16. Riewoldt, NPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$600,500
17. O'Keefe, RPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$576,300
18. Didak, APts: 0 Avg: N/A
$558,600
19. Franklin, LPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$466,700
20. Gray, RPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$449,600
21. Hall, BPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$366,000
22. Hitchcock, CPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$103,400
29. Gumbleton, SPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$100,200
30. Podsiadly, JPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$83,400

 

[PatrickBateman]

Re: Rate My SuperCoach team IV

Have hit a bit of a brick wall here, not sue what else I can do...would love the advice guys. Cheers

BACKS

1. Goddard, BPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$613,600
2. Hodge, LPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$485,600
3. Gilbee, LPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$453,500
4. Mackie, APts: 0 Avg: N/A
$421,400
5. Kennelly, TPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$320,700
6. Hunt, JPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$252,300
7. Waters, BPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$151,100
23. Maguire, MPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$114,000
24. Davis, PPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$100,200

MIDFIELD

8. Ablett, GPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$744,200
9. Mitchell, SPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$576,300
10. Watson, JPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$541,000
11. Cooney, APts: 0 Avg: N/A
$484,100
12. Martin, DPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$169,200
13. Barlow, MPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$111,400
25. Banner, MPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$100,200
26. Moles, BPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$89,400

RUCKS

14. Tippett, KPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$425,900
15. Naitanui, NPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$304,900
27. Warnock, RPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$132,200
28. Trengove, JPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$100,200

FORWARDS

16. Riewoldt, NPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$600,500
17. O'Keefe, RPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$576,300
18. Didak, APts: 0 Avg: N/A
$558,600
19. Franklin, LPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$466,700
20. Gray, RPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$449,600
21. Hall, BPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$366,000
22. Hitchcock, CPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$103,400
29. Gumbleton, SPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$100,200
30. Podsiadly, JPts: 0 Avg: N/A
$83,400

I think there's better value than Watson for 540k. The brownlow(although probably not deserved) has gotten Cooney a heavy tag every week since, and his performances are lacking because of it. Maybe reconsider.

Bring more $$ into your midfield, it's a little light considering the wealth of scorers available. Upgrade Watson to an elite and get rid of Didak. If Didak gets tagged at all he'll score nothing, which has been shown time and time again since his purple patch mid-season '09. Can't handle tags.

Rucks are a little light. Tippet not a good option, will score inconsistently at FF. I would bring in Hille and either McIntosh or Jolly for Naitanui.