![](https://images.bigfootymedia.com/icons/mobile-bullets/fremantle.png)
Nothing
Brownlow Medallist
- Jul 30, 2009
- 10,047
- 16,875
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
I can't remember whether sleeping on the park bench was considered a modkill or we assume that TGB was killed.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Round 24
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
Or someone slept at her place last night?
You need to be invited and then you can choose to stay in the house. If you're not invited you can't stay. You need them to be home too, so you can't invite someone then stay at the hotel.
there is no control over who stays at the hotelThat too - im still not really sure how that mechanic works. If someone has to invite you in, are people just inviting random others in, and then if you aren't home and someone attacks you, are you attacked or your house?
I missed where Raz confirmed this. What's the advantage of having someone in your home or going to another? The hotel where multiples can be protected by the Patrol seems like the only useful place to stay at night. Or am I missing something?
What were you doing in the cells in the first place?I spotted the shiny object in the cells but rather than break into grab it or to head directly home I chose to inform the village.
Two clues pointing right at CursingFijian . What say you?
This is phenomenal work. If you're evil and have purposefully left off a clue from someone in your faction ... well, I'm not going to do anything about it, but I won't be impressed. Well, I'll be impressed, I won't be amused. Actually, kind of amused, but I'll still be dirty about it.So what clues have we got
jmoo killed in hotel - sliced and diced, methodical, madman
IMS arrested - jmoo and IMS friends - drank in the hotel all day
SaltnVinegar appears confirmed red herring from the chapter two post
TGB froze to death for trying to sleep somewhere not in the rules - seems modkill
DP cried out for the lawyer and said she was innocent
Chippy said he never lies and was the sheriff
photos of kurve chanting and dancing by the fire to indicate billabong club - looks like another red herring
kurve looks to have been killed by both factions? shot and stabbed
the hooded person who found the note in the alley outside the hotel yesterday also went and got a shiny object from the gaol, kurve was killed with a shiny knife, does that make the hooded person a member of the billabong club?
beasty lawyer card found at scene of death, tip off from foreign accent
a note that was meant to be in the mine found at kurves house
dank went to the mine and looks to have been tracked/seered
mp slept at the mine
i tried to sleep at the mine but ended up sleeping at home, so I think TBG was definitely mod killed for going outside the rules
Is it possible TheGoatBaron wasn't modkilled, but tried to kill the Psychotic Partner and was killed in retribution? Natural causes probably suggests not though.especially when it looks like there was only one kill night one but two last night
Yeah I don’t think I was seered, there was no need.Dank looks to have been tracked/seered = Where do you get that from?
Excuse me, I take offence at "poor and defenseless" thank you very much.This is phenomenal work. If you're evil and have purposefully left off a clue from someone in your faction ... well, I'm not going to do anything about it, but I won't be impressed. Well, I'll be impressed, I won't be amused. Actually, kind of amused, but I'll still be dirty about it.
Here are my thoughts around that:
I'm not sure this is super helpful, but I think we've gotta delve into the clues as much as possible to get any sort of info.
- jmoo killed at the hotel = means the Town Patrol wasn't there (which has been confirmed in-thread)
- Sliced and diced, methodical, madman = If we agree Salt'n'Vinegar was a red herring, then this must be a clue. I'm not sure if CursingFijian fits and think it points to me the most (if we're just basing it on usernames). Not sure on the sliced and diced part though.
- IMS and jmoo drank in the hotel all day = IMS had also booked to stay at the hotel that night before being arrested
- Salt'n'Vinegar = Red Herring
- TGB freezing to death = Modkill (to be honest, I'm still not convinced on that)
- DP cried out to the lawyer = DP was a member of the Bunyip team
- Chippy never lies = Confirmation he was the Sheriff
- Photos of Kurve dancing = I originally thought it was a sign she was part of the Billabong, but considering she was killed twice, that's obviously not the case.
- Hooded person in the alley = I didn't read that part at all, but I assumed all the Billabong crew get about in hoods (as it's a cult) and that confirms that they killed Kurve. I think Raz might be setting clues up on one night for the next night's death.
- Shiny thing in the cell = As above ... OR ... it's indicating that whoever killed Kurve had spent time in the jail. Which would be IMS. Worth pursuing.
- Beasty lawyer card = feels like a red herring because it's a bit obvious to be a clue BUT the way I read the OP is that only the Bunyips leave red herrings. So either BEaston is the lawyer and the Billabong crew leave red herrings as well, or that's a bit of a setup of poor, defenceless, simple-minded BEaston*.
- A note at the Mine was found at Kurve's house = Could mean that one of Kurve's killers had slept at the mine the night before. I think it's too obvious for it to have been MP who was sleeping at the mine last night (or this morning, more likely).
- Dank looks to have been tracked/seered = Where do you get that from?
- MP slept at the mine = No-one else could have, so someone might have claimed that?
* Haha - who doesn't like a good old BEaston drive-by, huh?
Is it possible TheGoatBaron wasn't modkilled, but tried to kill the Psychotic Partner and was killed in retribution? Natural causes probably suggests not though.
So who do we think missed a kill - Bunyips or Billabongs?
I agree I think it boils down to whether the clues are left during the night and found that night or left the night before and found the night after but these points seem like one is likely to be trueI think Raz might be setting clues up on one night for the next night's death.
- Shiny thing in the cell = As above ... OR ... it's indicating that whoever killed Kurve had spent time in the jail. Which would be IMS. Worth pursuing.
- A note at the Mine was found at Kurve's house = Could mean that one of Kurve's killers had slept at the mine the night before. I think it's too obvious for it to have been MP who was sleeping at the mine last night (or this morning, more likely).
- MP slept at the mine = No-one else could have, so someone might have
He disappeared off the radar as well!All the individual letters of weirdo can be found in thewizardmelon.
Just saying.
From memory a lot of us voted Chip based on Kurve's theory which has proven to be a red herring and I reckon a lot voted DP just because she was banned?prior to manipulation
DP 5
Chip 4
CF 2
Wiz 1
The only bit is that most likely one of you, me or porps was manipulated onto Chip to make it a tie (or 1 of the 5 on DP was manipulated off onto someone else). If the write up didn't indicate DP was Bunyip, I'd have thought it was their tribe trying to save DP.From memory a lot of us voted Chip based on Kurve's theory which has proven to be a red herring and I reckon a lot voted DP just because she was banned?
Hard to gather a lot from that
can't save DP going to die anywayThe only bit is that most likely one of you, me or porps was manipulated onto Chip to make it a tie (or 1 of the 5 on DP was manipulated off onto someone else). If the write up didn't indicate DP was Bunyip, I'd have thought it was their tribe trying to save DP.