Rookie wish list??

Remove this Banner Ad

Stupid stupid call.
Hislop is a dud of the highest order.


What happened to the players that can kick mantra.

I'm emailing the club to tell them they are wasting resources!

Craig Cameron is a fool.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

PS3 Richmond Bachar Houli - Essendon
R11 Richmond Ben Jakobi - Coburg
R28 Richmond Brad Miller - Melbourne
R45 Richmond Tom Hislop - Richmond
R60 Richmond Passed

Geez, what a terrible RD. Miller and Hislop are pretty much guaranteed failures. Plenty of kids around that mark have turned into quality long-term players nearly on a yearly basis. "Only the Rookie list" is not really an excuse.
 
C'mon, he really hasn't had an opportunity over the many years at AFL level to prove himself!!!! :rolleyes:
____________________________________________

Hislop is a worse kick that 75% of the VFL players.
He'd be in the bottom 5% of kicks in the AFL.

Tough but nothing else, therefore a waste of space.

Certain delisting in 12 months time.
 
Geez, what a terrible RD. Miller and Hislop are pretty much guaranteed failures. Plenty of kids around that mark have turned into quality long-term players nearly on a yearly basis. "Only the Rookie list" is not really an excuse.

Agreed. Hislop will on past form has given every sign that he will never be a good flanker, midfielder, wingman or backman.

A Barden would have at least given some potential upside.

Pretty disappointed actually
 
Remember people, we can still Rookie list a player up until the end of the NAB Cup Grand Final. Basically we get a free trial period. So we may still yet get a young gun on our Rookie list.
Read paragraph 6 of this article: http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/rookie-age-rule-change-20100820-1395q.html

did not know that. Presumably hawks will use that to select Travis Tuck, whom they overlooked.

I presume that there is no hierarchy for selections though...
 
This drafting period has left me seriously un-motivated re the RFC going forward. It's one thing to be dicked by the AFL but to have it happen by our own recruiters..... once again:mad:
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Passing is criminal, considering there were just under 30 rookie upgrades recently. Surely there was someone worth the risk at our second pick?
 
According to Emma Qwayle we passed so that we could take part in the "Training Draft".

Which gives us until the end of the NAB cup 2011 to rookie a player onto our list.
 
According to Emma Qwayle we passed so that we could take part in the "Training Draft".

Which gives us until the end of the NAB cup 2011 to rookie a player onto our list.

Apparently we added Travis Casserly to our training squad

@AFL_JenWitham Jennifer Witham


RT Correction: Travis Casserly added to Tigers' training squad, Travis Tuck & Paul Johnson to Hawks'. Can be rookied after NAB Cup #afldraft
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Rookie wish list??

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top