Ross Lyon - Rolling the dice?

[TownleyTime]

2 more recycled players in Gamble & Polo.

Has Ross learnt from the recruiting failures of last season?

 

[Ice-Wolf]

2 more recycled players in Gamble & Polo.

Has Ross learnt from the recruiting failures of last season?

Yeah not to use his 1st round pick on them

 

[Dick johnson]

2 more recycled players in Gamble & Polo.

Has Ross learnt from the recruiting failures of last season?

He's also had great success in schneider, gardiner, king and to a lesser extent ray

 

[Wooljay]

Polo is a brave choice by Lyon. Eddy must be feeling like crap right now.

 

[Gavin Excell]

The Peake experiment, Jesse Smith, Charlier Gardiner.

Its brave stuff.

 

[Ice-Wolf]

The Peake experiment, Jesse Smith, Charlier Gardiner.

Its brave stuff.

All taken with late picks and Peake has been quite servicable.

 

[Rustin Cohle]

Something makes me think TownleyTime is a The Panther alias.

 

[Scham]

One of the first things he said post GF was we need some class.

He stayed out of trade week and now looking at his picks today...I'm not so sure that's what he's got???

 

[sainter35]

The Peake experiment, Jesse Smith, Charlier Gardiner.

Its brave stuff.

Who did we give up for any of those "brave" picks?

Charlie G - Cats threw him in for the King deal and pick 90????
J Smith - pick 60
Peake?

I find it best to troll WITH a point.

 

[rose jam]

Recycled players are players that get delisted, not traded ones.

 

[The New Breid]

Eddy out, Polo in.

Umm....

 

[StringyDog]

All taken with late picks and Peake has been quite servicable.

Hepretty much directly cost Saints a flag in the first grand final this year with his pin point passing to Collingwood players....

 

[sainter35]

One of the first things he said post GF was we need some class.

He stayed out of trade week and now looking at his picks today...I'm not so sure that's what he's got???

all rated inside top 50 phantom draft?

you must have a crystal ball.

Ive got one - we'll still belt Freo next year and you'll still have that shyte song with your captain claiming its "wharfie time"...FFS...

 

[John Bonney]

He cannot help himself recycling everybody elses garbage,it is like a fetish with him.

 

[Gavin Excell]

All taken with late picks and Peake has been quite servicable.

If you are bottom 8 then yes Peake would be serviceable. But if you are shooting for the flag players like peake are liabilities. Need to accept that.

 

[sainter35]

I didn't realise you could score 13 points and 57 points with one kick?

I didnt realise you could take semantics to a new level of stupidity - nice work

 

[krisholio14]

St Kilda need a mid sized forward, and Ryan Gamble fits the bill.

He's got plenty of ability, but didn't work hard enough with us.

He'll get every opportunity at the Saints to cement his place if he does the hard yards, and he certainly fills a need St Kilda have, so it's a smart pick by them if you ask me.

Polo i'm not sure about though.

 

[sainter35]

If you are bottom 8 then yes Peake would be serviceable. But if you are shooting for the flag players like peake are liabilities. Need to accept that.

Every side has players that are "serviceable" - see Tom Hawkins/Mooney.

You need to learn they arent all stars.

 

[Gravyman]

Snake eyes rossy.

 

[sainter35]

St Kilda need a mid sized forward, and Ryan Gamble fits the bill.

He's got plenty of ability, but didn't work hard enough with us.

He'll get every opportunity at the Saints to cement his place if he does the hard yards, and he certainly fills a need St Kilda have, so it's a smart pick by them if you ask me.

Polo i'm not sure about though.

Spoke to a few non trolling cats mates who rate this guy - I know little bout him but if he can jag a goal as a mid sized fwd...means Goddard dont have to do it.....nice work Ross.... AGAIN.

 

[sainter35]

Snake eyes rossy.

Hes watching you...

 

[TBoyleSuperstar]

St Kilda need a mid sized forward, and Ryan Gamble fits the bill.

He's got plenty of ability, but didn't work hard enough with us.

He'll get every opportunity at the Saints to cement his place if he does the hard yards, and he certainly fills a need St Kilda have, so it's a smart pick by them if you ask me.

Polo i'm not sure about though.

I think the Gamble pick is quite a good one for them but the Polo one seems diabolical. Surely they could have found a decent kid at pick 103 rather than him. Not sure where he would fit in at St Kilda.

 

[Gavin Excell]

Every side has players that are "serviceable" - see Tom Hawkins/Mooney.

You need to learn they arent all stars.

So wihout having a go, or point scoring or anything like that - can you genuinely say you think that the Gamble and Polo pick ups are a positive and will improve the team?

 

[Invigoration]

I didnt realise you could take semantics to a new level of stupidity - nice work

Stupidity would be implying Ross Lyon lost two grand finals by under a kick when his average losing margin in GFs is over 5 goals.

 

[John Bonney]

Every side has players that are "serviceable" - see Tom Hawkins/Mooney.

You need to learn they arent all stars.

If you rate Hawkins and Mooney as ''serviceable'' then how do you rate Gamble who couldn't get a game behind them?