Round 1 Discussion

[Yoda_]

Only disappointments really are Charlie Dixon (22) and Ben Kennedy (23).

Jarryd McVeigh with 82 might hurt myself but most on here more than likely have him to.

Happy with the late minute Laidler (95) in.

992/9

Kade Simpson
Jared Polec
Tom Clurey (bench)
Jarman Impey (bench)

playing tonight

 

[TheOz]

Funny, I was doing the reverse.

I wanted a bit more stability and reliability in the back line so I ended up selecting Enright instead of Swallow.

My score is 8/992 ATM C played.
Mcdonough and Mcveigh are my let downs.

Westhoff and Polec for me today.

As I have the 4-0-6 midfield my other lines are pretty strong.

Can understand the thought process behind Enright and he's probably one of the safest backline picks there is. Swallow wont score 135 every week, personally will be very happy if he averages 95 for the season off of 22 games. Had him locked in for a couple of months now so glad I didn't make last minute rash decisions by taking him out.

I think McDonough will get better, did some ok things out there, hoping so anyway. McVeigh can throw in an odd 80 odd game but can also go pretty big so wouldn't write him off at all, was a pretty crap day for his style of game and will still finish top 6 defenders this season.

 

[Yoda_]

McVeigh can throw in an odd 80 odd game but can also go pretty big so wouldn't write him off at all, was a pretty crap day for his style of game and will still finish top 6 defenders this season.

Hopefully most people will realise this and stick with him and not make rash decisions because he had one below par game.

82 will still be better than 70% of the defenders available so eryone needs to stay patient.

 

[Super Hans]

I also went for Enright over Swallow, just for consistency reasons. Swallow looked great last night but the real story will be told around 8-9 though.

 

[TheOz]

Hopefully most people will realise this and stick with him and not make rash decisions because he had one below par game.

82 will still be better than 70% of the defenders available so eryone needs to stay patient.

In fact he had one of the worst games I've seen him play for a long time, his clanger from full back when he went the torp and totally fluffed it which resulted in GWS kicking the sealer would have cost him a fair amount of points, he shanked alot of shortish kicks and wasn't really sighted in the last quarter. 82 off of a crap game including the critical turnover is a score you would take.

 

[Satan]

should i play clurey or mcdonald? if mcdonald does not play i get langdons score

 

[Yoda_]

In fact he had one of the worst games I've seen him play for a long time, his clanger from full back when he went the torp and totally fluffed it which resulted in GWS kicking the sealer would have cost him a fair amount of points, he shanked alot of shortish kicks and wasn't really sighted in the last quarter. 82 off of a crap game including the critical turnover is a score you would take.

Yep, totally agree.

 

[Double the Fist]

Did Tmitchel get downgraded to 93 overnight SC scores? I thought he got over 100

 

[TheOz]

Did Tmitchel get downgraded to 93 overnight SC scores? I thought he got over 100

All the swans were scaled down coz they ended up losing what was a tight game except for the last few minutes

 

[Cevap_Roll]

8/1013 GAJ Captain.

Lowest score was Griffiths really dissapointed Dimma vested him. Would have scored 80+ had he played a full game.
Worried it may happen again

 

[timtamWB]

Judd_Magic I blame you for McDonough

Also realised that I didn't have Parker, I traded him out for Walters a couple weeks ago

739/7 so far, but that's not including Mumford's score or Beams as my captain. I'm very happy so far, Walters and McDonough my weak links with 65 and 45 respectively.

Also I told you all about Swallow

 

[joop]

7 players for 802.

Could murder Cloke (35) and Rohan (47)

Simpson
Murphy
Daisy
Polec
Wingard

All playing today, want 100 out of each.

 

[Amazing Bombers]

I also went for Enright over Swallow, just for consistency reasons. Swallow looked great last night but the real story will be told around 8-9 though.

Same, i'll back Enright in should average 90+ easy.

 

[Double the Fist]

7 players for 802.

Could murder Cloke (35) and Rohan (47)

Simpson
Murphy
Daisy
Polec
Wingard

All playing today, want 100 out of each.

Forgot I had Polec.
Simpson is the other. At least the game is still relevant too me from a SC perspective

 

[Lachy Jamison]

Forgot I had Polec.
Simpson is the other. At least the game is still relevant too me from a SC perspective

Polec the only for myself. Was going to have Simpson but requires me to chuck either Mitchell or Enright though.

 

[Double the Fist]

Murphy to get a hard Cornes tag?

 

[TheOz]

Murphy to get a hard Cornes tag?

He did last year and murdered him in the last quarter of that game. Kornes has been tagging him since 2011, his last three scores against port have been 130, 130, 127. Call me biased but a fit Murphy is a top 5 midfielder of the comp and should get back to a 110+ avg.

 

[Double the Fist]

Polec the only for myself. Was going to have Simpson but requires me to chuck either Mitchell or Enright though.

Enrights age concerns me.

 

[TheOz]

Enrights age concerns me.

He's only 11 months older than Mitchell

 

[Double the Fist]

He did last year and murdered him in the last quarter of that game. Kornes has been tagging him since 2011, his last three scores against port have been 130, 130, 127. Call me biased but a fit Murphy is a top 5 midfielder of the comp and should get back to a 110+ avg.

Gee. Didn't expect those numbers.....

 

[Double the Fist]

He's only 11 months older than Mitchell

Not being rude, but thats a fair bit in footy terms IMO. Mitchells age also concerns me. My OWN bloody age concerns me....

 

[TheOz]

Gee. Didn't expect those numbers.....

He has averaged over 111 for 4 years straight before last season where he played almost the whole year through injury, including 118 in 2011. He is priced at 92 this year, it's a bigger bargain than Beams imo.

 

[Double the Fist]

He has averaged over 111 for 4 years straight before last season where he played almost the whole year through injury, including 118 in 2011. He is priced at 92 this year, it's a bigger bargain than Beams imo.

Had Murhph, but swapped for Cotch.

 

[TheOz]

Had Murhph, but swapped for Cotch.

Cotch is underpriced too this year, if his DE% was half decent he would have scored the same as Ablett.

 

[Mad Sainter]

He did last year and murdered him in the last quarter of that game. Kornes has been tagging him since 2011, his last three scores against port have been 130, 130, 127. Call me biased but a fit Murphy is a top 5 midfielder of the comp and should get back to a 110+ avg.

biased, I'll name 5 who are better
in fact I'll name 10

GAJ, Pendles, Selwood, Beams, Dangerfield, Swan, SJ, Griffen, Watson, Rockliff