Round 1 Discussion

[Better Loosen Up]

I got the Holman one right and I'd love to be able to help you but unfortunately I ****** up my VC choices as I had Fyfe, so I'll make you a deal...I'll tell you which Rookie to play if you tell me who to play as Captain.

Ablett
Gawn
Franklin
Kelly

I'd go with Gawn

 

[fuic08]

Have only just realised I have the E on Holman and not Banfield to cover Dangers C donut. Dees game is a big one with 4 players on field.

 

[JuddgementDay]

Bloody hell ......who to play on-field ....Naughton or Finlayson ?? .....HELP !!

You've paid good $$$ for Naughton, might as well give him a chance to play first
That's what I'm doing
But, again it is just a guess at this stage look at Dow and LDU

 

[WaynesWorld19]

I got the Holman one right and I'd love to be able to help you but unfortunately I ****** up my VC choices as I had Fyfe, so I'll make you a deal...I'll tell you which Rookie to play if you tell me who to play as Captain.

Ablett
Gawn
Franklin
Kelly

Ablett ....no match practice, playing a good side @ 34
Gawn .....possible, but no ruck has dominated so far, & 2 top one's injured
Franklin ....playing in Perth ? ...he's always a boom bust risk
Kelly .....playing home ground, Bulldogs

 

[Cold Sober]

For those of us blind drunk yesterday and missed Footy what the hell is going on with Fyfe .. 75 ??

Nothing a hot poker up his arse wouldn't fix.

 

[TurtleKid]

I'd go with Gawn

Isn't it going to rain at the G today? Might affect Gawn.
I'd go Kelly

 

[Jiska]

Isn't it going to rain at the G today? Might affect Gawn

Yeah because Goldy struggled in the first half during torrential rain. I mean, there’s not many stoppages in wet weather

 

[Better Loosen Up]

Isn't it going to rain at the G today? Might affect Gawn.
I'd go Kelly

Kelly a good option too but will be sharing points with Cogs, Sheil, Whitfield etc. Kelly's scores were great last year but there was often at least 2 guns missing from the team each week. Who knows what impact that will make.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

You've paid good $$$ for Naughton, might as well give him a chance to play first
That's what I'm doing
But, again it is just a guess at this stage look at Dow and LDU

Really torn, both teams playing each other ....Naughton will have some big bodied GWS talls to mind .....Finlayson mature 22 yo in a side that should win ? ......urghhh

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Finlayson I reckon

Are you having a good R1 ?

 

[Jiska]

Really torn, both teams playing each other ....Naughton will have some big bodied GWS talls to mind .....Finlayson mature 22 yo in a side that should win ? ......urghhh

I’m fielding both.

 

[TurtleKid]

Yeah baby!

I'm tempted after old man simpsons game ... but nah
Looking forward to your melt when finlayson takes all his points

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Kelly a good option too but will be sharing points with Cogs, Sheil, Whitfield etc. Kelly's scores were great last year but there was often at least 2 guns missing from the team each week. Who knows what impact that will make.

Didn't affect Kelly last year .....his worst score for the year, a 88 .....best 177

GWS should win today

 

[WaynesWorld19]

I’m fielding both.

That doesn't help me

 

[enobrien]

Doedee and Murray on my field, and lastly going Finlayson over Naughton.

75 and over and it is a successful round of fielding rookies! Premos on the other hand..

Beams - wake up
Fyfe - WTF r u doing
Lambert - U got next week mate

 

[Changa10]

For those of us blind drunk yesterday and missed Footy what the hell is going on with Fyfe .. 75 ??

Most likely Ross ****ing Lyon!

 

[Better Loosen Up]

Didn't affect Kelly last year .....his worst score for the year, a 88 .....best 177

GWS should win today

I think you've missed my point

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Doedee and Murray on my field, and lastly going Finlayson over Naughton.

75 and over and it is a successful round of fielding rookies! Premos on the other hand..

Beams - wake up
Fyfe - WTF r u doing
Lambert - U got next week mate

Rationale ?

 

[ArdentEagle]

Ablett ....no match practice, playing a good side @ 34
Gawn .....possible, but no ruck has dominated so far, & 2 top one's injured
Franklin ....playing in Perth ? ...he's always a boom bust risk
Kelly .....playing home ground, Bulldogs

Thanks mate..Very sound logic.
It's a hard one as it wouldn't surprise me if GAJ rattled a huge one in his first game back, I expect Gawn to be "safe 110 bet", Kelly is juicy but I can't see him getting 140ish but with Gawn I think it's possible.

Franklin could go huge but man it'd take some huge cojones to pick him.

In regards to your question, for me, Naughton is the safer bet...But Finlayson has the higher ceiling potential.
I'm going Naughton FWIW but the again I stuffed up my VC choice.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

14 of my 30 players are playing today. Big day. Today could be the end of my season, or the start of it, depending which way it goes.

I've got 16

 

[Sir Hugh Percy]

1191/10(c) and it appears I'm lagging behind on players played thus far - maybe I have some pods?

Gawn, Hibberd, Petracca, Zuthrie

Cogs, Punchable, Bont, Dahl, Naughty

Heeney, NicNat, Ryan

 

[WaynesWorld19]

I think you've missed my point

IIRC it was a concern over point sharing .....don't think it's an issue ....it hasn't stopped Coaches selecting Danger, or Buddy ....champions will still dominate

 

[King_Steele]

I'm tempted after old man simpsons game ... but nah
Looking forward to your melt when finlayson takes all his points

It was either him or Burton.

#alreadywinning

 

[markm106]

1640 with 7 to go. Dusty captain. Gawn Fritsch Heeney Dunkley Hibberd Petracca Coniglio to play.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Nothing a hot poker up his arse wouldn't fix.

Yeah but will it fit along side the other one